The Tampa Bay Rays may not have been in on Dustin May, but his reported deal with the Chicago White Sox still lands like a warning shot.
According to multiple reports, May has agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with Chicago, a price tag that says plenty about where the starting-pitching market could be headed. For Tampa Bay, that matters because the Rays are already staring at an offseason with real holes to fill in the rotation.
May’s 2026 season was a mixed bag. He went 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA over 31 starts between the St.
Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers, while also piling up 144 strikeouts in 145.2 innings. Those innings and starts were both career highs.
But the finish with Milwaukee was rough, as he posted a 5.65 ERA in 10 regular-season starts after the trade.
Even with that uneven profile, Chicago still committed $17.5 million per year to the right-hander. That kind of money is exactly why the Rays have to be careful. May has dealt with injuries during his career, and he hasn’t exactly built a track record of steady production as a starter.
That’s the backdrop for Tampa Bay’s offseason. Nick Martinez and Freddy Peralta are both headed for free agency, and that leaves Erik Neander with some tough choices. Drew Rasmussen is expected to remain a major part of the 2027 rotation, but the Rays still need more dependable arms to get through a full season.
Shane McClanahan could be another answer, though his status is still clouded by injury concerns. Beyond that, Neander may have to look inside the farm system, where Brody Hopkins is among the names in the mix. But counting on young pitchers alone to replace Martinez and Peralta would be a dangerous gamble.
May would have fit a need, but the contract he reportedly got from the White Sox makes clear why Tampa Bay likely stayed away. At $17.5 million a season, he was probably never going to be a realistic target for the Rays.
If his deal is any sign of what the rest of the market will look like, Neander may need to get creative. One path could be bringing Martinez back on a manageable deal, especially with his reputation for giving innings. Tampa Bay has shown it can identify and develop pitching, but the organization still has to find enough reliable starters to stay in the hunt for another American League East title.
In Other News...
Rays Could Target An Outfield Fix For One Lingering Lineup Problem
The Rays search for a little more balance in the lineup could send them back to the outfield market, where Marc Topkin of the Tampa Bay Times floated Tyrone Taylor as a possible fit. Taylor brings a familiar kind of appeal for Tampa Bay: defensive versatility, major league experience with the Brewers, Mets and Cubs, and enough athleticism to give a roster some flexibility without forcing a major overhaul.
What makes Taylor interesting for the Rays is the specific hole he might help patch. Tampa Bay has been looking for more offensive support against left-handed pitching, and Taylors improved production in that split gives him a plausible path onto the radar. He is a free agent after the 2026 season, so any move would be about fit as much as upside, with the Rays weighing whether he can help solve one lingering lineup problem. [Read more 🡒]
Rays Just Sent A Clear Message About Xavier Isaac
The Rays made their intentions clear this week by adding first base prospect Xavier Isaac to the 40-man roster, a move that protects him from the Rule 5 Draft and keeps one of the organizations most intriguing young bats in the fold. Isaac, a 2022 first-round pick, has already shown the kind of power that made him a notable name in the system, and his path back to the field has carried even more weight after he overcame a brain tumor and surgery before returning in 2023.
For Tampa Bay, the decision also says plenty about where Isaac stands in the clubs long-term plans. The roster move leaves the Rays with a full 40-man roster and forces them to expose several other prospects to the draft, a reminder of how much the organization values Isaacs upside. In a system built on hard choices, this was one of the easier ones. [Read more 🡒]
Richie Palacios Is Giving Brooklyn Kids What He Never Had
Joshua and Richie Palacios brought their annual Built Different Baseball Camp back to Brooklyn this week, drawing more than 200 children for a free day of baseball instruction and encouragement. The event, supported by The Players Trust, brought together Major League and Minor League players, college students and local coaches with a simple goal: give New York City kids a real chance to learn the game and see a path in it.
For the Palacios brothers, the camp is about more than drills and fundamentals. It is a response to the obstacles young players in the city often face, from limited access to fields and equipment to fewer chances to be seen and developed. In Brooklyn, the turnout showed how much that kind of opportunity matters, and why the brothers keep making the trip home to provide it. [Read more 🡒]
