Tim Tebow isn’t buying the College Football Playoff Committee’s latest read on Tennessee and Alabama, and he made that clear while speaking on SEC Network ahead of Week 12 kickoffs.
In the third CFP rankings, Tennessee landed at No. 9 after dropping a spot, while Alabama sat at No. 3 despite both teams being 8-2. That gap has plenty of people in Knoxville fired up, especially because Tennessee beat Alabama 26-10 earlier this season.
Tebow pointed straight at that head-to-head result when he addressed the rankings.
"The problem is [Alabama and Tennessee] played a game for 60 minutes."
"I don't disagree with the eye test," Tebow said. "When I look at Alabama compared to Tennessee, the eye test says that Alabama is better.
The problem is that they played a game for 60 minutes, and Alabama got bludgeoned in the second half. It's not that you only look at that one game, but that one game has to be extremely valuable, and probably in my opinion the most valuable criteria you look from."
Hunter Yuracheck had originally pointed to Tennessee’s lack of quality wins as the reason for the difference, but Tebow’s stance was simple: the game in Knoxville should matter a lot more than it does right now.
And it was not a close one. Tennessee didn’t just edge Alabama - the Vols controlled the Crimson Tide, with Jim Knowles’ defense causing problems for Keelon Russell throughout the night. Russell entered the fall with Heisman Trophy hype, but in Knoxville he looked like an average SEC quarterback with Neyland Stadium rocking for 60 minutes.
Tebow did acknowledge Alabama has improved as the season has gone on, but the head-to-head result still hangs over the comparison. Tennessee still has LSU ahead, and if the Vols win that one, they’ll move to 9-2 with Vanderbilt left on the schedule. If they finish 10-2 and Alabama also ends up 10-2, the debate only gets louder.
At that point, the question becomes unavoidable: how do you justify putting Alabama ahead of Tennessee when Tennessee already handled the Tide so convincingly?
For now, the committee is sticking with its order. Tebow clearly thinks that’s a mistake.
In Other News...
Tennessee Suddenly Has A Jalen Haralson Problem To Monitor
Tennessee will have to get through its next game without Jalen Haralson, as the sophomore guard is set to miss the matchup with Coastal Carolina because of a right knee injury. His status is day-to-day, and Tennessee Athletics will continue to evaluate him, which gives the Volunteers a small but real health concern as they try to keep their rotation steady early in the season.
Haralsons absence also pauses a player who head coach Rick Barnes has pointed to as still developing and working through the usual challenges that come with that process. For Tennessee, the immediate question is less about one game than about how long it might take before Haralson is back in the mix and able to keep building momentum. [Read more 🡒]
LSU Brings A New Offensive Concern Into Tennessee Showdown
LSU heads into its showdown with Tennessee with a fresh wrinkle on offense, as wide receiver Jackson Harris is listed as questionable for the game. For a Tigers team trying to keep its College Football Playoff hopes on track, any uncertainty at receiver matters, especially in a matchup where every possession figures to carry extra weight.
The concern does not stop there, either, with Texas edge rusher Colin Simmons also listed as questionable for the Longhorns game against Arkansas. Between those two situations, the weekend carries a little more intrigue than usual for teams trying to protect their playoff positioning, and Tennessee will be watching closely to see how LSUs offensive plan takes shape. [Read more 🡒]
Tennessees Offense Is In Trouble And The Vols Just Sent A Message
Tennessees offense spent the opening stretch of the LSU game searching for any kind of rhythm, and the early returns were rough. The Vols opened with Faizon Brandon at quarterback, but possession after possession stalled as LSU controlled the first quarter with a pair of field goals to build a 6-0 lead.
As the game moved into the second quarter, Tennessee made a change under center and turned to George MacIntyre in hopes of jolting the offense. It was the kind of move that said plenty about how the night had gone so far, with the Vols still trying to find answers and LSU already dictating the tone. [Read more 🡒]
