Texas is 4-0, sitting at No. 1 and already has two wins that will define the early part of the season: a home stand against then-No. 1 Ohio State and a road escape at Tennessee. On the surface, that puts Arch Manning exactly where a quarterback at Texas is supposed to be - in the middle of a perfect start, with his team winning big when it matters.
But the deeper read on Manning is more complicated.
The Longhorns’ defense has been the steadier force. First-year coordinator Will Muschamp has Texas giving up just 13.2 points per game, a mark tied for the fewest allowed in the SEC. That total is helped by a 59-7 rout of Texas State and a 30-6 win over UTSA, but even after accounting for those lopsided results, holding Ohio State and Tennessee to 40 points combined is the kind of outcome Steve Sarkisian will gladly live with.
Manning, meanwhile, has had flashes without stacking up the kind of résumé that screams Heisman front-runner. His comeback effort against Ohio State gave Texas a potential signature moment, but beyond that, the big plays have been more scattered than sustained. He has not been near the top of any major passing category, and his 141.4 passer rating is solid without being enough to force his way into Heisman talk.
That matters because there’s a clearer comparison sitting right there in college football right now. Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss has a 156.3 passer rating and has already delivered Heisman-type outings against Louisville and LSU, including four touchdown passes against the Cardinals and three against the Tigers.
Still, Texas is undefeated, and that’s the only scoreboard the Longhorns are focused on. The Heisman isn’t awarded for team record, and the program isn’t chasing that trophy anyway. Sarkisian and company would take no Heisman finalists if it meant a deep CFP run.
Manning’s own evaluation depends on what standard you’re using. If the question is whether he looked perfect against UTSA, he didn’t.
He was willing to say as much. He has also been slow at times to sort through defenses, and teams have not always paid for it the way many expected.
But if the question is whether he has delivered when Texas needed him most, the answer is yes. No quarterback has authored a more dramatic comeback than his fourth quarter against Ohio State, and he has already guided Texas through two one-score games against top-15 opponents.
Texas has not needed him to be a one-man wrecking crew every week. Some games are about the defense.
Some games are about the quarterback taking over. The Longhorns haven’t had a full carry job like the 2025 Mississippi State game, but they have seen Manning stack enough big throws to win the biggest game any team has had so far this season.
So after four games, the record is clean: 4-0, No. 1, and Manning has done what Texas has asked of him.
The bigger question is what that means at the next level. For NFL scouts, the answer is probably less flattering.
Manning has held the ball too long often enough to build a reputation, and that’s the sort of habit that gets punished in the pros. He has taken 10 sacks in four games, including six against Tennessee, and he has thrown an interception in every game except the UTSA win in Week 3, when he also completed just 16 of 32 passes.
For college football, though, the picture looks different. Manning is still a work in progress, and he may need another year in Austin before he’s fully ready to move on. Even so, he has been especially dangerous late: through the first month, he has completed 76.9% of his passes in the fourth quarter with 115 passing yards, one touchdown pass and no turnovers.
That’s where he’s made his strongest case so far. Not as a finished product. As the quarterback Texas has needed.
In Other News...
Hero Kanu Sends Clear Message On Colin Simmons Controversy
The postgame conversation around Colin Simmons did not linger long inside the Texas locker room, at least not if Hero Kanu had anything to say about it. The Longhorns defensive lineman stepped up to defend his teammate after a controversial celebration against Tennessee, framing it as a split-second mistake in the heat of competition rather than anything deeper about who Simmons is away from the field.
Kanus response fit with the broader tone from the program, where Steve Sarkisian has made it clear he would rather see celebrations shared by the whole team than spotlighting one player. For Texas, it is a small but telling reminder of how quickly a moment can become a talking point, and how important it is for teammates to close ranks when the noise starts building around one of their own. [Read more 🡒]
Texas Bye Week Has To Fix One Growing Offensive Concern
Texas heads into the bye week undefeated and sitting at No. 1, but the narrow escape at Tennessee also left a clear reminder that the offense still has room to grow. The Longhorns have won enough to keep climbing, yet they have not consistently stretched defenses the way Steve Sarkisians best attacks usually do, with explosive plays showing up too rarely and big completions or runs hard to find.
Sarkisian now gets a break in the schedule to clean up that side of the ball, and the focus is on execution rather than trimming the playbook to compensate. For a team with championship expectations, the challenge in the next stretch is obvious: keep the wins coming while making the offense more dangerous when it matters most. [Read more 🡒]
Texas Defense Could Expose Oklahoma Where It Hurts Most
Texas heads into the rivalry game with a defense that has earned the right to believe it can make life difficult for Oklahoma in several places at once. The Sooners have had trouble generating steady pressure on the quarterback, their run defense has been uneven, and their offense has not found much rhythm on the ground, which gives the Longhorns a chance to dictate the game with toughness and field position.
The bigger concern for Oklahoma is how often its offense has put itself in precarious spots, especially with John Mateer at the controls. Turnovers have been a recurring issue, and if Texas can keep forcing hurried decisions while also taking away the Sooners already limited rushing answers, the game could tilt quickly toward the Longhorns in a matchup where hidden mistakes tend to matter just as much as headline plays. [Read more 🡒]