Yankees Could Lose Their Best Catcher Fix To A Division Rival

With the Yankees and Rays both vying for a coveted All-Star catcher, the trade stakes are higher than ever in the AL East showdown.

The Yankees’ search for catching help could end up turning into a battle with a division rival, and Bleacher Report’s Zachary D. Rymer thinks the Tampa Bay Rays may have the edge.

New York’s need behind the plate is clear. Austin Wells has struggled offensively this season, and the Yankees are looking for an upgrade at catcher. But they may not be the only AL East team with eyes on the same target.

Rymer predicted on Tuesday that the Rays will outbid the Yankees for Hunter Goodman of the Colorado Rockies.

“If nothing else, though, here's why this fit is perfect: Goodman's 30 homers through 93 games this year is more than the Rays have gotten from their catchers in the last three seasons combined,” Rymer wrote.

Goodman has put together a big season, hitting 30 home runs with an .881 OPS in 93 games. He is under club control through the 2029 season, so Colorado does not have to move him. The Rockies will have to decide whether they see the 26-year-old as part of their future or as a trade chip.

“He must decide whether Hunter Goodman [Paul DePodesta] is a can't-miss building block, or a can't-miss trade chip. There are surely more than a couple teams crossing their fingers for the latter,” Rymer added. “With back-to-back All-Star selections to his name and 30 home runs already this year, Goodman is theoretically the prized hitter on the market.”

If Goodman does become available, both the Yankees and Rays have a straightforward need at catcher. The question, as Rymer sees it, is which club is willing to make the strongest offer.

In Other News...

This Rays Outfield Breakout Could Change Everything At The Deadline

The Rays needed a lift after getting swept in Boston and watching a five-game skid hang over the club, and they finally found one in the win over Toronto. The offense has been searching for a steadier spark, and Victor Mesa Jr. has given it exactly that, bringing left-handed pop and useful all-around play after coming over from the Marlins.

Mesas surge has been hard to ignore, with eight home runs and enough production to make him look like more than a short-term patch. He has also helped on the defensive side, which matters for a Tampa Bay club still trying to sort out the rest of its roster before the deadline, and his emergence could shape how aggressively the Rays attack their other needs. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Suddenly Have A Serious Market For One All-Star Bat

The Rays came out of the All-Star break in rough shape, getting swept in four games by the Red Sox and reminding everyone how uneven the offense can look when the pitching staff does its part. Tampa Bay still has real strength in the rotation, but the lineup has been harder to trust, especially on the infield side where second base has been a sore spot since Brandon Lowe was dealt away over the winter.

That is why the trade market around San Franciscos Luis Arraez has started to draw attention from some analysts as the deadline approaches. Arraez would fit the kind of contact-driven profile Tampa Bay often values, and with his contract situation putting him on the move radar, the price may not be prohibitive. For now, though, it remains one of those names that makes sense on paper while the Rays sort out how aggressive they want to be. [Read more 🡒]