Rays Let One Brewers Star Take Away Their Biggest Edge

William Contreras's all-around excellence has him leading the Brewers through a thrilling postseason, redefining what it means to be a game-changing catcher.

MILWAUKEE - William Contreras keeps finding ways to put his fingerprints all over this Brewers October run.

He did it again Friday in Milwaukee’s 3-2 win over Tampa Bay in Game 1 of the 2026 World Series, when his impact went far beyond the two singles he collected at the plate. One of those hits drove in the second run of the game in the first inning, giving the Brewers an early jolt. The bigger damage, though, came with his arm and his timing behind the plate.

The Rays came in perfect on the basepaths this postseason, 11 for 11 in stolen-base attempts. For two innings, Contreras shut that door.

In the fifth, Victor Mesa Jr. singled to open the frame against Jacob Misiorowski and eventually moved to third with two outs. With Yandy Díaz hitting and Mesa trying to steal on an 0-2 count, Contreras cut him down at third with a sharp throw.

A few innings later, Tampa Bay tried again. With Abner Uribe on the mound in the sixth, Chandler Simpson struck out on a back-foot slider while Jonathan Aranda broke for second. Contreras handled the pitch cleanly and gunned Aranda down to finish the inning-ending double play.

Contreras didn’t hide what his mindset was in the moment.

"I think in today's game I took defense over offense," Contreras said through a team translator. "Some of the plays there, I think there were some close plays with runners on third, but scoring opportunities for them.

"God was able to gift me that one today, a complete game on both sides. But my goal is to go out there and find a way to win the game, whether that be offensively or defensively."

Pat Murphy made it clear afterward that this has been a theme all month, not a one-night spike.

"If people aren't noticing Contreras, like he was maybe the MVP of the Dodgers series," Brewers manager Pat Murphy said after the game. "It should have been co-MVPS.He was maybe MVP of the Padres series. I don't think they pick one for that, do they?"

They don't.

But the way Contreras has controlled games this October makes the debate easy to understand. He isn’t carrying the Brewers because they need carrying. He’s making a team that has already been excellent even harder to beat.

That’s been true at the plate, especially with runners on base, and it’s been true behind it, where he has taken command of the game and of his pitchers. At 28, he has said the leadership piece was something he wanted to sharpen this season.

More voice. More presence.

More control over the pace of everything around him.

In the eighth inning Friday, that leadership showed up in a mound visit that Aaron Ashby called “quite frankly a one-way conversation.” Ashby had just seen a curveball sail behind Victor Mesa Jr. and carom off the backstop, and Contreras stepped in with the kind of directness the moment required.

"I was doing the listening. I needed to hear what he was saying.

He knows the right time to speak and what to put down. He was unbelievable."

Ashby got out of the inning with a strikeout and a groundout.

That sort of response has been the Brewers’ calling card all season. They won 103 games, and their only loss since Oct. 6 came against the Padres in the NLDS.

They’ve already beaten a lot of top-end pitching on this run, including Tarik Skubal, Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Blake Snell against the Dodgers. In Game 4, they even made Tyler Glasnow look like a bulk reliever.

Nothing has knocked them off course yet, not the Padres, not the Dodgers, and not the Rays in a game that unfolded much the same way the Brewers’ postseason has all along: different contributors, same edge.

Now Milwaukee is three wins from a title, with Saturday evening set to bring Tampa Bay ace Drew Rasmussen against Logan Henderson. But for this Brewers group, the label “ace” doesn’t seem to carry much weight.

Contreras is part of the reason why. He keeps shaping these games in every direction, with his bat, with his arm, and with the kind of control that settles a dugout and rattles a running game.

In Other News...

Rays Let World Series Opener Slip After Ninth-Inning Rally

Milwaukee set the tone early and never quite let Tampa Bay fully settle into the opener, cashing in for two runs in the first inning before adding another in the seventh. Jacob Misiorowski was at the center of it all, working five innings and allowing just one run in a 78-pitch outing that gave the Brewers a sturdy start in their 3-2 win. The Rays answered with a run in the fourth and then mounted a push late, but the early hole left them having to chase the game all night.

Tampa Bay finally made things interesting in the ninth with a rally that brought the pressure right to the doorstep of the series opener. Trevor Megill was the one who closed the door for Milwaukee, and the Rays are left to sort through a missed chance after getting within striking distance in the final inning. Misiorowski, meanwhile, also delivered the kind of headline pitch that can linger in a World Series opener, even before the final frame settled the result. [Read more 🡒]

Padres Rotation Reset Could Depend On One Costly October-Proven Arm

San Diegos rotation issues have already pushed the Padres toward a winter of hard decisions, with the bullpen carrying too much of the load and a chunk of their potential free agents coming from the starting staff. Seven of their 17 possible free agents are starters, which makes the search for innings an obvious part of the conversation as they try to rebuild a group that can hold up over a full season.

One name that has surfaced in that orbit is Freddy Peralta, the Tampa Bay Rays right-hander whose October work only added to his appeal. He was excellent in the postseason, covering 16.2 innings with a 1.08 ERA and taking home ALCS MVP honors, but any run at a pitcher with that kind of rsum would come with a steep price tag, and for now it remains more of a speculative fit than a concrete move. [Read more 🡒]

Rays Got One Last World Series Lifeline Before It Slipped Away

For a brief moment in Game 1 at American Family Field, the Rays found the door cracked open in a game that already felt like it was slipping away. Milwaukee had a potential game-ending double play in hand late, only for Tampa Bay to challenge the call and get a reprieve when replay showed Brewers shortstop Cooper Pratt had not quite stayed on the bag.

The extra breath did not turn into a turnaround. Tampa Bay still needed to make the most of one final lifeline, and Milwaukees closer made sure it never became a full-blown rally, finishing the night with a strikeout of Jonny DeLuca to close it out. For the Rays, it was the kind of instant replay swing that can briefly change the mood without changing the result. [Read more 🡒]