The future of Mike Evans in Tampa Bay is one of the biggest questions hanging over the Buccaneers this offseason-and for good reason. We're talking about the franchise's all-time leader in receiving yards, touchdowns, and just about every meaningful wideout stat you can think of. As Evans takes time to weigh his options post-Super Bowl, the Bucs-and the rest of the league-wait.
Right now, it seems like two doors are open: retirement or another year in pewter and red. The idea of Evans suiting up for another team in 2026 hasn’t gained much traction, but this is the NFL-nothing’s ever off the table.
Still, the most realistic scenario might be a return to Tampa on a short-term, team-friendly deal. If that happens, it could be a win-win.
Evans, even at this stage in his career, still has Pro Bowl-level production in him-assuming he stays healthy. He’s not just a red zone threat or a chain-mover; he’s a tone-setter.
A player defenses still have to account for on every snap. And beyond the stat sheet, his leadership in the locker room is invaluable, especially for a team that’s still shaping its identity in the Baker Mayfield era.
Now, the question everyone’s asking: do the Bucs need Mike Evans?
On paper, the weapons cupboard is far from bare. Chris Godwin remains a reliable target, and the influx of young talent-Emeka Egbuka, Tez Johnson, Jalen McMillan-gives Mayfield plenty of options. Add in tight end Cade Otten and running back Bucky Irving, and you’ve got a skill group that can stretch the field, create mismatches, and keep defenses honest.
But let’s not kid ourselves. Mike Evans brings something different.
He’s the kind of player who makes contested catches look routine, who can flip a game with a single play, and who’s been the heartbeat of this offense for over a decade. That kind of presence doesn’t just grow on trees.
So while the Bucs could field a competitive offense without him, keeping Evans in the fold-especially on a manageable deal-would be a smart move. He’s still got gas in the tank, and more importantly, he’s got the kind of experience and poise that can help guide a young, evolving offense through the grind of a long season.
If Tampa Bay wants to make a real push in the Mayfield era, bringing back a player like Evans could be the difference between a playoff appearance and a playoff run.