Oilers Fans Have A Fair Question About Sam OReilly

The Oilers' decision to swap Sam O'Reilly for Isaac Howard is under scrutiny as Howard struggles to make an impact in the NHL.

The Edmonton Oilers made a move in July 2025 that was supposed to help them right away, sending Sam O’Reilly to the Tampa Bay Lightning for Isaac Howard. Months later, with the Oilers facing the Lightning on Nov. 19 and O’Reilly having just made his debut a few games ago, the deal looks a lot less like a quick fix and a lot more like a missed chance.

Howard was 21 at the time of the trade, while O’Reilly was 19. Edmonton’s logic was simple enough: Howard was closer to the NHL and the team needed help now.

But the early returns haven’t backed that up. Howard put together a strong first pro season with the Bakersfield Condors in the American Hockey League, scoring 24 goals and 50 points in 47 games.

In Edmonton, though, he has managed just three goals and eight points in 42 games.

That’s where the frustration starts to build. The Oilers had already used a future first-round pick to select O’Reilly, which says plenty about how they viewed him.

Then they moved him a year later. If Howard was the target, the argument goes, Edmonton should have found another way to keep O’Reilly in the fold.

Howard was a disgruntled asset in Tampa Bay and wasn’t signing there, so the price may not have needed to be so steep.

The bigger issue is fit. Edmonton keeps hunting for a right-shot centre and still needs help down the middle, especially in the bottom six.

Owen Michaels is currently handling the fourth-line centre job after signing directly out of college, but he’s still adjusting and needs more development before he’s truly ready for the NHL. There isn’t another centre in the system ready to push him.

Howard, meanwhile, has been stuck in a role that doesn’t match his game. He’s been parked on the fourth line and is averaging only 8:53 per game.

He’s a skilled forward who needs room to create, but he’s been completely misused. In Bakersfield, he’s on the top line and the top power-play unit.

In Edmonton, he’s on the fourth line and getting no power-play time. The gap between those two versions of Howard is hard to ignore.

O’Reilly, on the other hand, brings a different profile. He’s a strong two-way centre with defensive responsibility and some offensive upside, and his game looks more versatile and adaptable.

Howard is more offense-first, but he hasn’t been surrounded by enough skilled linemates to really let his shot and release do damage. The Oilers forward has the tools, but he hasn’t been placed in a spot where those tools can matter.

The development question is just as important as the usage question. Howard needs to learn how to penalty kill, raise his battle level, and pay closer attention to detail so he can handle the role he’s given when he gets called up. Right now, he’s being asked to adjust to two very different jobs, and the NHL version has offered him almost nothing to work with.

That’s why O’Reilly’s early opportunity with Tampa Bay stands out. The Lightning have already put him on their loaded power play just five games into his NHL career, and he stepped in on the top unit after Brandon Hagel was injured.

All 7:18 of O’Reilly’s power-play time has come with Nikita Kucherov and Jake Guentzel. Howard, by comparison, has only seen 43 seconds with Connor McDavid and 52 seconds with Leon Draisaitl in his 42 games.

The Oilers have had injuries, too. Matt Savoie has been out, and Ryan Nugent-Hopkins and Zach Hyman have both missed time at different points.

Those absences should have opened the door for Howard to move up, but he still hasn’t broken into the top six. If he can’t climb the lineup with those openings, it’s fair to ask when he ever will.

Edmonton can point to the fact that it’s a contender and has less room for mistakes than a rebuilding club. But Tampa Bay is in the same category.

The Lightning sit first in the Atlantic Division and have Cup aspirations of their own, yet they’ve still found a way to give a 20-year-old real minutes. The Oilers haven’t done that with Howard.

For now, the trade hasn’t given Edmonton anything back. O’Reilly is getting the kind of chances Howard isn’t, and the Oilers’ player development problem is staring them right in the face.

In Other News...

Lightning Defensive Depth Plan Just Took A Notable Turn

The Lightnings defensive pipeline got a small but notable shuffle this week, with Dyllan Gill moving from Syracuse down to Orlando and Zach Uens coming back up from the Solar Bears. It is the kind of transaction that rarely grabs headlines on its own, but for Tampa Bay it speaks to how the organization keeps its depth chart moving and its affiliates aligned as injuries, workloads and development needs shift.

Gill has been working through the system after spending time with the Crunch, while Uens gets another chance to rejoin Syracuse after his recent stint in the ECHL. For a Lightning team that leans heavily on organizational depth, these are the sorts of moves that can matter later, even if they do not change the NHL picture right away. [Read more 🡒]

Lightning Give Jansen Harkins Another Chance In A Shorthanded Stretch

With injuries thinning out the forward group, the Lightning have turned back to Jansen Harkins for the first time this season. The centerman had already skated in the season opener before being sent back to the AHLs Syracuse Crunch, where he has logged 11 games, and now he is back in the mix as Tampa Bay tries to get through a short-handed stretch.

The timing matters with four games left in the homestand, when depth suddenly becomes a bigger part of the conversation. Harkins gives the Lightning another option down the middle, and his recall is a reminder of how quickly the roster picture can change when the injuries start piling up. [Read more 🡒]

Lightning Get A Real Test With Oilers Heat Coming To Tampa

The Lightning are about to get an early measuring stick when the Edmonton Oilers arrive for the first meeting between the clubs this season. It is the kind of matchup that tends to sharpen a teams edges quickly, with Connor McDavid bringing a 23-game point streak into Tampa and Nikita Kucherov on the other side as the spotlight naturally settles on two of the leagues biggest stars.

There is also a smaller subplot for Tampa Bay rookie Sam OReilly, who will face his former team in a game set for 7:30 p.m. at Benchmark International Arena. For a Lightning group still trying to establish its footing against elite competition, this one offers a chance to see where it stands against a high-powered opponent and a familiar face from the other bench. [Read more 🡒]