The 2027 NFL Draft quarterback picture has shifted fast, and the name sitting on top now is Drew Mestemaker.
What was supposed to be a loaded class entering the 2026 college football season has not played out that way. Instead of a crowded race, one quarterback has started to separate himself from the pack: Oklahoma State’s Mestemaker, who is in his first season with the Cowboys after transferring from North Texas.
That rise showed up in a poll ESPN conducted with 25 NFL scouts and executives. Seventeen of them called Mestemaker the clear QB1 in the 2027 class. And for those wondering where Arch Manning stood in that conversation: none of them picked him.
The rest of the field has thinned out quickly. Notre Dame’s CJ Carr got four votes, Miami’s Darian Mensah received three, and Oregon’s Dante Moore picked up one. Moore’s situation is even more complicated now, with his playing career currently on hold after the hit he took in Oregon’s game against USC earlier this season.
The contrast with August is striking. In that earlier poll of 25 scouts and executives, Moore led the way with 14 votes.
Manning had seven. Mestemaker wasn’t part of the conversation yet.
There’s still a long season ahead, and this race can change again. But right now, the gap is real, and it keeps getting wider.
If the draft were held today, the landing spot conversation would start with the teams holding the top picks. The Chargers sit at No. 1, followed by the Titans at No. 2 and the Dolphins at No. 3.
It’s hard to picture the Chargers moving on from Justin Herbert, so the real discussion begins with Tennessee and Miami. The Titans’ blockbuster trade of Jeffery Simmons to the Chicago Bears adds another layer to that picture, especially with Cam Ward in place as a long-term franchise QB option. That kind of move has to say something about where they see things.
The Dolphins, meanwhile, look like the cleaner fit on paper. Malik Willis is currently serving as the bridge quarterback, and that role could carry into next year as the roster continues to take shape.
So if Mestemaker keeps this trajectory and finishes as the QB1 in the class, the draft board points toward one of those two teams.
In Other News...
Titans Trade Suddenly Raises An Uncomfortable Question About What They Gave Up
Jeffery Simmons move from Tennessee to Chicago came together fast enough to leave the Titans with a familiar kind of second-guessing hanging over the deal. What made the trade stand out was not just the player involved, but the way it unfolded behind the scenes, with reports saying Giants coach John Harbaugh directly reached out to Titans owner Amy Adams Strunk in an effort to land Simmons even after Tennessee had initially denied it was shopping him.
For the Titans, the bigger issue now is whether the market was fully tested or whether relationships helped shape the outcome more than the usual trade process would suggest. In a league where front offices talk constantly but personal connections still matter, this kind of move can prompt an uncomfortable follow-up question: did Tennessee get the best possible offer for one of its most important assets, or did the timing and the people involved narrow the return before the bidding really opened up? [Read more 🡒]
Calvin Ridley Just Got A Huge Titans Opportunity At A Telling Time
Jeffery Simmons is gone, and the timing could hardly be more awkward for a Titans team heading into Week 8 already dealing with injuries and a thinner margin for error. The move leaves Tennessee short on one of its most important defensive pieces, but it also has ripple effects on the other side of the ball, where Calvin Ridley suddenly finds himself in a much bigger spot than he has had for much of this season.
Ridleys role has faded as the year has gone on, and his future in Tennessee is still very much up in the air with the November 10 trade deadline approaching. For a veteran receiver who has seen limited involvement, the coming stretch could amount to more than just extra snaps, it may be a chance to show enough to shape what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Jeffery Simmons Trade Could Haunt Titans Rebuild For One Reason
The Titans decision to move Jeffery Simmons and a 2027 fifth-round pick to Chicago in exchange for a pair of first-rounders and a 2027 fourth-rounder gives Tennessee the kind of draft capital every rebuilding team says it wants. On paper, it is the sort of deal that can reset a roster, especially when a proven veteran is the price of admission and the return includes multiple shots in the first round.
The catch is what those first-round picks are likely to become. History says selections in that late range rarely turn into foundational starters right away, which leaves the Titans in a familiar spot: plenty of assets, but no guarantee the rebuild gets a true difference-maker unless they hit above average. That is the part that could linger long after the trade is finalized, because the value of the deal may end up depending less on the volume of picks than on how well Tennessee uses them. [Read more 🡒]