Arch Manning Faces A Real Test Against A Desperate Florida Defense

The Florida Gators must address recent inconsistencies and brace for the formidable challenges posed by Texas standouts Arch Manning and Colin Simmons to avoid further setbacks.

GAINESVILLE - Florida’s next two weeks may tell the whole story of where this season is headed, and the first test is a brutal one.

The Gators, who surged to a 4-0 start before back-to-back double-digit losses sent them tumbling to 4-2, are heading into a stretch that features No. 7 Texas on Saturday and No.

1 Georgia in Atlanta on Oct. 31.

The mood around the program has already shifted sharply after a sold-out homecoming crowd turned on Florida during a 38-19 loss to South Carolina.

Coach Jon Sumrall didn’t flinch at the reaction.

“They have the right to boo,” Sumrall said. “The thing I love is having freaking passionate, awesome fans.

Why you come to the University of Florida is because people care. I love that our fans care enough to boo.

“I don’t want to applaud when we’re not playing well.”

So now comes the hard part: can Florida steady itself before the season really starts to spiral? Here are the biggest issues facing the Gators against Texas.

Arch Manning has already shown both sides of the coin this season, and Florida is hoping it gets the shaky version. The Texas quarterback lit up Ohio State with a fourth-quarter comeback from a 20-3 deficit, but he was undone a week ago against Oklahoma, throwing three touchdowns and tying the game late before two fourth-quarter interceptions helped sink the Longhorns in a 27-24 loss.

Florida knows Manning well enough to remember what happened in 2025, when the Gators sacked him six times and intercepted him twice in a 29-21 upset. But the Texas star went on to finish 7-1 after that, throwing 20 touchdowns and just two interceptions as the Longhorns missed out on a third straight College Football Playoff berth.

Now Manning gets another shot at a Florida defense that has been vulnerable. He’ll have help, too, with receivers Cam Coleman and Ryan Wingo giving him a dangerous set of targets. Manning also remains a threat as a runner; in last year’s game in the Swamp, he ran for 74 yards on the ground, not counting sacks.

“He’s athletically a little bit different maybe than his uncles,” Sumrall said.

Florida’s defense also has to clean up a problem that has burned it in consecutive losses: the “middle eight.”

Missouri and South Carolina each seized control during the final four minutes of the first half and the opening four minutes of the second, outscoring Florida 24-3 in that window. If a Missouri touchdown 4:26 before halftime is included, the margin in that stretch becomes 31-3, with the Tigers then stringing together six straight scoring possessions while Florida answered with punts.

South Carolina used the same kind of swing to its advantage. After Aaron Philo’s interception helped the Gamecocks break a 10-10 tie with 1:42 left before halftime, Florida failed to answer on the next drive, opened the second half with a field goal, and then watched South Carolina punch back again at 11:47 to go up 24-13. The Gamecocks scored on five straight possessions during that run.

“It really has started (in) that middle eight for us,” offensive coordinator Buster Faulkner said. “We’re trying to play catch-up and we’ve got to keep ourselves out of that situation the best we can.”

There’s also an internal question: who steps up when Florida needs a voice? Dallas Wilson may be giving the team one.

Wilson’s postgame speech in the locker room after the South Carolina loss, emotional and at times profane, stood out. The sophomore receiver has already established himself as a go-to target, and his ability to become a steadying presence could matter as much as his production.

Vernell Brown III has also been one of the team’s louder voices, but the sophomore receiver has missed two games with a knee injury and remains questionable for Saturday. Junior linebacker Myles Graham is another player who can rally the group.

Graham said Wilson’s emergence was welcomed.

“It was great having Dallas step up,” Graham said Tuesday. “Having the same voice over and over again, it happens, that’s part of being a leader. But we do need other guys to step up and help get the team where we need to go.”

And then there’s the matchup that could wreck Florida’s plans all by itself: Texas edge rusher Colin Simmons against a shaky Gators offensive line.

Sumrall’s first look at Simmons on film left him stunned.

“He’s wow good,” Sumrall said Monday. “I really started to watch the tape last night, and I’m like, ‘All right, I’m just gonna turn this off.

I don’t even want to watch this guy anymore right now.’ ”

Simmons and South Carolina’s Dylan Stewart are projected by Sumrall to be the top two edge rushers in the 2027 NFL draft, and Florida already saw what Stewart could do last weekend. Stewart had a sack and forced two fumbles after returning from a one-game suspension.

Simmons has been even hotter. The 6-foot-3, 246-pound pass rusher had two sacks against Oklahoma after recording 5.5 the week before against Tennessee. His 9.5 sacks lead the nation.

Florida’s line, especially right tackle Emeka Ugori, will have its hands full. The sophomore Stanford transfer struggled badly against Stewart, earning a pass-blocking grade of 2.1 out of 100 from Pro Football Focus.

Faulkner said the plan is to give Simmons extra attention.

“We got to know where he is,” Faulkner said.

In Other News...

Sarkisian's Latest Officiating Frustration Will Fire Up Texas Fans

Steve Sarkisian did not hide his frustration after a pass-interference flag on cornerback Kade Phillips in Texas loss to Oklahoma, saying Phillips made a good play on the ball. The call added another flashpoint to a game that already had the Longhorns feeling hard done by, and it fit into a season in which Texas has seen its secondary spend too much time on the wrong side of the officials.

Phillips has now been flagged for pass interference three times this season, while senior cornerback Bo Mascoe has picked up two such penalties of his own. Sarkisians complaint was not just about one call, either - he made clear the Longhorns are waiting for similar contact to go their way, and that imbalance is the sort of thing Texas fans are likely to latch onto as the season moves on. [Read more 🡒]

Oklahoma May Have Sparked A Bigger Arch Manning Debate

Arch Mannings uneven start to the 2026 college football season has started to spill beyond the box score, and the latest sign came when Mel Kiper Jr. updated his top 10 prospects for the 2027 NFL Draft without including the Texas quarterback. Manning has been under a brighter spotlight than almost any player in the sport, and the recent loss to Oklahoma only sharpened the scrutiny after he threw two interceptions in that game.

Kipers list instead opened with Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith at No. 1, a reminder that the early draft conversation is already taking shape around other headliners. For Manning, the omission is less about one rankings update than the broader debate it reflects: how much patience evaluators should have for a quarterback whose talent is obvious, but whose early-season play has left plenty of questions hanging in the air. [Read more 🡒]

Arch Manning Suddenly Has A Draft Question Texas Fans Didn't Expect

Arch Mannings first season as Texas starter has been productive enough to keep him in the national spotlight, but it has also stirred a new layer of draft speculation. Through five games, Manning has completed 63 percent of his passes for 1,122 yards with 10 touchdowns and five interceptions, numbers that have kept the Longhorns in the conversation while he continues to develop under a bright microscope.

So when NFL Draft analyst Todd McShay released his top 10 quarterback rankings for the 2027 draft and left Manning out, it only added another wrinkle to an already unusual storyline. The bigger question around Manning is no longer just how high he can climb if he keeps playing well, but whether he would even be in that draft class at all, with ongoing discussion about a possible return to college for a fifth year. [Read more 🡒]