Josh Heupel’s tenure at Tennessee has delivered its share of recruiting victories, but not every blue-chip arrival has turned into the kind of player Vols fans expected. Some prospects came in with star billing and left behind more questions than answers.
Three names stand out as the biggest disappointments from the high school recruiting side of the Heupel era.
Cameron Seldon arrived with a lot of buzz as a 4-star RB/WR and the kind of versatile offensive threat people imagined could become a Deebo Samuel-type weapon. Tennessee never got that version of him.
He began his career in the backfield and produced 48 carries for 224 yards and a touchdown over two seasons before transferring to Virginia Tech and moving to wide receiver. That switch didn’t unlock much, either, as he caught just 23 passes last season on a struggling Hokies team.
247Sports had him as the No. 77 player in the 2023 class, but that projection hasn’t matched the production so far. Seldon is now at South Florida for one more year, trying to get back on track.
Jordan Ross came to Knoxville with even bigger expectations. The 5-star EDGE was ranked in the top 10 of the 2024 class, and plenty of people saw a future first-round pick.
Instead, the production never caught up to the hype. In 22 career games, Ross managed only 1.5 sacks.
Even on a defense that had its issues last season, he couldn’t carve out a consistent role, finishing sixth on the defensive line in pass rush win percentage. He entered the transfer portal this winter and is now at LSU with Lane Kiffin, hoping to take his game to another level.
There have been flashes, but not nearly enough to match the billing of a top-10 recruit.
Then there’s Nico Iamaleava, the most disappointing of the group for a lot of reasons. He did help Tennessee reach its first-ever college football playoff appearance, but the source of that success was mostly the defense and Dylan Sampson’s running, not Iamaleava turning into the explosive quarterback he was supposed to be coming out of high school.
In 2024 at Tennessee, he threw for 2,616 yards with 19 touchdowns and six interceptions while completing 64% of his passes. Those are respectable numbers, but they don’t scream game-changing for the No. 1 player in the 2023 class.
At UCLA, he hasn’t taken off either, finishing last year with 1,928 passing yards, 13 touchdowns, and 7 interceptions. His departure from Tennessee also left a sour taste for many Vols fans, and with the hype he carried, it’s hard to imagine anyone taking this spot from him.
In Other News...
Outsiders Just Weighed In On Faizon Brandon And Vols Fans Will Debate It
The quarterback race in Knoxville is already one of the more watched competitions in the SEC, with true freshman Faizon Brandon joining second-year George MacIntyre and transfer Ryan Staub in Tennessees 2026 mix. Even before fall camp opens, the buzz around Brandon has been hard to miss, with plenty of observers expecting the highly touted newcomer to push for the job right away.
One of the latest outside takes came from SEC Mike, who slotted Brandon near the top tier of league quarterbacks in a preseason ranking that will surely give Vols fans something to argue about. Brandon landed behind the biggest names in the conference and ahead of a handful of other SEC passers, a placement that says as much about the hype around Tennessees young quarterback as it does about the uncertainty that still hangs over the position. [Read more 🡒]
One Former Vol Just Turned Up Tennessee's NBA Buzz
Former Tennessee players have already started making the NBA Summer League feel a little more orange this month, with several ex-Vols getting real run for San Antonio and others popping up on the schedule in the days ahead. Chaz Lanier has been the loudest name in that group, while JaKobi Gillespie and Igor Milicic Jr. have also been part of the Spurs lineup mix, giving Tennessee fans a chance to track a familiar pipeline in a setting where every possession is being watched closely.
Felix Okpara has also gotten into the action in what is still an early stretch of Summer League play, and the next wave of games should keep the Vols connection going. Lanier, Tyreke Key, Jaden Springer, Jahmai Mashack and Kennedy Chandler are all slated for upcoming appearances, which means Tennessees presence in Las Vegas is not just a one-night burst but a running subplot worth following as these former Vols try to carve out their next step. [Read more 🡒]