Before Adley Rutschman ever landed with the Red Sox at the trade deadline, the Orioles had already floated him to two other division rivals - and the Yankees were one of them.
According to Jon Heyman of the New York Post, Baltimore was prepared to send Rutschman to the Bronx in a four-player return built around Austin Wells, Elmer Rodriguez, outfield prospect Yostin Pena, and either Ryan Weathers or Will Warren. New York passed on the idea, with Heyman saying Pena was “one big sticking point” in the talks. Heyman characterized the Orioles’ approach as a final chance for the Yankees and Rays to beat Boston’s offer, though it isn’t clear whether that four-player framework was Baltimore’s last ask.
The deal that eventually sent Rutschman and fellow backstop Jake Rogers to Boston looked very different. The Red Sox sent catcher Carlos Narvaez, prospects Anthony Eyanson, Enddy Azocar, and Kyson Witherspoon, plus a player to be named later who turned out to be outfield prospect Harold Rivas.
That package leaned much more toward the future, with all of the prospects still at least a year away from the majors. Baltimore’s proposed Yankees return, by contrast, would have brought in players who could have helped right away.
Wells and Weathers or Warren would have been immediate roster fits, and Rodriguez already made his MLB debut this season.
The timing mattered, too. On Deadline Day, August 3, the Orioles were still only 2.5 games out of a wild card spot despite a 54-58 record.
Trading Rutschman for that Yankees package would have been a true buy-and-sell move, not the pure seller’s posture Baltimore eventually settled into. The Orioles wound up dealing away Dean Kremer, Tyler Wells, and Rutschman in the Boston trade, and the rest of the season reflected the club’s uneven identity.
They stayed around the wild card picture for much of the year in a weak American League, then finished 79-83 after running hot and cold in equal measure.
From the Yankees’ side, the decision to walk away at least looks sensible in the short term. Wells’ offense picked up late, and over his final 138 plate appearances he hit .231/.341/.444 with seven homers after opening the year at .161/.265/.272 in his first 250 plate appearances. Rutschman, meanwhile, hit .222/.278/.410 in 126 plate appearances for Boston after the trade.
Rutschman remains under arbitration control through 2027 and still carries the higher ceiling on paper, helped by the fact that he was named to his third All-Star team just this summer. But most of that production came in a brilliant first six weeks, and the rest of his recent track record has been clouded by injuries and prolonged slumps. That uncertainty now follows him into 2027, especially after his limited production with the Red Sox.
The other names in the rejected package also come with their own appeal. Weathers is under arbitration control through 2028, and Warren through 2030.
Rodriguez was drawing top-100 prospect buzz heading into the 2026 season, while Pena, who turns 19 later this month, flashed power and speed in his first pro season after moving from the Dominican Summer League to A-ball. And from Baltimore’s perspective, Wells may have been viewed as a stopgap anyway, since moving Rutschman also cleared the way for Samuel Basallo to take over as the Orioles’ full-time catcher.
In Other News...
Rays Just Sent Yankees A Clear Message With This Game 2 Move
After opening the American League Division Series with a 1-0 win over the Yankees, the Rays are sticking with a formula built around run prevention and matchup-driven lineup choices. Jonathan Arandas solo homer was enough in Game 1, and the bigger story was the kind of pitching duel Tampa Bay was able to drag Gerrit Cole into alongside Drew Rasmussen, a reminder that this series may come down to slim margins.
For Game 2, Tampa Bays lineup sent a message of its own by going with DeLuca over Mullins against Yankees right-hander Cam Schlittler. It is the sort of decision that reflects how the Rays operate at this time of year, favoring current form and specific history over reputation, even with Mullins having arrived as a notable offseason addition. [Read more 🡒]
Kevin Cash Sent Rays Fans A Very Different October Message
Kevin Cashs latest October message to Rays fans was a familiar one, even if the setting made it feel a little louder: trust your people. In Game 1 of the ALDS, Cash let Drew Rasmussen keep dealing deep into the night, and the right-hander rewarded him with eight scoreless innings, 10 strikeouts and almost nothing to work with for the Yankees.
It was the kind of postseason decision that can define a series before it really starts, especially for a Rays team that has long been built around pitching judgment and nerve. After Rasmussen finished his job, Bryan Baker was asked to finish it off, and he did just that by striking out a key Yankees hitter to seal the 1-0 win and give Tampa Bay an early edge. [Read more 🡒]
Chandler Simpson Is Giving Rays Fans A New Reason To Believe
Chandler Simpson has quickly become one of the more intriguing reasons for optimism around the Rays, and not just because of what he does at the plate. The left fielder has taken a major step forward defensively, going from a minus-9 defensive runs saved season in 2025 to an 8 this year, a jump that has helped round out a profile that already stood out for its contact skills and speed. First-base coach Corey Dickerson has been part of that growth, and the improvement has given Tampa Bay a player who is affecting games in more than one phase.
Offensively, Simpson has kept forcing opposing clubs to adjust, and Rays manager Kevin Cash has pointed to his ability to adapt as defenses and pitch plans change around him. Simpson finished second in the American League batting average race and led the league in multi-hit games and singles, production that makes him a problem even when teams think they have the right approach. For a Rays club always looking for the next edge, Simpson is becoming the kind of everyday difference-maker that can shift the tone around the roster. [Read more 🡒]