Tennessee’s Quarterback Future: George MacIntyre Steps Into the Spotlight as Vols Navigate Postseason and Portal Decisions
As Tennessee gears up for its Music City Bowl matchup against Illinois, there’s a lot more on the line than just closing out the 2025 season on a high note. While Tuesday's game is the official finale, the real work for Josh Heupel and his staff has already shifted toward what comes next - and that starts under center.
The Vols are in the midst of a transitional period at quarterback, and how they handle this offseason could shape the trajectory of the program for years to come. With Joey Aguilar set to play his final college game and backup Jake Merklinger heading to the transfer portal, the quarterback room is undergoing a major reshuffle. That leaves redshirt freshman George MacIntyre as the new No. 2 for the bowl game - and potentially the face of the future in Knoxville.
MacIntyre’s Moment Arrives - Quietly, for Now
MacIntyre won’t get the same kind of spotlight Nico Iamaleava had two years ago when Joe Milton III opted out of the Citrus Bowl, handing the reins to the freshman for his first start. Aguilar is suiting up for the Music City Bowl, so unless something unexpected happens, MacIntyre will remain on the sideline.
But make no mistake - the staff is watching closely. So is Aguilar, who’s seen MacIntyre’s growth firsthand throughout the season.
“I think he’s prepared,” Aguilar said after Friday’s practice. “He’s grown a lot, got the playbook down, and he’s ready.
Super talented, super smart, and he’s a leader. When he gets his chance, he’ll take advantage of it.”
That chance might not come on Tuesday, but it’s coming. The question is when - and how ready Tennessee feels he’ll be when it does.
The Quarterback Room Reset
Once the final whistle blows in Nashville, Tennessee’s quarterback depth chart gets a full reset. Aguilar’s out of eligibility.
Merklinger is on his way out. And while five-star Faizon Brandon is set to enroll in just a few weeks, he’s still a true freshman who’s never taken a college snap.
That leaves MacIntyre, all 6-foot-6 and 195 pounds of him, as the most seasoned returner - at least in terms of time in the system. His in-game experience is limited to just two appearances this season (against East Tennessee State and New Mexico State), totaling nine pass attempts and 18 snaps. But the staff saw enough in preseason camp to be intrigued by his potential.
Heupel has already said the Vols need a third quarterback to go with MacIntyre and Brandon. Whether that means dipping into the transfer portal for a one-year bridge starter or rolling the dice on young talent will depend on how Tennessee evaluates MacIntyre’s readiness - and how much they’re willing to spend in a quarterback market that’s never been more expensive.
Development Behind the Scenes
MacIntyre’s growth this year hasn’t been flashy, but it’s been steady. Aguilar praised his improvement in the film room, his timing with receivers, and his overall command of the offense.
“He’s asking the right questions, learning defenses, and getting the scheme down to a tee,” Aguilar said. “He’s also getting stronger.
People don’t think he is, but he’s actually really strong. He’s prepared.”
The physical development is worth noting. MacIntyre came in with a lean frame, but he’s added strength and has been putting in the work to handle the SEC grind. The mental side of the game - understanding coverages, leading the offense, being vocal - has also taken a step forward.
What Comes Next
Tennessee’s decision at quarterback isn’t just about 2026. It’s about building a sustainable future. MacIntyre could be the bridge to something long-term, or he could be caught in the shuffle if the Vols bring in another experienced transfer and fast-track Brandon into the mix.
That’s why this offseason is so critical. It’s not just about who takes the first snap next fall - it’s about setting the tone for the next two or three years. And for MacIntyre, that means treating every rep like it matters.
“He’s a competitor,” Aguilar said. “He comes in and competes every day.
Just because the opportunity is getting closer doesn’t mean he’s changed - he’s always been ready. It’s next man up, and when his time comes, he’ll be ready.”
Final Thoughts
The Vols are at a quarterback crossroads. With Aguilar’s chapter closing and Brandon’s just beginning, MacIntyre sits in the middle - a redshirt with promise, polish, and a chance to claim the future. Whether Tennessee hands him the keys or brings in a veteran stopgap, one thing is clear: George MacIntyre will be in the thick of the competition.
And if the coaches believe in what they’ve seen behind the scenes, the next era of Tennessee football might already be on the roster - just waiting for his shot.