The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are still fighting the same perception problem that’s followed them for months: until they start stacking wins, plenty of people aren’t buying in.
That skepticism showed up again in Mike Sando of The Athletic’s annual survey of six NFL executives, who ranked all 16 NFC teams for the upcoming season and placed each one into four tiers. Tampa landed 10th in the conference, with votes of 9-10-14-11-11-10, an average of 10.8 and a median of 10.5.
Three executives put the Bucs in the division contender tier, while three slotted them among the sub-.500 teams. Their Vegas win total was listed at 8.5, tied for ninth in the NFC.
The most interesting part of Tampa’s placement wasn’t just the ranking itself, but the reasons behind it. The executives pointed to the run game, Baker Mayfield, and the secondary as the biggest issues.
One voter said, "The big question is, what will the run game look like?" and added, "The new coordinator (Zac Robinson) was in Atlanta when they struggled to marry the run and the pass.
But they get a motivated Baker (Mayfield) in a contract year, and they have arguably one of the best offensive players in the division with Emeka (Egbuka), plus a ton of draft capital in the defense."
Mayfield’s contract situation also came up as a talking point. With him entering his fourth season in Tampa, one executive suggested he can be the kind of quarterback people love when things are rolling, but less so when the pressure rises.
Another voter turned the focus to the defense, saying, "Defensively, they should be more physical up front, adding A'Shawn (Robinson), Rueben Bain, (Josiah) Trotter in the front seven," and continued, "(Keionte) Scott is a physical nickel built for (Todd) Bowles' blitzes. They'll need that rush to get home with questions in the secondary outside (Antoine) Winfield (Jr.).'
The survey also underscored how little confidence remains around the NFC South as a whole. Tampa’s streak of four straight division titles ended last season, and one executive summed up the division this way: "'I think all four of those teams are gonna be under .500 again,' one exec said. 'So, great, you're the best of the bad teams in your division.'"
There were also a few eyebrow-raising parts of the analysis. Tampa’s rushing attack may be viewed externally as a concern, but the roster additions tell a different story. The Bucs signed Kenneth Gainwell in free agency to pair with Bucky Irving, and Robinson’s arrival should help a ground game that was already productive under Liam Coen in 2024, when Tampa finished with the fourth-best rushing attack in the NFL.
Mayfield drew similar skepticism in the survey, even though plenty of observers expect him to respond well in a contract year. That made his inclusion among the concerns stand out, especially with Tampa adding more talent around him.
The Bucs were ranked behind the New Orleans Saints, who came in ninth, while the Carolina Panthers and Atlanta Falcons were listed 11th and 15th, respectively.
Even with the lukewarm national view, Tampa’s case is simple enough: last season ended at 8-9 after injuries, especially on offense, took a major toll. The team still has plenty of talent, even after losing Mike Evans, Lavonte David, and cornerback Jamel Dean. If the health improves, the Bucs should have every chance to clear last year’s win total and reclaim the top spot in the division.
In Other News...
Bucs First Round Pass Rusher Is Drawing Serious Early Buzz
Early buzz around Rueben Bain Jr. has been building quickly since the Buccaneers made him the 15th overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, and it has only grown through practices and preseason work. Tampa Bay targeted him to help change the edge of its defense, and the early returns have matched the kind of attention a first-round pass rusher usually brings when he starts flashing right away.
Bain has already drawn praise for his work ethic and physical style, the kind of traits teams love to see from a young defender trying to earn real snaps fast. Hes also the current betting favorite for Defensive Rookie of the Year, which speaks to how much confidence is already surrounding him, from former coach Jon Gruden to general manager Jason Licht, even before the games start to count. [Read more 🡒]
Former Buccaneers Coach Greg Schiano Is Under Pressure Again
Greg Schianos second stint at Rutgers has been measured against the expectation that he would steady a program he once helped define, but the latest setback landed with extra force. Rutgers fell to UMass, a team that entered the matchup buried in a long losing streak, and the Scarlet Knights also paid $1.5 million for the game, a detail that only sharpened the frustration around the result.
Since Schiano returned in 2020, Rutgers has shown a mixed record under his watch, enough to keep the conversation around the program from ever fully settling. A loss like this does more than sting in the moment - it raises the kind of questions that follow a coach into every press conference, especially when the wins are hard to stack and the margin for patience can start to shrink. [Read more 🡒]
Baker Mayfield Changed Something Big Inside The Buccaneers Locker Room
When Baker Mayfield arrived in Tampa Bay in 2023, he was stepping into the biggest possible void, taking over for Tom Brady and trying to give the Buccaneers some stability at the games most important position. He did more than just settle the offense. Mayfield has earned Pro Bowl recognition in both of his first two seasons with the team, posted career highs in passing yards and touchdowns, and helped the Bucs win the NFC South in each of those years.
Just as important inside the building, his presence has given the locker room a different kind of edge. Teammates and staff have pointed to his outgoing personality and easy approachability as a real plus, the sort of thing that can loosen a room without losing its focus. For a team trying to keep winning while moving beyond the Brady era, that kind of influence matters almost as much as what shows up on the stat sheet. [Read more 🡒]