With Week 1 of the regular season less than two weeks away, Rueben Bain Jr.’s first NFL snap is almost here, and the buzz around Tampa Bay’s rookie has only kept building.
That kind of attention comes with the territory after the Buccaneers took Bain 15th overall in April. Since then, he has checked just about every box a first-round defender can check during the offseason: comparisons to an NFL legend, a spot on NFL.com’s All-Rookie Team, and early status as the favorite to win Defensive Rookie of the Year. Coaches and teammates have also made plenty of noise about him.
But as loud as the hype has gotten, Bain still hasn’t played a regular-season game. That’s the line between projection and proof, and it’s why the expectations around him may be running ahead of reality.
Lance Zierlein of NFL.com recently laid out best- and worst-case outcomes for 13 first-round defensive rookies, and Bain’s range is a wide one. In Zierlein’s view, the upside is obvious: a strong rookie year, double-digit sacks, and DROY honors. The downside is just as real, with Bain needing time to figure out the speed and answers the NFL throws at him.
“ Best-case scenario: Bain uses leverage and explosive power to confound both tackles and guards as the Bucs move him around to mismatch weak-link linemen on his way to double-digit sacks and the Defensive Rookie of the Year award.
“ Worst-case scenario: Offensive tackles show no fear of Bain's ability to beat them around the edge, allowing blockers to focus on his inside counters and bull-rush while limiting his finishes in the pocket to fewer than five.
Zierlein’s projection makes it clear he sees Bain trending much closer to the optimistic end of that spectrum. If that kind of rookie season comes together, Tampa Bay will be thrilled.
If it doesn’t, the message will be simpler: the expectations were too heavy, too soon. That wouldn’t close the door on Bain becoming a Pro Bowl-caliber player down the line, but it would suggest he needs more time before he becomes that kind of force.
For my money, the Bain hype is real. I expect him to make noise right away and agree with Zierlein that he can get close to double-digit sacks as a rookie.
He also lands in a favorable setup. Tampa Bay can lean on other pass-rushing pieces in YaYa Diaby, Al-Quadin Muhammad, and David Walker, which should keep opponents from keying too heavily on Bain and give him chances in one-on-one matchups. Add Vita Vea and a healthy Calijah Kancey on the interior, and there’s even more reason for opposing offenses to spread their attention around.
In Other News...
Buccaneers May Already Regret Letting Jack Pyburn Get Away
Jack Pyburn did enough in August to make the Buccaneers take notice, even if it did not keep him in Tampa Bay for long. The undrafted rookie flashed all preseason and finished with four sacks, tying for the most among edge defenders, before the Bucs waived him during final roster cuts and watched Kansas City move quickly to claim him for its 53-man roster.
For a team always hunting for young pass-rush help, that kind of departure can linger. Todd Bowles had already singled out Pyburns work ethic and production, which only sharpens the question of whether Tampa Bay gave up on him a little too early, or whether the Chiefs simply got there first and saw enough to make the gamble worthwhile. [Read more 🡒]
Buccaneers Suddenly Have A Real Path Back To The Top
The NFC South does not look especially imposing heading into this season, and that has opened a lane for Tampa Bay to get back where it has spent plenty of time in recent years. ESPNs Dan Graziano sees the Buccaneers as a team that could reclaim the division, pointing to the kind of ingredients that often matter most in a crowded race: a quarterback with something to prove, better health, and a roster that has been reinforced on both sides of the ball.
Baker Mayfields motivation in a contract year sits at the center of that optimism, but it is not the only reason Tampa Bay is drawing notice. The Buccaneers have added talent on offense and defense, and if the health picture improves, they should have a real chance to separate themselves from what is expected to be a weak division. The bigger question is whether all of those pieces come together quickly enough to make the path back to the top look as clear as it does on paper. [Read more 🡒]
Falcons Quarterback Battle Just Put New Pressure On Atlanta's Roster
Baker Mayfields situation in Tampa Bay remains one of the more interesting subplots of the offseason, especially with Todd Bowles noting the quarterbacks motivation even before a contract extension is finalized. For the Buccaneers, that kind of stability matters. Mayfield has already become the focal point of the offense, and Bowles comments only reinforce how central he is to what Tampa Bay wants to build heading into the next stretch of team planning.
Across the division, the Falcons are juggling a different kind of quarterback conversation, with general manager Ian Cunningham talking through the teams current situation and the roster moves that have come with it. The broader NFC South picture also includes Carolina, where Dan Morgan has been addressing roster commitments, injuries and practice squad decisions, a reminder that every team in the division is still sorting out the same basic question: who is ready now, and who still has more to prove before the picture settles? [Read more 🡒]