Todd McShay Stuns Fans With Bold Pick For Titans In 2026 Mock Draft

Todd McShay reconsiders the Titans' draft strategy, favoring Rueben Bain Jr. over Jeremiyah Love for a stronger defensive edge in the 2026 NFL Draft.

In the latest twist of the NFL Draft saga, Todd McShay is shaking things up with his fresh take on the Tennessee Titans' fourth pick. While most mock drafts have been buzzing about the Titans potentially snagging running back Jeremiyah Love, McShay is steering clear of that narrative. Instead, he's got his sights set on Rueben Bain Jr., the dynamic EDGE from Miami.

Now, this choice might raise a few eyebrows, especially since David Bailey, another top-tier EDGE from Texas Tech, is still in the mix. McShay's decision to let Bailey slide to the New Orleans Saints at the eighth spot is certainly a bold move that could turn heads on draft day.

So, why Bain over Bailey for Tennessee? McShay's reasoning is rooted in the Titans' draft philosophy under GM Mike Borgonzi, who hails from the Kansas City Chiefs' school of thought.

Borgonzi is known for prioritizing premium positions with high picks-think quarterbacks, edge rushers, offensive tackles, and cornerbacks. While the allure of a running back like Love is undeniable, McShay points out a compelling trend: no top-10 drafted running back in the past decade has reached the Super Bowl with their original team.

The Bain pick also speaks to the Titans' strategic needs. With Jermaine Johnson anchoring the wide-9 rush, head coach Robert Saleh is on the hunt for a gritty, disruptive force up front.

Bain fits that bill perfectly, bringing a physical edge and pass-rushing prowess that could elevate Tennessee's defense. Sure, there might be some concerns about Bain's arm length, but his potential impact on the field is hard to ignore.

In the end, McShay's mock draft offers a fresh perspective on the Titans' strategy, highlighting the delicate balance between talent, fit, and long-term vision. As draft day approaches, all eyes will be on Tennessee to see if McShay's forecast hits the mark.