Baker Mayfield’s name keeps landing in the same conversation: good enough to be Tampa Bay’s guy, not quite enough to crack the NFL’s elite tier in the usual quarterback rankings. Dan Orlovsky’s latest ESPN breakdown leans into that debate, but with a twist.
He didn’t rank quarterbacks overall. Instead, he sorted the position into seven traits - arm strength, ball placement, mechanics, decision-making, pocket presence, second reaction, and rushing ability - and asked where the league’s passers actually separate.
Mayfield showed up in the top 10 three times.
He came in sixth in arm strength, 10th in second-reaction ability, and eighth in rushing ability. That’s a respectable showing, but it also means he missed the cut in four of the seven categories Orlovsky highlighted as most important to quarterback success.
And if you’re wondering how that stacks up against the other big-name quarterbacks Mayfield wants to be paid like, the answer isn’t exactly flattering. Jordan Love appeared in the top 10 for two of the seven traits, while Trevor Lawrence made it once, landing 10th in pocket presence.
That doesn’t automatically settle the contract argument, of course, but it does frame the discussion around what Mayfield is and isn’t. He had a down season in 2025, same as the Buccaneers as a whole, yet the situation around him was anything but normal.
Tampa Bay was missing its top three wide receivers from 2024 for long stretches. Bucky Irving, the team’s top running back, sat out seven games.
And four of the five starting offensive linemen each missed at least five games.
Mayfield also dealt with multiple injuries during the year, even though he didn’t miss any games. Those issues were laid out in the Netflix docuseries Quarterback. How much all of that influenced Orlovsky’s rankings is impossible to know, but it’s hard to look at the full picture and not think the setup dragged down what Mayfield could show.
Some of the placements make sense on their own. His arm strength has never really been the question. He’s not in the same class as Josh Allen, Matthew Stafford, or Patrick Mahomes, but he can make every throw a quarterback is asked to make, and sixth feels about right.
The rushing ranking is more debatable. Mayfield has always been willing to create with his legs, and last year he ran for 382 yards with a 6.9 yards-per-carry average. That kind of production is easy to overlook, but it matters, and eighth may have sold him a little short.
The 10th-place nod in second-reaction ability is where the case gets murkier. Orlovsky is essentially measuring how well a quarterback performs when the play breaks down and he has to throw outside the pocket.
Mayfield posted a 90.6 passer rating on those throws last season, which ranked 21st. Still, from 2022 through 2024, that number sat at 95.6, so the drop-off lines up with a year in which his most reliable weapons weren’t around nearly enough.
The other omissions are easier to explain. Decision-making and mechanics both remain areas where Mayfield can improve, and ball placement took a hit as well.
After completing 71.4 percent of his passes in 2024, he dropped to 63.2 percent in 2025. That, too, likely reflects the chaos around him.
Pocket presence is a more complicated read. At 6'1, Mayfield doesn’t have the natural advantage taller quarterbacks enjoy when they can see over the rush. He sometimes drifts to find a lane and can wander into pressure.
So while the list didn’t exactly shower him with praise, it also didn’t bury him. If anything, it painted the picture of a quarterback with real strengths, some clear flaws, and a season that was hard to evaluate cleanly because so much around him was falling apart.
That’s why the bigger question may not be where Mayfield landed in Orlovsky’s rankings this year, but where he could land next year if Tampa Bay is healthier. The belief here is that he’ll have a better chance to climb those lists in 2026, especially with a contract year in front of him and plenty to prove.
In Other News...
Buccaneers Roster Battle Took Center Stage In A Messy First Look
The Buccaneers first preseason look against the Jets was less about the 24-16 final and more about the kind of roster sorting that usually defines August. Tampa Bay used the game as an extended evaluation window, with the coaching staff watching how individual players handled live action, from the quarterback room to the rest of the offense, defense and special teams.
Connor Bazelak and Jalon Daniels both drew close attention in a matchup that featured plenty of uneven moments, along with a few flashes that will keep their names in the conversation. For a team trying to sort out the bottom of the roster, the bigger takeaway was the competition itself, and the fact that the first real test brought both encouraging signs and some messy tape to sort through. [Read more 🡒]
Jalon Daniels Just Turned Up The Heat In Tampa Bays QB3 Battle
The Buccaneers opened their preseason with a win over the Jets, but the more interesting development for Tampa Bay might have come in the second half. Undrafted rookie Jalon Daniels got his turn and handled it with the kind of poise and confidence teams always notice in August, giving the staff a cleaner look at a quarterback room that still has one final spot to settle.
Daniels is fighting Connor Bazelak for the third quarterback job, and the way the reps were divided made the battle feel very real. Bazelak got the first half, Daniels finished the game, and now Tampa Bay has a decision to sort through after seeing both passers in live action under preseason pressure. [Read more 🡒]
Todd Bowles Just Set Up Tampa Bays Next Preseason Decision
The Buccaneers handled their preseason opener against the New York Jets with a lineup made up entirely of backup players, giving the staff a clean first look at the depth behind the starters. That approach fits the usual early-August plan, but it also leaves the more revealing evaluation for what comes next, when the competition level rises and the regulars are set to get involved.
Todd Bowles has already pointed to the second preseason game against the Kansas City Chiefs as the point when Tampa Bays starters are expected to play, with rookie Rueben Bain Jr. also slated to make his debut. What remains unsettled is how much work the first unit will actually get, and that choice could land anywhere from a brief tune-up to a more extended run before the preseason schedule keeps moving. [Read more 🡒]