Former Tennessee Titans scout Blaise Taylor was convicted Wednesday in Nashville of killing his pregnant girlfriend and their unborn child, bringing a swift end to a case that centered on prosecutors’ claim that he poisoned her drink in 2023.
A jury found Taylor guilty on one count of second-degree murder, one count of first-degree murder and two counts of first-degree felony murder. The panel deliberated for just over two hours before reaching its verdict, then unanimously sentenced him to life in prison. Taylor will have to serve at least 51 years before he can be considered for parole.
Taylor, 30, had pleaded not guilty.
Prosecutors said Taylor poisoned Jade Benning on Feb. 25, 2023, by slipping a fatal dose of cocaine into her drink. Benning was five months pregnant, according to police, and prosecutors said Taylor did not want her to keep the child while Benning refused to have an abortion.
Benning’s unborn fetus died two days later, on Feb. 27.
Benning died on March 6 from acute cocaine poisoning, which was her 25th birthday. She was never able to speak with investigators before her death.
Testimony from one of Benning’s friends, Nijaiha Deshay Jackson, gave the jury a glimpse into Benning’s final hours. Jackson said Benning called her the night she was poisoned and repeatedly accused Taylor of putting something in her drink while telling her he was scaring her.
“‘I knew my drink tasted funny. I know you put something in my drink because I can’t even walk,’” Jackson recalled Benning saying. “She said, ‘You did this so something could happen to the baby.’”
After the verdict, Taylor’s attorney, Joshua Brand, urged the jury to consider mercy.
“You don’t have to give him life without the possibility of parole,” Brand said. “… You can give him the opportunity to try for rehabilitation.
You can give him the opportunity to work hard in prison. He’s not going anywhere.”
Brand was not available for comment.
Taylor’s path to the courtroom followed a football career that included a run at Arkansas State from 2014 through 2017, where he was a team captain and first-team All-Sun Belt defender. He later moved into NFL scouting with the Titans, staying there until 2023 before leaving for a senior defensive analyst job at Utah State. After one year with USU, he took a defensive analyst position at Texas A&M, but was arrested less than a week after that hiring was first reported.
In Other News...
This Quiet Titans Addition Could Shape Cam Wards Entire 2026 Season
Austin Schlottmann arrived in Tennessee as one of those low-key veteran additions that can end up mattering a lot more than the name recognition suggests. The Titans brought in the experienced center to compete for the starting job in 2026, and his background gives him a real chance to settle in quickly. He has bounced around the league, spent time under Carmen Bricillo and Brian Daboll in New York, and came off a strong 2025 season that showed he can still hold up at a high level.
What makes Schlottmann especially interesting for Tennessee is the way his work at center could ripple directly into Cam Wards season. The two are already building chemistry, and Schlottmann looks like one of the top options to anchor the line in front of the young quarterback. The competition is still open, but if Schlottmann keeps separating himself, the Titans may have found a quiet move that ends up shaping the entire 2026 offense. [Read more 🡒]
Former Titans Scout Faces Shocking New Chapter In Unthinkable Case
A Nashville jury has turned a horrifying case involving former Tennessee Titans scout Blaise Taylor into a stunning criminal ending, after prosecutors said he deliberately poisoned his pregnant girlfriend in 2023. Taylor, who once played at Arkansas State and later worked in the NFL, was convicted on serious murder charges after the death at the center of the case drew national attention.
The verdict closed one chapter, but the details remain as disturbing as they were during the trial, with jurors weighing the evidence against Taylor in a case that has already cast a long shadow over his football past. For Tennessee fans, the former scouts name now sits in a far different kind of history, tied not to talent evaluation but to a courtroom outcome that will follow him for decades. [Read more 🡒]
Titans Veteran Suddenly Caught In A Much Bigger Linebacker Squeeze
The Titans made a clear statement in the 2026 NFL Draft when they traded up to land linebacker Anthony Hill Jr., a move that immediately complicated the outlook for Cody Barton. Barton, an eight-year veteran and the current MIKE linebacker, now finds himself in a battle that feels bigger than a simple preseason depth chart decision, especially with Hill arriving as the kind of linebacker this defense had targeted for its next phase.
Hill has already drawn praise in offseason work and has been talked about as a future leader in the middle of the defense, which only adds to the pressure on Barton. The competition for the green-dot role is set to carry into training camp, and while Bartons experience could still give him an early edge, the Titans have made it plain they are not treating this as a placeholder situation. [Read more 🡒]