Aaron Judge is back, and the Yankees finally get their middle-of-the-order hammer again.
After being out since May 31, the two-time reigning AL MVP was activated from the injured list Monday night and is set to return to the lineup Tuesday against the Colorado Rockies. New York has 19 games left in the regular season, and Judge is expected to help push the club toward an AL East title before the postseason begins.
Judge, 35, said this past weekend, "I wanted to be back June 1, but that didn't happen," Judge said this past weekend (via MLB.com). "... We'll be back out there and continue to play smart, especially in the rest of this year and then going into the postseason."
The Yankees have felt his absence. Since Judge last played, they’ve averaged just 4.06 runs per game, the fifth fewest in baseball, even while going 45-39 thanks to a pitching staff that has carried much of the load. Aaron Boone made it clear over the weekend that the offense hasn’t been the same without him.
"We've had long stretches where the offense has struggled," manager Aaron Boone said over the weekend (via MLB.com). "I think a big part of that is not having your guy.
I also feel like that's ticked up here in the last couple of weeks, where we've really started to play better offensively. We certainly look forward to getting our guy back."
Now the real questions start.
First, what kind of Judge will the Yankees get right away? He pushed to avoid a minor-league rehab assignment, instead spending the past week or so hitting against the high-velocity machine in the batting cage, taking batting practice with the team this weekend and facing live pitching Monday at Yankee Stadium. It’s all useful work, but it’s not the same as game reps.
"I don't see a point. Why waste at-bats?"
Judge said about skipping a rehab assignment (via MLB.com). "...
I'm not too worried about the power or bat speed. I feel like even if it's a tick off, I still think it's better than nothing."
Boone hinted the Yankees may treat the next few days like a rehab window anyway, which could mean shorter outings, occasional off days or some managed innings early on. After a three-month layoff and no minor-league tune-up, a full workload immediately seems unlikely.
It could take about a week before Judge is back to playing nine innings on consecutive days. That’s the tradeoff New York is willing to make, because the goal is October, not a clean first week back.
There’s recent evidence for that kind of rust. In 2023, Judge missed close to two months with a toe injury, skipped a rehab assignment, and went 5 for 27 (.185) with one home run and eight strikeouts in his first nine games back. The Yankees can live with a slow reentry if it gets him right for the stretch run.
The outfield picture also looks a lot cleaner now than it did a few days ago. Trent Grisham’s Grade 2 hamstring strain and trip to the 15-day injured list removed what had been a tricky roster crunch.
Before that injury, rookie Spencer Jones had been outplaying Grisham in right field, which created a decision the Yankees were going to have to make once Judge returned. Jones could be sent down, or someone like Amed Rosario could have been cut loose.
Grisham’s injury solved the problem for them.
Since the All-Star break, the numbers tell the story:
Grisham: .170/.261/.352, 8 homers, -0.4 WAR in 181 plate appearances
Jones: .254/.321/.492, 7 homers, 0.7 WAR in 141 plate appearances
Jasson Domínguez was brought up to fill Grisham’s spot and platooned in right field with Heliot Ramos for a few days, but he was sent back down to open the roster spot for Judge. Going forward, the setup should be Judge in right, Jones in center and Cody Bellinger in left. Ramos is expected to start against left-handers, likely at Jones’s expense, though he could also give Bellinger or even Judge a breather at times.
And then there’s the division race. The Yankees are still alive in the AL East, and technically they control their own fate.
Win out, and they win the division. But that’s the clean version of the math, not the realistic one.
Here’s where things stand:
Rays: 85-58
Yankees: 81-62, 4 games back
Red Sox: 80-65, 6 games back
Blue Jays: 72-72, 13.5 games back
Orioles: 70-75, 16 games back
The Yankees and Rays still have a four-game series at Yankee Stadium from Sept. 22-24, and that matchup looms large. If New York is within four games going into that series, it still has a shot.
One Yankees win would clinch the season series and the tiebreaker for Tampa Bay, though, so the margin for error is razor thin. Realistically, the Yankees probably need to be one or two games back when that series starts.
The math is steep. If Tampa Bay goes 9-10 the rest of the way, the Yankees would need to go 13-6 to win the division if they sweep the Rays, and 14-5 if they don’t.
That’s a tough climb, but Judge’s return at least gives New York a real shot at making it interesting again. If he finds his MVP gear quickly, the Yankees’ odds rise with him.
In Other News...
Rays Suddenly Have A Catching Decision That Could Matter To Miami
The Rays have put themselves in a much better spot behind the plate in a hurry, and Caden Bodine is a big reason why. The prospect has moved through four minor league levels in one season, flashing both the kind of bat and defensive skill set Tampa Bay has long needed from its catchers. For a franchise that has too often had to patch together offense at the position, that kind of rapid rise is notable on its own.
Add in the arrival of Liam Hicks in a trade, and suddenly the Rays have real depth and a decision to make as they look toward the next few seasons. It is the kind of competition that can help a club, especially one that has spent years trying to get more production from its catching group, and it also gives Tampa Bay another layer to consider as the season turns toward the stretch run and the wider implications around the division, including Miami, come into view. [Read more 🡒]
Garrett Cleavingers Slide Leaves Rays Watching One Small Detail
Garrett Cleavingers season has followed a familiar reliever arc for long stretches, but the August break in performance has been hard to miss. His ERA and FIP climbed sharply after a strong first half, even though the underlying shape of his delivery and his command metrics have stayed largely intact, leaving the Rays to sort through why the results suddenly turned south.
One answer seems to be hiding in the margins of where his fastball has lived. The pitch has drifted from its usual glove-side lane toward the arm side, and a higher BABIP has only made the damage look worse. If Tampa Bay can get the catchers setup nudged back into a better spot, theres hope Cleavinger can rediscover the fastball location that made him so effective earlier in the year. [Read more 🡒]
Jonathan Aranda Is Giving The Rays A New October Question
Jonathan Aranda keeps giving the Rays another reason to think differently about their lineup as October draws closer. His three-run homer in the 10th inning against the Rangers was the kind of swing that can change a night, but it also fit a larger pattern for Tampa Bay, which has been looking for more reliable pop and a steadier offensive rhythm as the playoff race tightens.
The Rays have shown some encouraging signs in that series with Texas, yet the broader question is still hanging there: who can they trust to carry the offense when the games get tighter and the runs get harder to find? Arandas emergence has made him part of that discussion, and the way Tampa Bay answers it could go a long way toward shaping how dangerous this team looks once October arrives. [Read more 🡒]