TCU Faces The Quarterback Decision Sonny Dykes Cant Keep Avoiding

Indiana's tactical decision to bench ex-TCU QB Josh Hoover challenges the norm by prioritizing victory over player sentiment and financial stakes.

Indiana’s decision to bench Josh Hoover may be the clearest sign yet that college football’s new rules are starting to settle in.

Hoover, the former TCU starting quarterback who left in December looking for more money and a better shot at a major conference title and a national championship, has been pushed aside at Indiana. Curt Cignetti turned to Grant Wilson, a seventh-year senior, and in the process sent a message that reaches well beyond Bloomington.

The message: money should not block a coach from making the move that gives him the best chance to win. Feelings do not override performance. And a quarterback who looked solid in one league may not carry the same value in another.

That is a bold call, and it takes a coach with real confidence to make it. Cignetti has that kind of freedom, and maybe more than anyone else in the sport right now. He can do what he wants, and he did.

Not every coach has that kind of runway. Texas A&M, for one, is still trying to figure out what to do with Marcel Reed.

It was around this time last year that Reed was exposed by Texas in a loss in Austin on Nov. 28, and neither he nor the Aggies have looked the same since. Texas A&M finished the season with two straight losses, including a home playoff defeat to Miami in which Reed struggled.

After that game, Aggies coach Mike Elko said, “I don’t hope that it’s trending, it is trending [in the right direction].”

Reed, now a fourth-year senior, has kept playing at the same level he showed down the stretch a year ago, and Texas A&M sits near the top of the nation’s most disappointing teams. The Aggies are 4-6 overall and 1-6 in the SEC.

Fans want Brady Hart, or somebody else, to get a shot. Elko has not gone there. Texas A&M is not making the kind of change Michigan made with Bryce Underwood, the high-paid sophomore quarterback who was benched last month in favor of true freshman Tommy Carr.

Elko’s reluctance says as much about the quarterbacks behind Reed as it does about Reed himself. He does not seem to trust Hart or anyone else on the roster, and the biggest mistake may have been ignoring what the last two games in 2025 revealed before doubling down on Reed. Texas A&M’s season has been hanging by a thread, and that decision did not help.

TCU’s situation is different, but it still fits the same conversation.

Sonny Dykes is expected to stay with Harvard transfer Jaden Craig for Saturday night’s game against No. 2 Utah, even though Craig is dealing with an injury. The alternative is inexperienced sophomore Adam Schobel, who is well regarded but still untested.

Dykes is coaching with his job on the line, which leaves him little room to treat the season like a development project. Cignetti can make a clean, ruthless decision because of the power he has. Others do not have that luxury.

“As coaches we all just want to win; you’re going to play whoever gives you the best chance to win,” Dykes said Wednesday. “But when you’re invested in somebody, it’s kind of hard to put them on the bench. There’s a lot of factors to consider, because if you’re paying a quarterback $5 or $6 million chances are that money came from somebody.”

That, of course, points to a donor who may have a say in the matter.

Dykes also said the sport has changed in ways that make development much harder.

“It’s hard to develop anybody. Imagine that every player in the NFL had a one-year contract.

That’s what it is in college football,” he said. “The game has suffered a little bit because of that; it’s just not as probably as clean as football as it used to be.”

He added that the old blueprint for winning - building through dominant lines - has been replaced by a game that leans heavily on quarterback experience.

“It’s more like the NFL where the teams that have the best quarterbacks, and most experienced quarterbacks are going to win most often,” he said.

That is the new reality Indiana just embraced. In this version of college football, the cleanest path is simple: do what Indiana did, don’t let money get in the way of winning, and remember that feelings don’t matter.

In Other News...

Texas A&M Could Lose Trev Alberts At A Brutal Time

Texas A&M may have to keep an eye on a familiar name far beyond College Station, because athletic director Trev Alberts has interviewed for the Michigan job and is now considered a leading candidate, according to ESPNs Pete Thamel. The timing is awkward for the Aggies, who have only recently settled into the Alberts era and would prefer stability in a role that touches everything from football oversight to long-term department planning.

Michigans current athletic director, Warde Manuel, is set to step down at the end of the year, which could open the door for Alberts to move into one of the sports most visible posts. If that happens, the next set of decisions would not be routine, especially with Michigans football program carrying major expectations and looming questions that any new administrator would have to confront quickly. [Read more 🡒]

Texas A&Ms Next Tackle Decision Just Got A Lot More Important

Texas A&Ms offensive line haul in the 2027 class took a hit when five-star tackle Mark Matthews flipped his commitment to Georgia, a reminder that even the most carefully built recruiting plans can change quickly. The Aggies still have a strong foundation in place, though, with five-star Kennedy Brown and four-star tackles Kaeden Scott and DeMarrion Johnson expected to sign despite attention from other programs.

Mason Josephs visit added another layer to the picture, and the three-star lineman came away with a positive impression of Texas A&M. Even so, there are still moving parts in the class, from coaching staff decisions to the final shape of the commitments, which makes the next stretch especially important for the Aggies as they try to hold the line up front. [Read more 🡒]

Texas A&M Is Climbing Early But One Bigger Test Awaits

Texas A&Ms early run has already started to change the conversation around Buzz Williams team. The Aggies are 5-0 after a recent win over SE Louisiana, and the numbers on the bracketology board have moved with them, as ESPNs Joe Lunardi bumped Texas A&M up to a 7-seed after having them lower in earlier projections. With transfer guards PJ Haggerty and Jordan Pope giving the offense a different look, the Aggies have given themselves a strong opening stretch and a little more national attention than they had a week ago.

Still, the early climb comes with a few reminders that November can flatter a team before the real tests arrive. Rebounding remains a concern, and Texas A&M is also waiting on an injured forward who is expected back later, a piece that could help balance the rotation once the schedule gets tougher. For now, the Aggies have banked wins and improved their standing, but the next step is proving they can keep that momentum when the matchup quality rises. [Read more 🡒]