The College Football Playoff is on the verge of another massive overhaul, and this one could reshape the sport in ways that go far beyond the bracket. According to Pete Thamel, the playoff is nearing an agreement to expand from 12 teams to 24 for the 2027 season.
For Baylor and the rest of the Big 12, that sounds like a path to more postseason chances. But the tradeoff is hard to miss: more access, less meaning in the regular season.
I’ve been watching football since the Power-I-formation dominated the landscape. I’ve seen dynasties rise and fall, the air raid take hold, the read option spread from the shotgun, and the playoff evolve from the BCS to four teams to 12.
I’m open to change. I’m also not eager to watch the regular season lose even more of its weight.
There was a time when an undefeated season stood as the gold standard for a national title run. That’s not the reality anymore.
Now two-loss and even three-loss teams can land on level footing with teams that never lost. And with conference realignment continuing to reshape the sport, it’s not even rare to imagine multiple undefeated teams sitting inside the same league.
A 24-team field might help settle the national championship debate more cleanly. It could also make the whole ranking process messier than ever.
The numbers make the case for just how wide this format could reach. If a 24-team playoff had existed since the CFP began in 2014, 80 teams would have appeared by now.
Alabama and Ohio State would have made it every single season since then. Clemson would have been in 11 times, Notre Dame 10, Utah eight, and Baylor four.
That Baylor note matters, especially when looking back at the 2021 Big 12 champion that finished 11-1. If that team had been given a place in a 24-team field, it opens the door to some fascinating what-ifs.
Were they the best team in the country? A format like this would have had a real shot at answering that.
Still, the larger issue is what a 24-team playoff would do to the sport around the bracket. The source of the change is hard to ignore: this is about money.
More media rights. More inventory.
More games that can be sold, packaged, and monetized.
There’s also the question of how the field would actually be chosen. It isn’t clear whether the new setup would require automatic spots from each conference or operate as a straight top-24 free-for-all.
Looking back at a hypothetical 24-team bracket for 2025 makes the concern even clearer. A field that large would not be packed with elite teams from top to bottom. Some early matchups would look a lot like conference championship rematches, and repeat games from title weekends could show up right away.
That’s the promise and the problem with this kind of expansion. The perennial powers would benefit.
Smaller programs could still break through from time to time. But the climb from No. 24 to No. 1 is still a long one, and the sport would have to decide whether more access is worth what it takes away.
In Other News...
TCU Just Sent Baylor A Message Fans Needed To See
TCU walked out of McLane Stadium with a 17-6 win over Baylor, and it was the kind of result Horned Frogs fans have been waiting to see in this rivalry. Baylor had won four straight in the series, but TCU leaned on a defense that set the tone early and kept the Bears from ever finding much rhythm on offense.
Koron Hayward was a constant problem in the backfield, helping pressure Baylor throughout the night, while Jaden Craig gave the Frogs enough balance on offense to control the game. Craig connected on key throws, including a long strike to Jordan Dwyer, and finished with two touchdown passes as TCU improved to 4-1 against Baylor under Sonny Dykes. [Read more 🡒]
Baylor Fans Still Havent Forgotten These Revivalry Gut Punches And Highs
The Revivalry has spent plenty of time living up to its name, with Baylor and TCU trading blows in games that have shaped the modern feel of the matchup. From Robert Griffin IIIs 2011 showcase to the tense, back-and-forth meetings that have defined the series in recent years, the rivalry has been built on the kind of pressure-filled moments that stick with fans long after the final whistle.
Baylor supporters still have reasons to circle this one every season because the stakes never seem to stay ordinary for long. The Bears have been on both ends of the drama, including some especially cruel finishes and a recent breakthrough that reminded everyone just how thin the margin can be between a breakthrough and a gut punch in this series. [Read more 🡒]
Baylor Still Has One Harsh Problem After Rivalry Loss
TCUs latest trip through the Revivalry offered a little of everything the Horned Frogs needed after a rough stretch, and the defensive side set the tone early. The new offensive line setup also gave TCU a different look up front, though the group still had its hands full in run blocking and had to fight through tackles for loss and sacks while the game tilted toward a low-scoring grind.
Baylor, meanwhile, had to sit with the bigger problem that can linger after a rivalry loss: there was not much room for offensive rhythm against a TCU defense that kept making life difficult snap after snap. Hayward was a major part of that pressure, finishing with five tackles and three sacks, and his impact helped make the Horned Frogs return to the win column feel a lot more decisive than the final score alone might suggest. [Read more 🡒]