The first College Football Playoff rankings of the 2026 season wasted no time stirring up a fight, and Paul Finebaum jumped right into the middle of it.
On Wednesday’s edition of ESPN’s Get Up, the ESPN analyst went after the committee’s handling of Alabama and Tennessee, zeroing in on the gap between the two 6-2 teams. Alabama landed at No. 5, while Tennessee checked in at No. 13, even though the Volunteers beat the Crimson Tide earlier this season.
Finebaum made it clear he didn’t buy the logic behind Alabama’s spot, especially with Tennessee carrying the head-to-head win. He said the rankings were unusually difficult to understand and took direct aim at Alabama’s placement.
The reaction fits into a broader argument that always follows these rankings: how much should the committee value the full résumé compared with what happened on the field in a head-to-head matchup? Alabama’s schedule includes several tough opponents, which could be part of why the committee is leaning its way.
But Tennessee fans have a simple answer to that. Their team beat Alabama and still ended up eight spots lower.
The committee, though, does not treat head-to-head as an automatic trump card. It weighs strength of schedule, results against quality opponents and direct matchups, and committee chair Hunter Yurachek has said those comparisons matter most when teams are close together in the rankings. That framework may help explain the separation here, but it hasn’t done much to quiet the noise.
Both teams now get another chance to shape the conversation this weekend. Alabama goes on the road to face No.
14 LSU, while Tennessee takes on No. 6 Kentucky.
Those results will give the committee more to chew on before the next set of rankings comes out.
A big Alabama win would help steady its place. A Tennessee win over another ranked opponent would only strengthen the Volunteers’ case. For now, Finebaum’s criticism has given the debate another loud voice, and the rankings have already produced one of the season’s most controversial comparisons.
In Other News...
DeSean Bishop Changes Tennessees Kentucky Outlook At The Perfect Time
DeSean Bishop looks set to give Tennessee a timely boost as the Volunteers come out of their bye week and turn their attention to Kentucky. Josh Heupel said Bishop is in good shape to be active after the late injury he picked up at South Carolina, a welcome update for a Tennessee offense that has leaned on him heavily as he closes in on 1,000 rushing yards this season.
For a back who has spent four years in Knoxville, the timing matters on more than one level. Tennessee gets one of its most dependable runners back for a key SEC matchup, while Bishop continues to build a strong final-season case that could shape what comes next, including the possibility of entering the NFL draft after the year. [Read more 🡒]
Tennessee Is Suddenly In Position For Its Next 5-Star Win
The recruiting board has a familiar high-end name back on it for Tennessee, and this one is still wide open. Five-star point guard Nasir Anderson remains uncommitted in the 2027 class, with Tennessee and Virginia emerging as the programs out front after a round of visits that has put the Vols squarely in the mix for one of the countrys top guards.
Anderson is ranked 12th nationally by Rivals, which gives Tennessee a real chance to add another elite piece to its pipeline if it can finish the job. The Vols last landed a five-star recruit two years ago in Nate Ament, and he has since been drafted into the NBA, a reminder of how much value a top-tier prospect can bring to the program if this pursuit breaks Tennessees way. [Read more 🡒]
Tennessee's Kentucky Night Could Matter Big For Heupel Off The Field
Saturday night at Neyland Stadium is shaping up to be about more than just Tennessee and Kentucky. With more than 100,000 fans expected, the Vols will also have a sizable recruiting audience in the building, including three 2027 prospects who could come away with a strong impression of the program and the atmosphere that surrounds it.
Among the visitors are cornerback Preston Glasco, pass-rusher Hayden Lowe and defensive lineman Joshua Lane, all names Tennessee is tracking closely. Lowe has Tennessee in the mix as he works through a run of visits before an early-December decision, while Lane, a Memphis native, is also drawing heavy attention from Alabama. For Josh Heupel and his staff, a win over Kentucky would do more than help in the standings. It could give those recruits one more reason to picture themselves in orange. [Read more 🡒]