There are two Arch Mannings showing up for Texas right now, and the split-screen is getting harder to ignore.
One version looks every bit like the quarterback people have projected for years. That’s the guy who climbed the pocket and reset his feet before firing a 41-yard touchdown to junior wide receiver Cam Coleman on Saturday in the Cotton Bowl. He’s also the one who dropped a 42-yard completion to Coleman right between two defenders, or rifled a 34-yard touchdown strike to junior wide receiver Ryan Wingo down the seam in rhythm and on time.
Then there’s the other version.
That quarterback - the one the source framed as Mr. Swoopes - is the one battling processing issues, shaky pocket sense and accuracy problems.
He’s the one who still looks stuck between whether to run or throw, the one with three illegal forward passes in the last three games. He’s the athlete trying to play quarterback, the one who can float “a duck into the defense on the run that turns into a touchdown back in his face.”
He’s also the one whose footwork falls apart, whose late-game interception came off his back foot and inside to the defender’s leverage instead of harmlessly out of bounds, and whose hesitation in a clean pocket ends with him drifting into the back of his center, closing off his own throwing lanes and taking a sack that leads to a blocked punt touchdown.
On Monday, Texas coach Steve Sarkisian pushed back on the idea that Manning is processing badly.
“I think that he’s processing fine,” Sarkisian said on Monday.
But that naturally raises the bigger question: is “fine” enough for a fourth-year player in his second season as the starter?
Sarkisian didn’t dodge the expectations part.
“I think if you took the name off the back of his jersey, and you said, ‘Here’s Joe Smith playing quarterback at the University of Texas, and here’s a guy who’s beaten four top 10 ranked teams in his last 13 starts,’ we’d be praising the guy, but the expectations are high for him. He understands that the expectations are high for all of us, so we’ve got to we got to put our nose back to the grind and get back to work,” Sarkisian said.
The Sooners game brought both versions into sharp focus. Manning hit three big throws, but the afternoon was also defined by two crushing interceptions that led to 10 points. Sarkisian made clear that’s the part that stings.
“I hate it for him. He has two interceptions in the fourth quarter of that game when, quite frankly, I thought he played pretty good up until that point, and that’s the frustrating part, but that’s the level of consistency that’s needed,” Sarkisian said.
That inconsistency is the heart of the issue. Texas keeps getting flashes of the ceiling, but too often the floor shows up too.
And the problem isn’t only Manning. The coaching side deserves a hard look as well. The source points the finger at Sarkisian, AJ Milwee and Mike Bimonte, arguing that Manning has not developed enough over four years in Austin and that the lack of growth from Quinn Ewers only deepens the concern.
There are also tactical questions. Why hasn’t the game slowed down for Manning?
Why does his footwork still break down? Why does he remain so uneasy in the pocket?
Why does he look so unsure when he has space to run?
One theory is that the myth around Manning got ahead of the reality. His last name led people to assume he’d inherit the football brain and processing of his uncles, along with the talent of the family tree. Instead, the source suggests, he often looks like a gifted athlete being squeezed by a system that has told him not to scramble and rarely gives him designed runs.
The numbers tell part of that story. Last year, Manning ran for 519 yards and 10 touchdowns, including 32 scrambles for 349 yards and 31 designed runs.
This season, he still hasn’t scored a rushing touchdown. Against Oklahoma, three of his five designed runs came in that game alone.
His decision-making seemed to tighten after being reprimanded for scrambling too much in the UTSA game, and that links back to the illegal forward passes piling up.
The passing game hasn’t exactly made life easier. The source says Sarkisian’s play-calling has left Manning without enough hot reads against the blitzes SEC opponents have used, and without the quick-game answers that should be there. The biggest missing piece, it says, is the screen game that used to be so dangerous before Manning took over.
There’s also a clear contrast in how Manning was used from one season to the next. Last year, his average depth of target swung wildly from 20.2 against Florida to four yards against Oklahoma, when Sarkisian leaned into an efficient, game-manager role in a win. This year, the lesson appears to have been forgotten, with Manning’s average depth of target sitting at 10.7 yards on Saturday.
For now, Texas is living with both quarterbacks in one body - the playmaker and the problem, the precision thrower and the hesitant runner. And with a growing sense that Manning and Sarkisian may both be back for a fifth season, the Longhorns may just be stuck with that package deal.
In Other News...
Florida Just Got A Needed Recruiting Boost After That Ugly Loss
Floridas Week 6 loss to South Carolina stung on the field, but the Gators needed something positive quickly and got it on the recruiting trail. Five-star wide receiver Easton Royal, the No. 1 receiver in the 2027 class, flipped his commitment from Texas to Florida shortly after the defeat, giving the program a jolt at a time when the margin for good news felt pretty thin.
Royals decision matters beyond the headline because he is one of the most coveted prospects in the country and is expected to wrap up his recruitment soon. For Texas, it is a notable miss in a class that had been building momentum, while Florida gets a major boost as it tries to steady itself after slipping to 4-2 overall and 2-2 in the SEC. [Read more 🡒]
Texas Has A Discipline Problem Sarkisian Can't Ignore
The loss to Oklahoma brought Texas back to a familiar and frustrating theme: the Longhorns again hurt themselves with flags at the worst possible moments. They were penalized eight times for 61 yards, and the numbers fit the broader concern Steve Sarkisian has been trying to push to the front of the conversation. Even with a modest dip in penalties per game from last season, the Longhorns have not shaken the kind of mistakes that can swing a tight rivalry game.
Sarkisian has already pointed to penalties as the biggest issue the staff has to clean up, and he described the problem as a mix of effort-based plays and mental miscues. That makes the fix harder than simply preaching discipline in practice, because the issue is not coming from one place or one player group. Texas can outplay an opponent in stretches and still leave the door open if it keeps layering avoidable mistakes on top of itself. [Read more 🡒]
Texas Must Fix One Frustrating Problem After Red River Loss
The Red River loss left Texas with more than a blemish in the rivalry column. It also put a spotlight on the kind of offensive inconsistency that has followed the Longhorns at times this season, even with plenty of individual talent on the roster. Senior offensive lineman Trevor Goosby and coach Steve Sarkisian both pointed to the same basic task afterward: put the disappointment behind them and get the unit executing better.
Sarkisian also owned the responsibility for the offenses struggles, a notable admission from a coach who knows the standard in Austin does not leave much room for uneven Saturdays. The Longhorns have shown enough ability to suggest the ceiling is still there, but the next stretch will be about turning that talent into steadier production. For Texas, the frustration is not just the loss itself, but the feeling that the offense still has to prove it can hold up when the stage gets biggest. [Read more 🡒]