Yordan Alvarez is still sitting on the American League throne in our latest MVP poll, but the National League picture finally got flipped on its head.
A total of 37 MLB.com experts submitted ballots for the awards race, with 33 players getting at least one vote. The poll wasn’t based only on what has already happened; voters also weighed how they expect the rest of the season to unfold. Each ballot ranked five players in each league on a 5-4-3-2-1 system.
In the AL, Alvarez keeps stretching the gap. Even in what counts as his worst month of the season by wRC+, he’s posted a 138 mark in August, which is still 38% better than league average.
That kind of production is a big reason he’s held the lead for so long, especially since Aaron Judge went down with an injury in late May. Alvarez is also in the thick of a Triple Crown chase, leading the league in batting average at .320, home runs with 36 and RBIs with 90.
Junior Caminero remains the clear No. 2, even without a first-place vote this time. The Rays’ 23-year-old has become the biggest force behind their push to the top of the AL East, and his numbers keep climbing: a career-best .895 OPS, an 11.8% walk rate and a looming second straight 40-homer season. He’s stayed in second place for the second straight poll because enough voters kept piling him high on their ballots.
Bobby Witt Jr. checks in at third and still looks like the most complete player in the league behind Alvarez. He leads the American League in both FanGraphs and Baseball-Reference WAR at 6.2, while Alvarez sits at 5.8 fWAR and 5.7 bWAR. Witt’s 18 Fielding Run Value leads the AL, and his .822 OPS keeps him firmly in the mix as one of the game’s best all-around players.
Willson Contreras lands fourth, giving Boston another name in the race as the club powers toward the postseason. His towering 452-foot shot over the Green Monster last Friday was one of a career-high 26 homers, but the bigger point is how central he’s been to the Red Sox’s turnaround. Contreras is tied with Pete Crow-Armstrong at a 156 wRC+, second in the Majors only to Alvarez’s 185.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. rounds out the AL top five. He did not get a first-place vote for the first time since the season’s first MVP poll, and fifth is the lowest he’s finished so far. His second-half .602 OPS has cooled the buzz, but 34 home runs is still 34 home runs, and he’s helped keep the Yankees within striking distance of the Rays in the AL East while they wait for Judge to return.
The National League, though, is where the real shakeup hit.
Pete Crow-Armstrong has surged to the top of the poll for the first time, taking advantage of Shohei Ohtani’s absence on the mound. The Cubs center fielder now leads the MLB in WAR and has matched Ohtani’s bat with a run that’s been just as loud, while also providing an MLB-best 24 FRV in center.
Since Ohtani’s last start on July 3, Crow-Armstrong has outpaced him in wRC+ (171 to 149), home runs (14 to 12) and OPS (1.014 to .948). He even added a leadoff and walk-off homer in the same game against the White Sox earlier this week.
Ohtani still isn’t going anywhere. He finished second with 154 total points and eight first-place votes, and he’s closing in on a return to pitching, with a start during the Dodgers’ next homestand in view.
If he’s healthy and can build on the 8-2 record and 1.79 ERA from his first 14 starts, Crow-Armstrong’s grip on the top spot may not last long. At the plate, Ohtani remains elite, ranking second in the NL in OPS at .935, tied for fifth in home runs with 30 and tied for sixth in RBIs with 80.
Kyle Schwarber is right there in third as the Phillies keep rolling. Philadelphia has won nine straight and is pushing toward the Braves in the NL East and the Cubs for the top NL Wild Card spot.
Schwarber has homered four times during the streak, including the two blasts he delivered in the MLB at Field of Dreams Game. He now has an MLB-leading 39 home runs and looks likely to reach his fourth 40-homer season.
Jacob Misiorowski comes in fourth after one of the most eye-catching pitching seasons in recent memory. His 248 ERA+ is more than 50 points better than the next pitcher, Cam Schlittler at 194, and he leads the majors with 216 strikeouts. Pitchers haven’t won MVP since Clayton Kershaw in 2014, outside of Ohtani’s two-way seasons, but Misiorowski has at least forced his way into the conversation.
Matt Olson is back in the NL top five after narrowly missing out the last two times. He’s been the top hitter on a Braves club that’s found its form again, and he’s on pace for his second 40-homer season.
Olson also continues to give Atlanta Gold Glove-caliber defense at first base and, as MLB’s current Iron Man, has literally played every day. His .864 OPS would be his best since the .993 mark he put up during his 54-homer 2023 season.
Others receiving votes in the AL: Dillon Dingler, Tigers; Kevin McGonigle, Tigers; Pete Alonso, Orioles; Miguel Vargas, White Sox; Cam Schlittler, Yankees; Munetaka Murakami, White Sox; Dylan Cease, Blue Jays; Yandy Díaz, Rays; Ceddanne Rafaela, Red Sox.
Others receiving votes in the NL: James Wood, Nationals; CJ Abrams, Nationals; Jordan Walker, Cardinals; Brice Turang, Brewers; Cristopher Sánchez, Phillies; Corbin Carroll, Diamondbacks; Jake Bauers, Brewers; Otto Lopez, Marlins; Andy Pages, Dodgers; Bryce Harper, Phillies; Fernando Tatis Jr., Padres; Chris Sale, Braves; Gabriel Moreno, Diamondbacks; JJ Wetherholt, Cardinals.
In Other News...
Rays May Have A Bullpen Boost They Still Can't Fit
Ty Johnsons move from the rotation to the bullpen has given the Rays another one of those familiar pitching-development wins they seem to find whenever a starter gets repurposed. The right-hander has seen his fastball tick up to around 94 mph, and the sharper command has come with it, along with a breaking ball that now plays more like a cutter and has helped him generate more whiffs in August.
The problem for Tampa Bay is not whether Johnson has looked more useful in relief. It is finding a place for him, both on the 40-man roster and in a bullpen that is already tight enough to make every call-up and recall a small roster puzzle. With injured pitchers beginning to edge closer to returning, the Rays may soon have to make a move just to create the room a promising arm like Johnson appears to deserve. [Read more 🡒]
Rays Stadium Push Just Hit A Crucial Turning Point
After months of wrangling over how to pay for a new ballpark, the Rays appear to have cleared a pivotal local hurdle. Tampa City Council member Bill Carlson has now moved into support of the revised financing plan, giving the project the swing vote it needed as the team continues its push for a stadium deal that has been one of the regions biggest sports and civic debates.
The timing matters because the next steps are lined up in sequence: the city council and Community Redevelopment Agency are set to vote on the related agreements before the Hillsborough County Commission weighs in, assuming the city gives its approval. Rays CEO Ken Babby has been working local leaders through the economic case and the updated funding structure built around new tax revenues, but the plan still has to survive the formal votes ahead before it can move from political momentum to reality. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Just Added More Pressure To A Slipping Rays Team
The Rays still sit atop the American League East with a three-game cushion over the Yankees, but the margin for comfort has shrunk a bit after a rough week. Tampa Bay went 3-4 and came away with series losses to both the Blue Jays and Orioles, the kind of skid that can change the feel of a division race even when a team remains in first place.
Now the schedule offers a chance to steady things quickly, with the Tigers and Padres on tap in a six-game stretch this week. A strong showing would help Tampa Bay regain some momentum and remind the rest of the AL East that the division lead is still theirs to protect. [Read more 🡒]