TCU’s box score from Dublin does more than record a loss to North Carolina. It shows a team that leaned hard on a few trusted pieces, shuffled others into smaller jobs, and never really found a second gear after building an early 10-3 lead at Aviva Stadium.
The clearest sign of how narrow the rotation became was in the backfield. Jeremy Payne handled the load almost by himself, carrying 25 times for 142 yards and adding five catches for 27 more. That’s 30 touches in a game TCU lost, and it tells you everything about how much the Horned Frogs leaned on him once the game settled in.
Jon Denman did get the first moment in the spotlight, punching in a short touchdown run to put TCU in front early. But his role never came close to matching Payne’s, and by the second half UNC’s defense had mostly taken Payne out of the picture anyway.
Quarterback Josh Hoover Craig had a rough debut against a Power Four opponent, finishing 20 of 32 for 175 yards with no touchdowns. He was sacked three times, lost 22 yards on the ground, and coughed up a fumble that turned into points for North Carolina.
The deeper issue was the lack of bite in the passing game. Craig spread completions to seven different players, but only two averaged more than 10 yards per catch, and TCU had just two completions that traveled more than 15 yards in the air.
That kind of production suggests the Horned Frogs never really threatened UNC vertically. Whether the issue was protection, coverage, play calling, or Craig himself, the downfield game never arrived.
Jordan Dwyer’s absence also changed the shape of the offense. The WR1 was out with a foot injury that had lingered since the Alamo Bowl, and Ed Small was the main beneficiary, finishing with nine catches for 65 yards. Even so, that 7.2 yards per catch points to a lot of short throws and not much in the way of a receiver winning downfield.
The rest of the passing game was spread thin. Kari Ashley, Jacobe Hayes, Ka'Morreun Pimpton, and Jeremy Scott all showed up in the mix, but none of them produced a heavy volume of catches.
Terry Shelton, who was expected to take on a bigger role at outside receiver with Dwyer sidelined, saw only one target. Dane Jones, one of the names that stood out in fall camp, also got just one target.
On defense, TCU had enough answers to keep things interesting for most of the afternoon. Max Carroll was everywhere, leading the team with nine tackles and recovering two fumbles while forcing one of them. Kaden McFadden added his first career forced fumble, and Gil Jackson came up with a timely pass breakup on a ball intended for Jordan Shipp before UNC later punted.
The pass rush had a few bright spots too. Ansel Din-Mbuh registered both of his sacks in the first quarter, making him the most productive rusher in the game, and John Schobel picked up the first sack of his career.
The final takeaway from Dublin is less about the loss itself and more about how the Horned Frogs reacted once the game tightened. Payne became the clear workhorse, the passing attack struggled to stretch the field, and the defense was asked to keep the team alive. With a bye week ahead, the question now is whether those roles stick or whether this game pushes TCU’s staff to widen the competition again.
In Other News...
TCU Player Assault Case Turns More Serious Than Fans Realized
Dozie Ezukanmas injury from the Aug. 13 altercation with former TCU wide receiver Jacob Fields turned out to be far more serious than many around the program initially realized. Ezukanma was hospitalized after the incident and went through multiple CT scans, with medical staff confirming both a brain bleed and a concussion, along with a growing hematoma that underscored how severe the situation had become.
Fields has since been charged with aggravated assault causing bodily harm, and the case now sits well beyond the kind of off-field dispute fans usually file away as routine summer noise. For TCU, the focus has shifted from the incident itself to Ezukanmas recovery and the broader fallout of a matter that clearly carried more medical and legal weight than first appeared. [Read more 🡒]
TCUs New Quarterback Has A Chance To Become A Real Draft Name
For TCU fans, the conversation around the 2025 quarterback class is bigger than just one national list of names. Jaden Craig is part of a group of passers drawing early attention because of what they could become this fall, joining a mix that includes CJ Bailey, Drake Lindsey, DJ Lagway and Cutter Boley. The common thread is potential: each has traits that can translate into a breakout season if the production catches up with the hype.
Craig fits into that same lane as a quarterback whose profile could grow quickly once the season starts and the spotlight gets brighter. The idea for the Horned Frogs is simple enough, even if the path is not: if he delivers the kind of leap evaluators are watching for, he could move from being just another name on a preseason watch list to someone with real draft buzz before long. [Read more 🡒]