Arch Manning and Julian Sayin are heading into Saturday night with the kind of attention that follows a No. 1 recruit, but the first Texas-Ohio State meeting didn’t quite deliver the quarterback fireworks everyone expected.
Last season, Ohio State’s 14-7 win in Columbus was more about defense than star power. Sayin, in his first extended action, threw for 126 yards and a touchdown.
Manning, making his third career start, finished with 170 passing yards, one touchdown and one interception. The hype was there.
The production, not so much.
That’s not the expectation this time around.
Texas coach Steve Sarkisian said the film tells a very different story now.
“You see the level of confidence that both guys are playing with, the presence in the pocket, you notice their confidence to use their legs,” Texas coach Steve Sarkisian said. “You see the trust and timing.
It’s a pretty drastic difference for the two players the second time around going up against one another. It should be pretty high-level quarterback play on Saturday.”
The rematch arrives with both quarterbacks carrying far more polish and responsibility than they had a year ago. And while neither was eager to make a big deal out of the matchup, both gave the kind of understated answers that fit veteran signal-callers.
Sayin said, “I think just having last year’s experience definitely helps you as a quarterback in kind of every aspect of your game.”
Manning kept it even shorter: “A year better.”
Sayin’s rise has been obvious. He completed 77 percent of his passes last season, the third-highest mark in college football history, and finished as a Heisman Trophy finalist. Ohio State coach Ryan Day has praised the way Sayin now runs the offense and commands the huddle, and Day said the 6-foot-1, 214-pound California native has also grown as a leader.
“He gets together with the receivers, the offensive line and talks through things,” Day said.
Manning’s growth has come in a different way. He didn’t put up eye-popping numbers a year ago - he ranked 31st nationally with 243.3 passing yards per game - but he caught fire late. Over his final six games, he threw 14 touchdown passes and only two interceptions, and he enters the season No. 3 on Dane Brugler’s list of top players for the 2027 NFL Draft.
Day sees a quarterback who has become far more dangerous.
“He was playing some really good football at the end of the season and did some good things in the first game of the year, this past Saturday,” Day said. “He can beat you with his legs, beat you downfield, and he can make throws when he needs to. He’s really improved.”
Ohio State defensive end Kenyatta Jackson has seen the same thing.
“He looks more polished than the first game last season,” he said.
The numbers from last year’s meeting explain why Ohio State and Texas both played it close with their young quarterbacks. Day said afterward that he felt he could have asked more of Sayin, who had 20 pass attempts - his fewest in a full game last season - and a 37 percent dropback rate that matched Ohio State’s lowest of the year, according to TruMedia. But the Buckeyes were working with rough field position all game, starting six of 11 drives inside the 20 and five inside the 10.
“We had poor field position to start, so that played into it as well,” Day said. “You have to be aggressive, but you also have to be smart. That’s the balance.”
Ohio State only tried one pass that traveled 15 yards or more downfield, and it turned into a 40-yard touchdown to Carnell Tate, the play that essentially decided the game.
Texas attacked more vertically, with eight throws of at least 15 yards downfield. The Longhorns completed three of them for 90 yards, with one touchdown and one interception. Manning had trouble sorting through Ohio State’s coverage looks, and Sarkisian said the disguise was a major problem.
“I thought their ability to disguise coverages in the first half was at an elite level,” Sarkisian said after the game. “I wouldn’t say a good level - an elite level.”
Even then, Texas still didn’t fully open things up. The Horns had a 50.7 percent dropback rate, their fourth-lowest of the season, because the staff still didn’t want to overload Manning.
“Not a lot of good memories from a year ago,” Manning said. “Hoping to have a good game this year.”
The challenge on Saturday is much bigger than just a rematch of last year’s result. Both quarterbacks have already shown they can produce against elite defenses, but they’ve also shown that those defenses can make life miserable.
Last season, Sayin faced two top-20 defenses - Indiana and Miami - and went 43-for-64 for 545 yards, two touchdowns and three interceptions. Ohio State lost both games.
Manning saw four top-20 defenses and split those games 2-2. Texas lost to Ohio State and Georgia, and beat Oklahoma and Texas A&M. In those four games, he completed 79 of 129 passes for 766 yards, four touchdowns and two interceptions, and he also ran for a score against Texas A&M.
Saturday’s game may come down to the same things it did a year ago, only with better quarterbacks on both sides: third-down execution, pressure, and whether either line can hold up long enough to let the playmakers work.
That’s why the opening performances from both rushing attacks matter, even against overmatched opponents. Texas ran for 156 yards on 36 carries against Texas State. Ohio State piled up 237 yards on 35 attempts against Ball State, though 114 of those yards came on just two runs.
There’s also a clear concern on Ohio State’s right side. The Buckeyes’ right tackle, Phillip Daniels, could be on a short leash after his rough showing against Ball State.
Texas may have the edge there, and if its defensive front can get after Sayin while Manning protects the ball, the Longhorns have a real chance to settle the score. Another key piece: how Manning handles Ohio State’s linebackers. Last year, the Buckeyes kept him to 38 rushing yards on 10 carries, and they’ll need that kind of control again if they want to slow him down.
In Other News...
Arch Manning Faces The Ohio State Test Texas Still Hasn't Passed
The buildup to Texas and Ohio State has the feel of a measuring-stick game, and for the Longhorns it comes with an extra layer of intrigue because they still have not gotten past the Buckeyes in recent seasons. Steve Sarkisian has kept the focus on preparation, knowing the opener will reveal plenty about where his team stands early and how well it can handle the kind of stage that leaves little room for hesitation.
Arch Manning will be at the center of it for Texas, while Ohio State counters with Julian Sayin in a matchup that already carries Heisman Trophy buzz on both sides. For the Longhorns, the challenge is bigger than one quarterback duel or one early-season result. It is about finally breaking through against a program that has kept them waiting and doing it in a game that should say a lot about what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Urban Meyer Sees One Texas Problem In Ohio State Showdown
The No. 4 Longhorns are set to welcome No. 1 Ohio State to Austin in one of those early-season games that instantly feels bigger than the calendar says it is. It is a rare chance for Texas to host the top-ranked team, and the matchup has drawn plenty of attention because both rosters have been upgraded and because the Buckeyes have kept rolling under Ryan Day.
Urban Meyer, who knows Ohio State as well as anyone, offered a blunt read on what Texas will need to make it a game. He sees the Longhorns having a path if their skill positions can stack up with the Buckeyes, but he still leans toward Ohio State overall, which only adds to the intrigue around how Texas matches up when the ball is finally kicked off in Austin. [Read more 🡒]
Ryan Wingo Could Decide Texas' Rematch With Ohio State
Texas passing game will again be under the microscope when it meets Ohio State, and the Longhorns have a receiver group with enough variety to make that matchup interesting. Arch Manning will be operating behind the offense, but the more immediate pressure point may come from the outside, where Ryan Wingo and Cam Coleman have the kind of speed and separation ability that can stress a defense if the structure gives them room to work.
Ohio States new-look approach under Matt Patricia is expected to lean heavily on zone, which puts a premium on receivers who can find soft spots and turn them into chunk plays. That is where Wingo becomes such a fascinating piece for Texas, especially with Sarkisian looking for ways to create advantages against a secondary that will be trying to keep the Longhorns from getting comfortable early. [Read more 🡒]