One game into the season, the Bucs have already flipped the script on a few of the biggest questions hanging over the roster.
What looked shaky in August came out looking sturdy on Sunday. What seemed like a strength turned into a concern. It’s only one data point, sure, but it was enough to leave a clear set of early takeaways from the Week 1 loss to the Bengals.
The most encouraging development came in the secondary. That was the unit that carried the most doubt all summer, with questions about Zyon McCollum, Benjamin Morrison and the depth behind Jacob Parrish. Against Cincinnati, the group answered loudly.
Ja’Marr Chase was kept in check almost all day, finishing with two catches for 12 yards on four targets. McCollum never allowed a catch to Chase, and he even broke up a third-down throw to Chase on the Bengals’ opening drive.
Cincinnati also tried moving Chase into the slot to attack rookie Keionte Scott, but that didn’t pay off either. Chase managed just one catch for 16 yards against him.
Parrish and Morrison, after Parrish left because of injury, both handled the former Offensive Player of the Year.
Tee Higgins had the biggest day among Cincinnati receivers, catching three of six targets for 59 yards. His 18-yard grab on the game-sealing drive came with McCollum in coverage, and while the Bucs corner was in position and played the route well, Higgins still made a high-level play. Overall, Bengals receivers caught only eight of 14 targets for 91 yards, a 6.5 yards-per-target average and less than one yard per route run.
That’s a strong opening statement from a secondary that was supposed to be the worry spot.
The pass rush, meanwhile, didn’t carry the same promise. Tampa Bay spent the offseason trying to upgrade that area, adding A’Shawn Robinson, signing Al-Quadin Muhammad and giving Vita Vea an extra $30 million on a one-year extension.
Rueben Bain Jr. arrived with plenty of buzz as the 15th overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. The expectation was that the Bucs could win with four rushers.
That didn’t happen against Cincinnati.
Bain had a rough first regular season game, producing no pressure on 26 pass rush attempts. Amarius Mims handled him well, repeatedly absorbing his bull rushes, and even when Bain mixed in something different, Mims had it covered. Vea also came up empty as a rusher, with Sumer Sports crediting him with 40 pass rushes and no pressures.
The rest of the front offered a little more. Robinson logged one pressure on 19 rushes, and Calijah Kancey was the bright spot up front with a team-high three pressures.
When healthy, he looked like exactly the player the Bucs think he can be. But the bigger picture was hard to miss: Tampa Bay only really bothered Joe Burrow when it blitzed.
That’s the part that should sting. The four-man rush was supposed to be better. It wasn’t.
Then there was Baker Mayfield, whose day was shaped by both the line in front of him and some costly decisions of his own. The Bucs entered the season expecting a healthier offensive line to stabilize the offense after injuries ravaged that group last year.
Tristan Wirfs missed five games, Luke Goedeke missed six, Ben Bredeson was out for the final six, and Cody Mauch was lost for the season after the second game. With more protection, Tampa Bay believed Mayfield would be able to settle in.
Instead, he helped create some of the damage.
His third fumble of the day came on a sack by Boye Mafe, but Mayfield held the ball too long and paid for it. The other two turnovers were the kind that come from trying to do too much.
On a third-and-nine scramble on the second drive, he avoided a sack but should have just thrown the ball away. Instead, he kept the play alive and put it on the ground, leading to a scoop and score.
The most damaging turnover may have been the one that came in the red zone. Tampa Bay had first-and-five at the Bengals’ 12, and a touchdown felt likely.
Even a field goal would have kept the Bucs within a score. Mayfield escaped pressure again and picked up a new first down with his legs, but he kept extending the play and lost the ball, turning a near-guaranteed scoring chance into a back-breaking mistake.
Last year, some of that style was easier to justify because the offensive line was so battered. This year, with better health up front, Mayfield needs to trust the pocket and take what’s there. That should help him protect the ball and give the offense a better chance to function the way it’s supposed to.
So after Week 1, the early picture is pretty simple: one encouraging sign, two worrying ones, and nothing locked in yet. The Bucs will get another chance to sort it out next week against the Browns.
In Other News...
Bucs Already Have A Real Concern In The Middle Of Their Defense
Alex Anzalones stat line looked busy enough against the Bengals, with seven tackles, but the tape told a more complicated story for the middle of Tampa Bays defense. He was credited with inconsistent play and found himself out of position at times, which is the kind of issue that can quietly unravel a unit even when the box score still looks respectable. Rookie Rueben Bain Jr. also had only a small footprint in the game, finishing with one assisted tackle as the Buccaneers searched for more impact in the middle of the field.
Josiah Trotter was the one bright spot, turning in the games most active defensive performance with 11 tackles, a sack, a pass defensed and a pick-six touchdown. Even so, Tampa Bays next test comes quickly with the Browns on deck, and the Buccaneers will need the center of the defense to settle in before a sturdier opponent starts probing those same soft spots. [Read more 🡒]
Bucs Week 1 Snap Counts Raised A Bigger Question Than The Loss
The Buccaneers season-opening loss to Cincinnati left plenty to sort through, but the snap counts may have been even more revealing than the final score. Tampa Bays offense showed an early look at how it plans to distribute work among its pass catchers and backfield, with Emeka Egbuka, Chris Godwin Jr. and rookie Ted Hurst III all drawing meaningful usage, while Bucky Irving and Kenny Gainwell split the backfield workload in a way that hinted at how this group might evolve as the season settles in.
On defense, the story was just as interesting because the workload centered on a young linebacker making a strong case for a larger role. Josiah Trotter led the Buccaneers in tackles and was involved in several key plays, while Alex Anzalone was the only defender to stay on the field for every snap. For a team trying to find its footing after one week, the bigger question is not just what happened against the Bengals, but what these usage patterns say about how Tampa Bay wants to build going forward. [Read more 🡒]
Buccaneers Loss Exposed Familiar Problems But One Rookie Gave Fans Hope
The Buccaneers came out of Week 1 with a 33-27 loss to the Bengals, and the film offered a little of everything that has frustrated this team before. Baker Mayfields three fumbles were the clearest example, but the problems did not stop there. Tampa Bays defense had its own communication issues and struggled to generate consistent pressure, while the offense had the kind of delays and miscues that can make a new playcallers first outing feel much longer than the calendar says it should.
Bucky Irving was one of the few reasons for optimism. The rookie running back scored on the ground and also caught seven passes, giving the Buccaneers a much-needed jolt in a game that otherwise exposed familiar concerns. For a team trying to establish a cleaner identity early in the season, Irvings debut offered a small but meaningful reason to believe there is at least one fresh piece ready to help steady things. [Read more 🡒]