The Bucs added two newcomers who could shape their season in very different ways, and the debate comes down to this: do you want the biggest impact from a running back who should be on the field plenty, or from a first-round edge rusher who could change the entire feel of the defense?
On one side, Kenneth Gainwell looks like a natural fit for Tampa Bay’s offense. The two-year, $14 million deal with $10 million guaranteed raised some eyebrows, but the case for Gainwell is pretty straightforward: he’s going to play a lot. He may not be the starter at running back, but his value comes from how often he can be used and how many jobs he can handle.
Gainwell brings speed, sharp vision and a decisive style when the lane opens. He can work in gap schemes, and he also gives the Bucs another way to keep defenses honest if Zac Robinson leans more on zone concepts. He sees the cutback lane well and has the burst to turn it into a big gain.
His biggest value might come after the handoff. Gainwell is a strong pass protector and a reliable receiver, which opens the door for more Pony Packages with him and Bucky Irving on the field together. Because his game overlaps with Irving’s, Tampa Bay can keep the offense moving without a major drop-off when Gainwell checks in.
There’s also the possibility that he ends up starting if needed, and that doesn’t appear to be a problem for him. He’s described as a team-first player who wants to win, and that mindset could also make him willing to contribute on special teams. As a former Super Bowl champion, he knows what winning requires.
Matt Matera also pointed to what Gainwell already showed in mini-camp, where he scored several touchdowns for the Bucs on offense. If that carries over, Tampa Bay’s ground game could get the boost it’s looking for.
The other side of the argument is even louder: Rueben Bain Jr. might be the kind of player who changes everything. Bailey Adams was close to going with veteran inside linebacker Alex Anzalone, but kept coming back to Tampa Bay’s first-round pick because Bain checks so many boxes for what this defense has needed.
Bain is more than just an edge rusher. The former Miami Hurricane brings disruptive speed-to-power, strong bend and the kind of all-around presence that can stress a quarterback snap after snap. Tampa Bay’s pass rush has been missing that kind of force in recent years, and Todd Bowles’ defense has felt the absence.
The ripple effect may be just as important as Bain’s own production. Adams believes Bain will help Yaya Diaby reach another level, even predicting Diaby crosses the double-digit sack mark this year with Bain drawing attention off the other edge. Bain’s ability to flush quarterbacks out of the pocket could create chances for teammates the way Akheem Mesidor benefited from playing alongside him at Miami.
That impact wouldn’t stop with Diaby. Vita Vea and Calijah Kancey could also profit from the pressure Bain creates on the outside.
And the depth chart at outside linebacker suddenly looks a lot stronger with Bain in the mix, since he and Diaby would project as the starters while Al-Quadin Muhammad, who had 11 sacks last year, and David Walker become quality depth pieces. Anthony Nelson would slide to No. 5, a spot Adams noted could make a strong case as the best No. 5 outside linebacker in the league.
So the question isn’t whether Tampa Bay added talent. It’s whether the more important addition is the versatile back who can help the offense in multiple ways, or the rookie pass rusher who could reshape the defense and lift the players around him.
In Other News...
Mac Jones Had A Funny Take On Tom Bradys Bucs Return
Mac Jones still remembers the buildup to that October 3, 2021 matchup at Gillette Stadium, when the Patriots hosted Tom Brady and the Buccaneers in one of the most anticipated regular-season games in recent memory. The atmosphere was electric, and the media attention around Brady facing Bill Belichick again made it feel bigger than a typical Sunday, with every snap carrying a little extra weight for everyone in the building.
Jones handled the stage well enough, completing 31 of 40 passes for 275 yards with two touchdowns and an interception, but the night belonged to Tampa Bay in the end. The Buccaneers left with a 19-17 win, and the game closed with a tense finish that fit the mood of the whole evening, the kind of result that kept the Brady return story lingering long after the final whistle. [Read more 🡒]
Bucs Fans May Not Like Where This QB Talk Is Heading
The Buccaneers quarterback conversation is starting to look a little more complicated than it did a few months ago. Baker Mayfield is heading into a contract year without a long-term extension in place, and Tampa Bay still has not publicly locked itself into anything beyond this season, which naturally keeps the door open to a future move under center.
That is why a recent mock draft from Justin Melo of Sports Illustrated caught attention, even if it was only a projection. The idea of Tampa Bay using draft capital on a quarterback would not necessarily mean a clean break from Mayfield, but it would signal the front office is at least keeping a hedge in play, whether as insurance or as a developmental option if the contract situation drags on. [Read more 🡒]
Bucs Hit With Brutal Offseason Verdict After Collapse And Key Exit
The Buccaneers offseason evaluation has a harsh edge to it after a finish that unraveled badly down the stretch. Tampa Bay went 2-7 after the bye, blew the NFC South, and left enough doubt behind that Frank Schwab slotted the club 22nd in his offseason power rankings, pointing to the historic collapse as the biggest reason for the drop.
The personnel losses only deepen the concern, with Jamel Dean gone and Lavonte David retired, leaving the roster thinner in spots that mattered most. Even so, Schwabs view is not entirely bleak for Tampa Bay, since he still thinks the Bucs can reclaim the division in 2026 if the core comes together, with Bucky Irvings health and explosiveness looming as one of the bigger questions hanging over the team. [Read more 🡒]