Baker Mayfield is back in the lineup, but Tampa Bay still doesn’t have a clean answer on how well his thumb is actually holding up.
The quarterback returned against the Carolina Panthers after dislocating the thumb on his throwing hand, an injury that cost him three games. Even with him on the field again, the signs around his throwing hand suggest the issue is still very much in play. Mayfield had to wear a special glove, there were reports of passes sailing during practice, and his workload Sunday was limited enough that it doesn’t tell the full story.
That matters because a thumb injury can mess with everything a quarterback needs to do cleanly - grip, control, and the release that drives accuracy. Mayfield may be able to manage the pain, but getting back to his normal mechanics can take more time than simply getting cleared to play. Offensive coordinator Zac Robinson said some of Mayfield’s passes were sailing during practice, and that’s the part worth watching as Tampa Bay tries to get its passing game moving again.
Against Carolina, Mayfield threw only 11 passes, which leaves a pretty small sample to judge where he really is. The Buccaneers didn’t need him to do much in a 43-13 win, instead leaning on the ground game and piling up 258 rushing yards on 45 carries. That let Tampa Bay control the game without asking its quarterback to win it through the air.
The bigger question now is what happens when the Bucs need more from him. The win was a good sign, but it came in a game where the offense could stay on the ground.
Tampa Bay still needs more consistency from the passing attack, especially after ranking near the bottom of the league in passing production earlier in the season. Mayfield is back, but until he’s throwing more often and doing it accurately, his thumb will remain a major storyline.
In Other News...
Todd Bowles Just Gave Buccaneers Fans A Bigger Coaching Debate
As the season rolls into Week 8, the leagues coaching temperature is starting to rise, and Todd Bowles has become part of that conversation in Tampa Bay. The Buccaneers have not given their fan base much reason to feel settled lately, and any midseason chatter around job security tends to land harder when a team is already searching for traction.
The timing only adds to the scrutiny, especially after the Colts moved on from general manager Chris Ballard and the broader sense around the NFL that front offices are willing to make changes before the year is over. For Bowles, the question is no longer just about getting the Buccaneers turned around, but about whether the next stretch can quiet a debate that is only getting louder. [Read more 🡒]
Bucs Suddenly Face A Trade Deadline Decision Fans Never Wanted
The Buccaneers have spent the first part of the season in an awkward middle ground, stuck at 2-5 but still close enough in the NFC South to avoid treating the year like a lost cause. The passing game has been a problem, the roster has some aging pieces, and the standings have left Tampa Bay trying to decide whether it can still make a push or whether it should start thinking more like a team that needs to protect what comes next.
Around the league, the Colts have already shown how quickly a team can pivot into seller mode, and that kind of move is at least part of the conversation in Tampa Bay now. It is not a call the Buccaneers have made, but the deadline can force a hard choice on teams that are lingering near the race without truly leading it, and the Bucs are suddenly one of them. [Read more 🡒]
Baker Mayfield Brings A Personal Grudge Into A Huge Bucs Game
Baker Mayfield heads into a pivotal Week 8 divisional matchup carrying more than the usual stakes that come with an NFC South game. The Buccaneers quarterback has a long memory when it comes to Cleveland, and the backdrop for this one goes well beyond the standings, with a familiar coach waiting on the other side and an old relationship still hanging over the matchup.
Mayfield has been open about his frustration with how things ended with the Browns, and that tension still colors the way he views this meeting. For Tampa Bay, it adds another layer to a game that already matters plenty, because this is the kind of spot where personal history can sharpen a quarterbacks edge and turn an ordinary divisional test into something a lot more charged. [Read more 🡒]