Jeffery Simmons turned in the best season of his career, and it still wasn’t enough to get him the respect he probably deserved.
That’s the frustrating part for Tennessee Titans fans after ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler released his annual consensus rankings of NFL position groups, a poll built from the opinions of scouts, coaches and executives around the league. Simmons did land some first-place votes, but when the dust settled, he was slotted second among defensive tackles.
The player who finished ahead of him was Seattle Seahawks defensive tackle Leonard Williams, a name that makes the result feel even stranger. Williams had never been in the top five of these rankings before.
Fowler’s write-up on Simmons made the case plainly enough:
Simmons produced his best season, with 11 sacks on a 16.3% total pass rush win rate despite facing double-teams more than 65% of the time. That win rate ranked second among defensive tackles, while his 17 tackles for loss led all interior linemen.
He nearly earned the No. 1 spot but fell just short in the voting.
"His tape was phenomenal," a veteran NFL defensive coach said. "And it's even more impressive doing it on a three-win team and getting little help around him."
- Jeremy Fowler, ESPN
The oddest part of the voting was how extreme it got. Both Williams and Simmons received votes all the way at first place and all the way at eighth place, a sign that the league’s evaluators clearly weren’t seeing Simmons through the same lens.
Simmons was a first-team All-Pro last season, so finishing second on a list like this isn’t some outrageous collapse. But the comparison gets tougher when you look at the rest of the field. Zach Allen was the other first-team All-Pro defensive tackle last year, and he wasn’t the one ranked above Simmons here.
At some point, though, this becomes bigger than a single list. Simmons put together a dominant season while playing on a three-win team with little help around him, yet the recognition still hasn’t matched the production. That’s the story the Titans keep running into: team failure dragging down individual appreciation.
Even the players around the league haven’t fully bought in. Simmons was recently ranked 83rd on the NFL Top 100 Players list, which is voted on by players themselves.
In Other News...
Titans Suddenly Have A Worrying Femi Oladejo Problem Again
Femi Oladejos first spring with the Titans was supposed to be about getting a head start on a major position change, but a hamstring injury kept him out of those practices and slowed the process before it really got rolling. The second-round pick is being asked to move from 3-4 outside linebacker to a 3-4 defensive end role, which makes every rep valuable as Tennessee tries to see how quickly his game can translate.
Robert Saleh said the real development for Oladejo will come once training camp opens on July 29 and the pads go on, which is where the Titans will finally get a better read on the rookies fit. For a player already trying to learn a new spot, the missed spring work only adds to the pressure to make up ground fast when camp begins. [Read more 🡒]
Titans Finally Enter Camp Without Their Biggest Cornerback Burden
Training camp arrives with the Titans no longer carrying the same cornerback uncertainty that has shadowed them since L'Jarius Sneed came aboard. The expectation was that he would stabilize the secondary, but recurring knee and lower-body injuries kept him from becoming the dependable presence Tennessee had envisioned, and the team spent too much of the last two seasons trying to work around his availability.
Sneeds limited time on the field forced the Titans to think differently about how they build the position, and the result is a roster that looks better equipped to absorb setbacks. Even if the cornerback room still has plenty to prove, Tennessee enters camp with more depth and a little less pressure to have one player carry the entire burden. [Read more 🡒]
This Under The Radar Titans Defender Suddenly Feels Too Important To Ignore
Jaylen Harrell spent much of 2025 in a rotational edge role, but he made the kind of late push that tends to linger in a coaching staffs memory. Over the final five games, he piled up five sacks while also handling a heavy special teams load, logging 228 snaps and giving Tennessee value in more than one phase.
Now the challenge is less about what Harrell showed than where he fits. He enters 2026 training camp fighting for a roster spot in a crowded edge group, with Jermaine Johnson, Keldric Faulk and Femi Oladejo all in the mix and Jacob Martin also potentially part of the conversation. Harrell has already made himself harder to overlook, but the Titans still have to decide whether that late-season surge was enough to carve out a real place in the rotation. [Read more 🡒]