Joe Maddon’s Hall of Fame case starts in Tampa Bay, not Chicago.
Yes, the Cubs’ 108-year title drought is the headline moment most fans remember. But Maddon’s run with the Rays is where his résumé really took shape, and it’s a big reason he’s now on the Contemporary Baseball Era ballot for the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame class. He’s one of eight candidates up for consideration.
When Maddon arrived in 2006, the Rays were still searching for their first winning season since entering the league in 1998. The early results didn’t exactly announce a turnaround. Tampa Bay went 61-101 in 2006, then improved only to 66-96 in 2007.
Then came 2008, and everything changed.
The Rays jumped to 97-65, a 31-win improvement that delivered the franchise’s first American League East title. They followed that by beating the Boston Red Sox in the American League Championship Series and reaching the World Series for the first time in team history. Tampa Bay lost to the Philadelphia Phillies, but the bar for the organization had already been reset.
Maddon was rewarded with his first American League Manager of the Year Award after that season, but the bigger statement came over time. The Rays didn’t just flash once under his watch.
They stayed relevant. Tampa Bay reached the postseason four times during his tenure and won another AL East title in 2010.
Even more telling, the Rays put together six straight winning seasons from 2008 through 2013 while going up against some of baseball’s biggest spenders. Maddon finished his nine years in Tampa Bay with a 754-705 record, a mark that firmly places him among the most successful managers in franchise history.
His next stop only strengthened the Hall of Fame argument. Maddon took over the Cubs in 2015, won his third Manager of the Year Award in his first season, and then helped Chicago end its 108-year championship drought the next year. By the time his managerial career was over, he had 1,382 wins, eight postseason appearances and three Manager of the Year Awards.
That’s a strong case. But it won’t be an easy one.
Maddon is on a ballot that also includes Dusty Baker, Bruce Bochy and former Rays manager Lou Piniella. To get in, a candidate needs at least 12 votes from the 16-member committee. The results will be announced December 6.
Maddon may not match some of the others in raw wins or championships, but the stretch he built in Tampa Bay still stands as a major part of his Hall of Fame story.
In Other News...
Rays Fans Wont Love Where This Former Tampa Bay Bat Landed
Jake Bauers is headed back into the American League East, and this time it comes with a twist Rays fans probably wont enjoy. After helping the Milwaukee Brewers win the World Series and earning National League Championship Series MVP honors along the way, Bauers reportedly agreed to a four-year, $58 million deal with the Boston Red Sox, giving a division rival a proven left-handed bat.
For Tampa Bay, it is another reminder of how quickly the offseason can reshape the balance of power in the division. Boston is clearly looking to strengthen its lineup, and adding a player who just played a major role in a championship run only raises the stakes for everyone else in the AL East. [Read more 🡒]
Rays Have A Real Snub Debate After Awards Night
The Rays had one of those seasons that usually leaves some hardware in the case, but awards night went by without a single trophy for Tampa Bay. After finishing with the best record in the American League at 98-64, the club had a presence in several major races, with Junior Caminero, Bryan Baker and Kevin Cash all drawing enough attention to reach finalist status.
Caminero ended up second in AL MVP voting without a first-place vote, Baker placed third in the reliever race and Cash was runner-up for Manager of the Year, yet none of them walked away with the prize. For a team that spent the year stacking wins and putting together one of the leagues strongest resumes, the blank finish across the board only sharpened the debate over how the Rays were viewed compared with the rest of the American League. [Read more 🡒]
Junior Caminero Just Put The Rays In Rare MVP Company
Junior Caminero did not take home the American League MVP award, but his runner-up finish still put the Rays in a place they do not visit often. The Baseball Writers Association of America announced the 2026 winner as Houstons Yordan Alvarez, with Kansas Citys Bobby Witt Jr. third, and Camineros second-place showing gave Tampa Bay a real seat at the table in a race dominated by star power.
For a Rays club that has long built around development and value, having one of its own finish that high in the voting says plenty about where Caminero has arrived. Alvarezs season was the standard, with a .316/.432/.601 line and league-leading marks across the board, but Camineros place just behind him gives Tampa Bay a fresh reminder that its next wave can still break through on the sports biggest individual stage. [Read more 🡒]