Cam Schlittler spent Monday night trying to survive the Yankees’ mistakes, then made sure nobody could mistake where he thought the blame belonged.
New York’s rookie right-hander took the ball in Game 2 of the American League Division Series with the Yankees already staring at a must-have response after a 1-0 loss in Game 1. Instead, Tampa Bay rolled to a 5-2 win and a 2-0 series lead, and Schlittler’s postgame comments turned as sharp as anything in the box score.
“I’m not disappointed in our defense. I’m not disappointed in the offense.
Really just disappointed in myself. That’s baseball, and those things are gonna happen.
But I’ve got to be able to work through those. I wasn’t able to do that today,” Schlittler said.
That was the tone all night: the Yankees made errors, Schlittler absorbed the damage, and then he refused to let anyone else carry the burden for him. New York committed four errors and had several other defensive lapses, but Schlittler kept circling back to his own outing.
“Obviously, it starts with me,” Schlittler said. “I’ll be the first one to say that I didn’t do my job, but it didn’t seem like we really showed up today.
So that’s what happens. They played really good baseball and took advantage of those opportunities.”
“We expect a lot out of each other. It’s been great all year, but we just didn’t play our brand of baseball,” Schlittler said.
Aaron Boone took the opposite tack, saying his starter kept bailing out the defense.
“He battled,” Boone said. “Obviously, [he] picked us up kind of all night.
It’s just hard to do that time after time. Too many free outs out there or free baserunners.”
Boone added, “But Cam did his job. We didn’t give him a good enough chance to really do his job.”
The game opened with a mess. Ryan McMahon committed an error on the second pitch, Jazz Chisholm Jr. made a throwing error trying to finish a double play, and Austin Wells was charged with catcher’s interference. Even so, Schlittler got through the first inning with just one unearned run, throwing 17 of 19 pitches for strikes.
But the trouble kept coming. Two miscues by rookie shortstop George Lombard Jr. helped Tampa Bay push across four runs, and Richie Palacios capped that burst with a two-run single off Brent Headrick.
Schlittler’s numbers told the same story as his words. Statcast had his whiff rate at 16%, far below the marks he posted in his three regular-season starts against Tampa Bay, when he had whiff rates of 39%, 38% and 29% and a 2.81 ERA. His fastball mix wasn’t getting the usual swing-and-miss either, with a 10% whiff rate on the four-seamer, 14% on the sinker and 11% on the cutter.
He finished with two strikeouts, matching a career low, and seven swings and misses. Of the 19 balls the Rays put in play, 11 were hard-hit. He also needed 41 pitches to get through two innings, and two of his four runs were unearned.
This was not a pitcher arriving cold. Schlittler had already shoved Tampa Bay aside on July 6 at Tropicana Field, firing eight innings of one-run ball with three hits, eight strikeouts and no walks.
That night, after hearing talk that he was slipping, he said, “They want to say there’s regression because I have one bad outing. It was personal to go out there and just have a dominant start.”
Tampa Bay knew exactly what it was up against then. First baseman Jonathan Aranda said, “When you pair that with 100 mph, and then he’s doing it consistently one through eight innings, it’s tough to square up,” Aranda said.
Schlittler had also been sharp in the wild-card opener against Boston, striking out 10 and getting 24 swings and misses over 6 1/3 scoreless innings.
But Monday was different. The Yankees’ defense kept handing him more outs to escape, and the Rays kept cashing them in. New York is now one loss from elimination, and the math is brutal: teams that have gone up 2-0 in a best-of-five have advanced 83 of 93 times.
Max Fried (5-5, 2.80 ERA) is lined up to face Nick Martinez (15-6, 3.10) in Game 3 at 8 p.m. EDT Wednesday at Yankee Stadium.
“It’s going to be a rough ride back,” Boone said. “You’ve got to find out what you’re made of. It’s gut-check time.”
The Yankees need three straight to keep going.
In Other News...
Rays Now Face Another Pitching Decision With Aaron Brooks
Aaron Brooks is back on the market after electing minor league free agency, adding another layer to a Rays pitching picture that has already been shaped by injuries and roster churn. Brooks appeared in one major league game for Tampa Bay in 2026 before a season-ending injury sent him back to the margins of the organization, and most of his year was spent in Triple-A Durham.
For the Rays, the move leaves yet another decision to make on a depth arm who never really got a chance to establish himself. Brooks was one of five players, along with Bailey Falter, Seth Martinez, Aramis Garcia and Owen Miller, to file for minor league free agency, and his path now depends on whether Tampa Bay wants to bring him back into the fold or let him move on elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]
Rays Put Their ALDS Control In Nick Martinezs Biggest Test Yet
Nick Martinez is set to take the ball for the Rays in Game 3 of the American League Division Series against the Yankees, a move that says plenty about how Tampa Bay has viewed his season. Kevin Cash went with Martinez based on the body of work he put together, and now the right-hander gets the kind of October assignment every pitcher wants and every staff leans on when the series starts to tighten.
Across the diamond, the Yankees are expected to counter with Max Fried, even with the left-hander acknowledging he may be waiting on a family development that could arrive any day. For Tampa Bay, the matchup turns into a test of poise as much as stuff, with Martinez asked to help the Rays keep control of a series that is becoming more serious by the hour. [Read more 🡒]
Rays Are Winning This Series With A Pitching Formula Yankees Havent Solved
Through the first two games of the ALDS, the Rays have leaned hard on a pitching plan that has kept the Yankees from ever really settling in. Instead of chasing innings with a parade of relievers, Tampa Bay has asked three of its starters to handle most of the outs, a structure that has let Kevin Cash manage the game with a little more breathing room and a lot less stress on the bullpen.
Freddy Peralta has been a big part of that foundation, giving the staff another arm that has looked sharper since arriving from the Mets and showing the kind of increased velocity that helped him earn AL Pitcher of the Month honors for September. The result has been a staff effort that players and Cash have both praised, even as the bigger question remains whether New York can finally find an answer for a formula that has worked so well so far. [Read more 🡒]