Arch Manning is stepping into the 2026 season with a wave of momentum from last year's finish, yet he's not universally seen as a top-five quarterback talent. In Bleacher Report’s ranking of College Football’s Top 25 QBs for 2026, after considering transfers and eligibility changes, Manning is slotted at No. 6.
This ranking might raise a few eyebrows, especially since Manning is the early favorite for the Heisman Trophy. With a name that echoes through college football history, many expected him to be leading the pack for 2026.
So, who edged out Manning?
At the top of the list is Ohio State's Julian Sayin, a Heisman finalist from last year who aims to maintain his stellar performance. Following him is Ole Miss' Trinidad Chambliss, who had to secure a court order to play in 2026.
Oregon’s Dante Moore takes the third spot after deciding to delay his NFL entry. Miami’s Darian Mensah is fourth, stepping in for the departed Carson Beck.
Rounding out the top five is LSU’s Sam Leavitt, entering his first season under Lane Kiffin in Baton Rouge.
Why is Manning just outside the elite tier in this ranking?
His 2025 season started off rocky, which cooled some of the preseason excitement around him. Although he finished strong, showcasing improved performance, it wasn't enough to leapfrog other quarterbacks who demonstrated more consistency or impact throughout the entire season.
Additionally, the quarterback field for 2026 is notably deep. With dynamic returners and impactful transfers like Sayin, Chambliss, and Moore, the competition is fierce. Evaluators may also factor in the surrounding talent, offensive systems, and projected development, which all play a role in shaping preseason rankings.
It's also important to remember that no two ranking systems are identical at this stage. Other outlets and draft boards might rank Manning higher, but Bleacher Report is taking a cautious approach for now.
Manning has a solid supporting cast in Austin this year, and he’ll have plenty of chances to make his mark early on. A Week 2 showdown with Ohio State promises to be a spectacle, with both Sayin and Manning expected to light up the field, all under the watchful eyes of several NFL scouts.