Baker Mayfield has spent three seasons in Tampa Bay proving he can handle the job, and the Buccaneers have every reason to believe in him as their long-term quarterback. He’s helped push the team to a 27-24 regular-season record, added a playoff win, and at his best has looked like one of the sharpest passers in the league.
But the national view hasn’t caught up.
CBS Sports’ Bryan DeArdo ranked every starting quarterback in the NFL into tiers, and Mayfield ended up in tier 4, the “volatile veterans” group. DeArdo described that section as “the murky middle of the quarterback landscap e, a mixed bag of talent. While each of these quarterbacks is capable of putting up big numbers, their Achilles heels -- whether it's age, a lack of consistency, or being turnover-prone -- can hold their respective teams back,”
Mayfield was placed there alongside Aaron Rodgers, Daniel Jones, C.J. Stroud, and Bryce Young.
DeArdo also wrote, “Mayfield followed up his impressive 2024 campaign with an underwhelming 2025 season that wasn't helped by all of the Buccaneers' injuries. The 2026 season will be a crucial one for Mayfield, who is slated to enter free agency next offseason.”
That’s a tough landing spot for a quarterback who has a real argument for the tier above it, where DeArdo slotted the “borderline stars.” That group includes Trevor Lawrence, Jalen Hurts, Jordan Love, Brock Purdy, and Bo Nix.
Mayfield’s case is built on production, plain and simple. He had a down 2025 season while dealing with injuries to himself and the roster around him, but in 2024 he finished top-three in the NFL in both passing yards and touchdowns. Since arriving in Tampa Bay, he’s ranked second among all quarterbacks in touchdown passes, and he’s taken the Buccaneers to the playoffs in two of his three seasons.
Even with that résumé, the skepticism keeps following him. He’s been overlooked and underrated on the national stage before, and this offseason has brought more of the same. For a player who has always seemed to thrive with a chip on his shoulder, 2026 gives him another chance to answer back.
In Other News...
Should The Buccaneers Go All In For Denzel Ward
The Browns decision to move Myles Garrett earlier this offseason has already changed the way the rest of the league views Clevelands roster, and it has put Denzel Ward squarely into the kind of trade conversation that usually only comes up when a team starts thinking bigger-picture. For the Buccaneers, that matters because they are still looking for a true top cornerback to anchor the back end of the defense, and Wards name naturally fits a need that has been hard to ignore.
Tampa Bay is one of the teams being discussed as a possible landing spot before the 2026 season, alongside Detroit and San Francisco, which says plenty about how the market could form if Cleveland keeps leaning into a reset. The question for the Bucs is whether they would be willing to pay the price in draft capital or part with a young defensive back to make a move like that happen, especially if Ward becomes available sooner rather than later. [Read more 🡒]
Bucs Offense Just Got A Brutal Verdict Fans Wont Ignore
The Buccaneers offense is heading into the kind of summer that invites a lot of second-guessing, especially after ESPNs Bill Barnwell slotted Tampa Bays weapons group 22nd in the league. That is a steep drop from where the unit stood a year ago, and it reflects a mix of uncertainty around the supporting cast and the simple reality that the Bucs are asking a lot from players who will have to carry more of the load.
Chris Godwin Jr., Bucky Irving and rookie Ted Hurst all sit in the middle of that conversation, which is where Tampa Bays hope and worry overlap. The offense still has enough talent to matter, but the questions are obvious: who stays healthy, who holds up over a full season, and who is ready to turn potential into production before the rest of the league forces the issue. [Read more 🡒]