Conor Geekie Is Giving The Lightning A Tougher Decision Than Expected

As Conor Geekie continues to show promise for the Tampa Bay Lightning, his evolving skills and consistent performance hint at a bright future within the team.

Conor Geekie has done enough this season to look like he belongs, but not enough to force the Lightning’s hand just yet.

Through 20 games in Tampa Bay, the 22-year-old winger has already made a far better impression than he did in the 2025-26 season. A year ago at this point, he was in Syracuse and headed toward an AHL all-star campaign. Now he’s settled into the Lightning lineup, and while the question has come up about whether he deserves more ice time, the numbers point to a pretty clear answer: probably not.

The eye test says Geekie has taken a real step forward. He’s skating with more pace, throwing his weight around more often, and playing with a confidence that wasn’t there last season.

He’s also been more noticeable shift to shift, the way he was in Syracuse. That has shown up in the production, too.

He has four goals and one assist in 20 games, already passing last year’s output and reaching halfway to the goal total he posted as a rookie in 52 games in 2024-25. All of that scoring has come at 5v5, which gives Tampa Bay a useful bottom-six threat.

The Lightning have also held up well when he’s on the ice. In what amounts to fourth-line usage, Geekie and his linemates have posted a 54.94% share of shot attempts, 51.61% of shots on goal, and 50.56% of the scoring chances, while the goals have been split 5-5. That’s not a bad tradeoff for a checking line, especially with the top unit driving play so hard.

Defensively, he’s held his own as well. His shots-against and goals-against rates per 60 are both among the best on the team, ranking fifth in each category, and Tampa Bay has been better than league average with him on the ice. The deeper numbers are a little less flattering - he sits 12th among forwards in scoring chances against at 26.08 per 60 and 11th in high-danger chances against at 10.84 per 60 - but his goaltenders have still posted a .933 SV% when he’s out there.

Geekie has spent most of his time with a rotating cast, thanks to Tampa Bay’s heavy 11/7 usage for much of the season. The two forwards he has logged the most minutes with are Jeff Viel, at 132, and Gage Goncalves, at 77. When the Lightning have gone 12/6, the line of Viel, Geekie, and Scott Sabourin has played about 34 minutes together and owned a 54.27% edge in expected goals, along with a 2-to-1 edge in actual goals.

Even with Brayden Point and Anthony Cirelli out of the lineup recently, Geekie’s role has stayed pretty steady. He’s sitting around 11:26 a night, with 10:14 of that at even strength.

Jon Cooper has shifted Jake Guentzel to center and used rookie Sam O’Reilly a bit more, at 11:08 at 5v5. At the moment, Sabourin and Viel are the only regulars averaging less ice time than Geekie.

That might not feel like much for a young player who’s producing, but Tampa Bay seems comfortable with the setup. Geekie’s usage has been sheltered, with only 24 of his 124 shifts that started on the ice coming in the defensive zone.

He’s also mostly seeing bottom-six competition. That’s not a knock; it’s part of the role right now.

His scoring has also come in waves. After three straight games with a goal, he’s gone seven without one.

The shot volume has dipped, too. Over a six-game stretch that included those three goals, he had 17 shot attempts and 11 individual scoring chances at 5v5.

In the four games since, that’s fallen to five shot attempts and four scoring chances.

There’s still a developmental angle here, and the Lightning seem to know it. Geekie is being groomed, not rushed.

A second-line wing job might sound tempting, but it may not be the right path for what Tampa Bay wants him to become. The organization appears to see him as a future middle-six center, and getting him reps down the middle - even in a limited role - should help.

Faceoffs remain a clear area to clean up; he’s at 40.5% in the dot, and only Jake Guentzel has lost a higher percentage of draws.

The bigger picture matters, too. Tampa Bay hasn’t exactly been short on offense, and the top six has produced in most combinations.

With Zemgus Girgensons, Ilya Mikheyev, and Pontus Holmberg locked into the third line, plus Yanni Gourde back in the mix, there just isn’t much room for Geekie to climb right now. For the way the roster is built, the fourth line is where he fits best.

That said, the 11/7 setup has given him some chances to flash a little more. Geekie and Viel have spent limited time with Nikita Kucherov and Jake Guentzel on double shifts, and those minutes have gone well. So he isn’t being buried entirely with defensive-minded linemates.

The Lightning have shown before that they’ll reward work and results. They did it with Dominic James and Charle-Edouard D’Astous last season, and they’re doing it with Pontus Holmberg and his linemates this year.

Geekie may be playing 11 minutes a night in November, but that doesn’t mean the number has to stay there. If he keeps producing, there’s still a path to more.

In Other News...

Wild Fans Just Got A Clearer Read On Quinn Hughes Talks

The latest chatter around the Lightning and the Wild has only sharpened the sense that both teams are trying to stay in win-now mode. NHL Network analyst Elliotte Friedman said Tampa Bay is expected to keep Nikita Kucherov, while Minnesota is expected to hold onto Quinn Hughes, a sign that neither club is eager to let contract uncertainty get in the way of a run at the Stanley Cup. Friedman pointed to the strong play of both stars as part of the reason the teams remain committed to competing at the highest level.

For Tampa Bay, the takeaway is straightforward: Kucherov remains central to everything the Lightning want to do, and the organization appears intent on keeping that core intact. The broader message from Friedmans read is that contenders are still weighing the long view against the urgency of the moment, and both the Lightning and Wild seem prepared to lean into the pursuit of a championship rather than entertain a reset. [Read more 🡒]