Tony Pollard’s future in Tennessee is hanging over the Titans’ backfield, and that’s pushed Tyjae Spears right into the center of the conversation.
Pollard is in the final year of his contract with the Titans, and while he just turned in an above-par season in Nashville - his fourth straight year topping 1,000 rushing yards, along with five touchdowns - the situation still feels temporary. At nearly 30 years old and on an expiring deal, there’s no guarantee Tennessee’s rebuilding team keeps him around for long.
So the question Titans fans keep circling is simple: is Spears ready to take over as RB1?
Dharya Sharma asked that question on X, and the replies from an increasingly energized Titans fanbase came back all over the map. Some were optimistic. Others went straight to the biggest concern that has followed Spears for years: health.
“If he can stay healthy yes” one fan replied, while another took a more skeptical route, saying, “if only he had the sustainability of Derrick Henry.”
That injury history is impossible to ignore. Spears tore his ACL multiple times before reaching the NFL, and since entering the league he has also dealt with concussions, hamstring strains and ankle strains. He did manage a clean rookie campaign back in 2024, but the Titans still haven’t really gotten the full version of Spears for a full season.
Now entering year four, Spears appears healthier than he has in a while. Even so, fans kept coming back to the same issue.
“No, he can’t stay healthy enough,” was one response. Another read, “I like Spears and I’m always rooting for him, but his health has been an issue.”
That’s the heart of the debate. If Spears can hold up physically, the path in front of him is pretty clear.
He already handled work as both a runner and receiver last season, and with Tennessee rebuilding its offense this offseason, he looks like one of the biggest beneficiaries. Brian Daboll is seen as a strong fit at offensive coordinator for Spears’ skill set.
And beyond Pollard, the depth chart doesn’t exactly scream certainty. Rookie Nick Singleton looks like the next notable name in the mix, but this season his role would mostly be to spell Spears, just as Spears has been spelling Pollard.
The Titans have every reason to worry about Spears’ durability - he didn’t even return to the team until October last season because of it. But if he stays on the field, this could finally be the year he gets a real shot to settle into RB1 duties.
In Other News...
Titans Running Backs Just Got The Disrespect Fans Will Remember
The Titans backfield looks set up for another season built around Tony Pollard, with Tyjae Spears positioned as the primary insurance policy and rookie Nicholas Singleton giving Tennessee a third option in the room. It is a group that still carries some intrigue because of how the offense could lean on the ground game if the passing attack has a hard time finding consistency.
Still, Pro Football Focus preseason ranking landed the Titans running back room at 22nd, a label that will not sit well with a fan base that expects more from one of the leagues most important position groups. The number itself is only part of the story, because Tennessees backs are going to matter plenty if the offense needs them to shoulder a bigger load than the outside perception suggests. [Read more 🡒]
Titans Roster Shakeup Puts Unexpected Focus On Their Defensive Depth
The Titans kept their roster moving this week, adding veteran defensive end Tanoh Kpassagnon and linebacker Milo Eifler after recent workouts while also making a change at tight end by releasing Matt Lauter. The pair of defensive signings fits the kind of late-summer roster churn that often reveals where a team thinks it needs more insulation, especially when injuries and availability start to reshape the back end of the roster.
Nazeeh Johnsons move to injured reserve adds another wrinkle for Tennessee, coming shortly after he was suspended for six games for violating the NFLs Performance Enhancing Substances policy. With Johnson unavailable and the Titans bringing in players who have already bounced around the league, the emphasis now shifts to how much reliable depth they can build on defense before the season settles in. [Read more 🡒]
Titans Add Two Defenders As One New Arrival Suddenly Stands Out
With a joint practice against the Seahawks on deck and another game looming, the Titans are continuing to churn the bottom of the roster while trying to keep the defensive depth chart stable. Tennessee placed safety Nazeeh Johnson on Reserve/Injured after his six-game suspension for violating the NFLs Performance-Enhancing Substances Policy, then opened the spot by releasing tight end Matt Lauter and bringing in defensive end Tanoh Kpassagnon and linebacker Milo Eifler.
The two additions give the Titans some extra bodies on defense at a time when preseason reps matter, and Kpassagnon in particular is a name that immediately jumps off the page among the newcomers. With the roster still in flux this close to the Seattle week, the more interesting question is how quickly Tennessee can sort out which of these fresh faces is simply filling space and which one might force his way into a larger role. [Read more 🡒]