The Rays’ path to a World Series upset, at least in Buster Olney’s view, runs straight through the starting rotation.
Tampa Bay and Milwaukee are set to meet in a Fall Classic that pairs two franchises chasing their first championship. The Brewers enter as the favorite, but Olney believes the Rays can flip the series if their starters keep the games on a tight leash and push deep into the later innings.
Speaking on “Just Baseball Media,” Olney pointed to the same kind of formula Milwaukee used against the Dodgers in the NLCS. The Brewers limited the workload of Los Angeles’ rotation and forced the Dodgers to lean on the bullpen early. Olney spelled it out this way:
“Because the Rays’ starting pitching got deep into games,” Olney said.
He also explained why the Dodgers never really got to fully unleash their top arms in that series:
“What the Brewers did in the National League Championship Series was to mitigate the strength of the Dodgers’ vaunted quartet in their rotation,” Olney said. “Between Tarik Skubal, [Yoshinobu] Yamamoto, Blake Snell and Tyler Glasnow, those four guys combined for 18 innings in that series, less than five innings.”
The game-by-game numbers backed up that point. Skubal worked five innings in Game 1, Yamamoto lasted 2.2 innings in Game 2, Snell went six in Game 3 and Glasnow covered 4.1 in Game 4.
For Tampa Bay, Olney says the blueprint is simple: make that same pressure work in reverse. If the Rays are going to beat Milwaukee, he thinks their starters have to keep the Brewers from turning the series into a bullpen battle.
“To me, if the Rays are going to have a chance, then [Drew] Rasmussen, Freddy Peralta, Griffin Jax, [Nick] Martinez, they have to consistently get that team into the sixth or even the seventh inning,” Olney said. “That is the path through which I think that they would have to go if they’re going to win this series.”
That idea lines up with what Tampa Bay has already shown this postseason. Rasmussen is 2-0 with a 1.29 ERA in three starts.
ALCS MVP Freddy Peralta is 2-0 with a 1.08 ERA in four appearances, including three starts. Martinez, who gets the ball in Game 1, is 1-0 with a 3.00 ERA in two starts.
Olney also sees a bullpen edge for Milwaukee. He said Tampa Bay’s relief corps is good, but not quite the overwhelming unit it has been at its best.
“In part because the soft underbelly of the Rays typically they have absolutely lights-out bullpen, not quite the case,” Olney said. “I think they have a good bullpen, but not totally dominant bullpen that the Brewers have.”
He added: “But if they get consistently see starters into the sixth or seventh inning, then we could be talking about a Rays upset.”
That makes Game 1 especially important, with Martinez taking the mound first as Tampa Bay tries to set the tone against the team that finished with the best regular-season record and swept the Dodgers to get here.
In Other News...
Freddy Peralta Just Gave Rays Fans A Reason To Dream
Freddy Peraltas arrival gave the Rays more than another arm for the stretch run, it gave the organization a potential long-term fit as well. Tampa Bay landed him from the Mets ahead of the 2026 trade deadline, and the fit has apparently been smooth enough that Peralta has already sounded at ease with his new surroundings as the Rays chase a title.
The timing only sharpens the intrigue, with Tampa Bay set to face the Brewers in the World Series and Peralta lined up to start Game 3. For Rays fans, that makes every outing feel bigger than a single October assignment, because the club also has reason to believe this could be more than a one-year stop for a pitcher they just added for the biggest stage. [Read more 🡒]
Rays Trade That Reshaped Two Careers Feels Even Wilder Now
A December 2018 three-team deal keeps looking more consequential with time, even though it was built around the kind of financial housekeeping that usually fades quickly from memory. The Rays, Guardians and Mariners put it together to clear obligations tied to veterans Edwin Encarnacin and Carlos Santana, but the swap also sent prospects into new situations that ended up mattering far beyond the original bookkeeping.
For Tampa Bay, the trade has taken on a different meaning because of how one of those young players developed after arriving. The deal was also finalized under unusual circumstances on the other side of it, with Mariners president Jerry Dipoto handling matters from a Las Vegas hospital while the transaction came together, which only adds to the strange backdrop of a move that now reads like much more than a routine roster shuffle. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers World Series Run May Hinge On One Massive October Question
The 2026 World Series is set to bring together two franchises still chasing their first championship, and that alone gives this matchup a different feel. Tampa Bay has spent years building around pitching depth, bullpen stability, and enough lineup flexibility to survive long series, while Milwaukee arrives with the same kind of October identity, a club that leans on run prevention and pressure from the mound to keep games in its control.
For the Rays, the biggest subplot may be the late-inning picture, because the margin in a Series like this can be razor thin when every matchup gets magnified. Milwaukees own October formula has only sharpened the focus on how each team handles the back end of the staff, and one lingering Brewers question is how much certainty they really have in the bullpen mix before the spotlight gets even brighter. [Read more 🡒]