Tennessee’s push for a big 2028 recruiting haul took a hit when one of its top targets chose to stay home.
Four-star safety Nick Carroll has committed to Georgia over Tennessee and Florida, according to Hayes Fawcett. The Peach State native had been on Tennessee’s radar as the Vols work toward building a top-10 class in the 2028 cycle. With the 2027 class essentially finished, Tennessee currently has just one commitment in 2028 and is still looking to add more pieces in the months ahead.
Carroll’s stock has been high for a while. At one point, he was ranked as the 48th-best player in the country, the fourth-ranked safety, and the fifth-ranked player from Georgia.
Tennessee made a strong run at him, but Georgia ultimately kept the in-state prospect from leaving home.
His commitment also adds to a familiar recruiting storyline for Tennessee in the secondary. The Vols have now missed on another safety target headed to an SEC program, following the recent pledges of four-star safeties Giovanni Tuggle and Braylen Bedford to Ole Miss. Tennessee is expected to keep chasing all three prospects all the way to National Signing Day in their senior years.
Rivals’ Jeremy Johnson offered this assessment of Carroll:
“Carroll can run. He can cover a lot of ground quickly when he locks in on the football.
Carroll isn’t a big safety, but his speed makes him a problem for offenses in space. Carroll can also play physical and has a good feel for positioning himself to make tackles in the open field.
Carroll will not be pigeonholed into any particular spot in the secondary. Carroll is a safety, but he has the skill set to play cornerback if need be.
Expect Carroll to play safety at Georgia. He is most likely a free safety.
The star position may not be out of the question either. There are many similarities to current Georgia safety Rasean Dinkins.
The former Warner Robins star, Dinkins, was a playmaker all over the field in high school. Dinkins has quickly adapted and earned a big role in Georgia’s secondary.
The same tools exist in Carroll’s game. The ball skills, nose for the ball, speed and even the beginnings of a sound tackler translate to being a key contributor in Athens.”
In Other News...
Tennessee's Quarterback Situation Just Got More Uncertain Before Arkansas
Tennessees quarterback picture has become even murkier heading into the trip to Arkansas, with Faizon Brandon now dealing with an injury and listed as questionable for the game. The uncertainty adds another layer to a position that was already under a spotlight after Brandon was benched in the previous game against Auburn, when George MacIntyre stepped in and gave the Volunteers a steadier look through the air.
Josh Heupel acknowledged Brandons injury status but stopped short of mapping out how Tennessee will handle the position this week. That leaves the Volunteers waiting on two fronts: whether Brandon can get healthy in time, and whether the staff chooses to lean back toward MacIntyre after his efficient relief work against Auburn. [Read more 🡒]
Tennessee's Playoff Margin Could Shift Before The Alabama Game
Tennessees early surge has the Volunteers sitting at 4-1 and hovering near the College Football Playoff bubble, which means the margins around them matter almost as much as what happens in Knoxville. Before Tennessee even gets to its Week 7 meeting with Alabama, a handful of high-profile games elsewhere could reshape the picture around the Vols and the teams theyre being compared against.
UCLAs trip to Oregon, Houstons matchup with Kansas State and, most notably, Alabama against Georgia all carry ripple effects for Tennessees playoff standing. The Vols do not play Georgia this season, so the Bulldogs remain part of the broader conversation only from a distance, but Alabama is still very much in front of them on the schedule and in the committee conversation. By the time Tennessee gets its shot at the Crimson Tide, the playoff margin could already look different. [Read more 🡒]
Tennessee Has A Clear Arkansas Opportunity If The Vols Can Deliver
Tennessee heads into its SEC matchup with Arkansas with a blueprint in hand, and the film from the Razorbacks loss to Texas A&M points to an opening the Vols will want to press. Tennessees spread offense and run game have been the focus of the prep work, with DeSean Bishop set to be a central figure as the Vols try to stress a defense that showed vulnerabilities in its most recent outing. It is the kind of game plan that can travel well if Tennessee can stay on schedule and force Arkansas to defend the full width of the field.
George MacIntyre is expected to make his first career start, which adds another layer to a game Tennessee already views as an opportunity. Arkansas still brings a defense coordinated by Jim Knowles, so the challenge is not hard to identify, even if the tape suggests some cracks to attack. For the Vols, the question is whether they can turn those areas into a real advantage on the road, and whether MacIntyres debut can stay steady enough to let the rest of the offense do its work. [Read more 🡒]