The Brewers are one win into the World Series and already have the upper hand after Friday night’s 3-2 win over the Rays at American Family Field. Tampa Bay had a chance to walk it off after a replay review wiped out what looked like a game-ending double play, but the extra life didn’t turn into a comeback. Jonny DeLuca struck out to finish it.
Kevin Cash said the challenge came after the close call on the field.
"My thought was it looked like a close play," Rays manager Kevin Cash said about the overturned double play. "(Video coordinator) Nick Rogers did a good job of recognizing that it was really close. In the moment, I don't think he thought too strongly about it, but at that point why not challenge it?"
Milwaukee now leads the series 1-0, and history is on its side: teams that take Game 1 in a best-of-seven have gone on to win the series 65% of the time. Still, the picture is hardly settled. The Dodgers were routed in last year’s Game 1 before coming back to beat the Blue Jays in seven, so the Brewers’ early edge does not make this a finished product.
Saturday night’s Game 2 brings three obvious pressure points.
The biggest one starts with Drew Rasmussen. Tampa Bay held him back from Game 1 and sent him out instead with extra rest, even though the workload question is more about the calendar than anything else. Rasmussen rarely worked on four days’ rest in the regular season - only seven of his 30 starts came on that schedule - and he hasn’t done it at all in the postseason.
"We prioritized Drew getting an extra day," Cash explained Thursday. "He's had a pretty thick workload here.
We've relied on him heavily. We know when he takes the ball, we're trying to get the full pitch allotment out of him."
He has looked every bit like the Rays’ ace lately. In three postseason starts, Rasmussen has allowed just three runs and 16 baserunners in 21 innings while striking out 23.
Tampa Bay needs that version again. Falling behind 2-0 would put a massive burden on the Rays, and it is difficult to picture them taking four of the next six without Rasmussen carrying Game 2.
Cash also kept his top relievers - Bryan Baker, Cam Booser, and Tyler Wells - out of the Game 1 push, and all three should be available Saturday for four or five outs if needed. Even so, Tampa’s best route is simple: Rasmussen does the heavy lifting and gives the bullpen a shorter night.
The next question is whether anyone outside the top of the order is going to do damage. Game 1 was the first World Series opener since 2000 with no home runs, which fits the shape of these two clubs.
Milwaukee finished 29th in homers during the regular season, while Tampa Bay was 22nd. Both lineups lean hard on their stars and have role players lower down who are asked to chip in any way they can.
The first four hitters for each team showed up Friday. Jackson Chourio, Jake Bauers, Christian Yelich, and William Contreras carried the Brewers, while Yandy Díaz, Jonathan Aranda, Chandler Simpson, and Junior Caminero did the same for the Rays. Beyond that group, the production fell off fast.
For Milwaukee, the 1-2-3-4 hitters went 6 for 15 with three RBI, a triple, and a walk. The rest of the lineup managed just 2 for 15 with a double and three walks. Tampa’s top four were 6 for 14 with a double and a walk, but the rest of the order went 1 for 17 with two RBI and a walk.
Liam Hicks did drive in both Rays runs, but both came on RBI groundouts, and both times the tying run was sitting at second. That counts, but only barely. At some point, one of these clubs is going to need a real hit from outside the heart of the order.
Milwaukee looks better built for that kind of contribution. During the regular season, the Brewers ranked second in batting average from the 7-8-9 spots at .248 and third in on-base percentage at .318.
Tampa Bay was far less productive there, hitting .228 with a .303 OBP, both lower-tier marks. The stars are doing the heavy lifting for both teams, but the club that gets something from the bottom of the lineup may end up owning the series.
Then there’s the running game, and that one already tilted toward Milwaukee in Game 1. Tampa Bay finished 2 for 4 stealing bases, though that line comes with some context.
The two successful steals came together in a double steal in the ninth, when Brewers closer Trevor Megill was locked in on the batter. The two caught stealings earlier in the game told a different story.
Victor Mesa Jr. was thrown out trying to steal third to end the fifth inning with Díaz at the plate, and Cash called that play part of an aggressive attempt to force the issue.
"Ultimately, Victor is really competing," Cash said after Game 1. "Trying to do something to make something happen, put a little pressure on the defense, and it didn't work in our favor."
The other caught stealing was easier to live with. Aranda went on a 3-2 count with Simpson at the plate, and when Simpson struck out, Aranda was cut down. Simpson had already struck out twice in Game 1, after striking out once earlier this postseason, so that one was more bad timing than bad decision.
Still, the Rays are dealing with a difficult matchup behind the plate. Contreras presents a major problem for runners, and Milwaukee has the kind of catching setup that can shut down a running game in a hurry. In Game 1, Contreras threw out both runners when he actually had to make a throw, and he also turned in two hits while helping snuff out two rallies with his arm.
The Brewers only stole one base Friday, and that runner never scored. But they know there are opportunities against Hicks and backup catcher Nick Fortes.
Tampa Bay’s challenge is different. Without the extra 90 feet, manufacturing runs gets much tougher, especially with Contreras controlling the game behind the plate.
"He's a very talented player on both sides of the ball," Cash said about Contreras. "We knew that coming in. Not surprised by anything that he did, but that's not going to change our aggressive approach, certainly on the bases."
In Other News...
Rays Let World Series Opener Slip After Ninth-Inning Rally
Milwaukee set the tone early and never quite let Tampa Bay fully settle into the opener, cashing in for two runs in the first inning before adding another in the seventh. Jacob Misiorowski was at the center of it all, working five innings and allowing just one run in a 78-pitch outing that gave the Brewers a sturdy start in their 3-2 win. The Rays answered with a run in the fourth and then mounted a push late, but the early hole left them having to chase the game all night.
Tampa Bay finally made things interesting in the ninth with a rally that brought the pressure right to the doorstep of the series opener. Trevor Megill was the one who closed the door for Milwaukee, and the Rays are left to sort through a missed chance after getting within striking distance in the final inning. Misiorowski, meanwhile, also delivered the kind of headline pitch that can linger in a World Series opener, even before the final frame settled the result. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Rotation Reset Could Depend On One Costly October-Proven Arm
San Diegos rotation issues have already pushed the Padres toward a winter of hard decisions, with the bullpen carrying too much of the load and a chunk of their potential free agents coming from the starting staff. Seven of their 17 possible free agents are starters, which makes the search for innings an obvious part of the conversation as they try to rebuild a group that can hold up over a full season.
One name that has surfaced in that orbit is Freddy Peralta, the Tampa Bay Rays right-hander whose October work only added to his appeal. He was excellent in the postseason, covering 16.2 innings with a 1.08 ERA and taking home ALCS MVP honors, but any run at a pitcher with that kind of rsum would come with a steep price tag, and for now it remains more of a speculative fit than a concrete move. [Read more 🡒]
Rays Got One Last World Series Lifeline Before It Slipped Away
For a brief moment in Game 1 at American Family Field, the Rays found the door cracked open in a game that already felt like it was slipping away. Milwaukee had a potential game-ending double play in hand late, only for Tampa Bay to challenge the call and get a reprieve when replay showed Brewers shortstop Cooper Pratt had not quite stayed on the bag.
The extra breath did not turn into a turnaround. Tampa Bay still needed to make the most of one final lifeline, and Milwaukees closer made sure it never became a full-blown rally, finishing the night with a strikeout of Jonny DeLuca to close it out. For the Rays, it was the kind of instant replay swing that can briefly change the mood without changing the result. [Read more 🡒]