For a long time, the Baker Mayfield-Dashaun Watson split made Cleveland the butt of the joke. Mayfield kept rebuilding his reputation in Tampa Bay, Watson kept dealing with injuries and uneven play in Cleveland, and the Browns wore the criticism for choosing the wrong quarterback. A quarter of the way into 2026, though, the storyline has started to bend the other way.
The Browns are 3-1. The Buccaneers are 0-3. And Cleveland’s three wins have all come with Watson engineering a game-winning drive in the fourth quarter.
One of those victories came against Tampa Bay in Week 2, a game Mayfield had clearly circled. He talked before kickoff about wanting to beat Cleveland, but the result was a 23-19 loss and a rough night for the Buccaneers quarterback.
Watson has looked revived through four games. He has completed 69.6% of his passes for 855 yards, six touchdowns and two interceptions. Over a full 17-game season, that production would project to 3,634 yards, 26 touchdowns and nine interceptions.
Mayfield’s start has gone in the opposite direction. He is completing 63.5% of his throws for 615 yards, two passing touchdowns, one rushing touchdown and two interceptions. That works out to a 17-game pace of 3,485 yards, 11 touchdowns and 11 interceptions.
The numbers get even uglier when you factor in ball security. Mayfield has also lost three fumbles, all of them coming in Week 1, when his turnovers directly helped sink Tampa Bay in the opener.
Now the Buccaneers are dealing with another problem: Mayfield is expected to miss at least three games with a dislocated thumb, leaving the 0-3 team without its starting quarterback as it tries to stop the slide.
The contrast between the two contracts has also been a huge part of this story. Cleveland took plenty of heat for trading for Watson, sending three first-round picks and handing him a fully guaranteed five-year, $230 million deal. At the time, the move looked even worse because Watson had appeared in just 19 of a possible 51 games over the previous three seasons and had gone 9-10.
Mayfield, by comparison, had been a bargain in Tampa Bay. He spent his first year on a one-year, $4 million deal, then signed a three-year, $100 million extension. He played in all 51 games and helped the Bucs go 27-24.
That balance shifted again this offseason when Tampa Bay gave Mayfield a three-year, $165 million extension. He now ranks among only eight players in the NFL making at least $55 million per year.
Still, it would be a mistake to treat four games as the final word. Mayfield has spent the past three seasons proving he can be a franchise quarterback in Tampa Bay, while Watson is only now giving Cleveland the kind of play it expected when it made the deal.
There is also a part of this debate that goes beyond the box score. Plenty of fans would rather endure a bad season with Mayfield than have Watson under center, and that reality sits outside the stat sheet.
So yes, Cleveland has real ammo right now. Watson is playing better, the Browns are winning, and the Buccaneers are stuck at 0-3. But the season is still young, and Mayfield has spent his career showing he’s tough to write off.
In Other News...
Buccaneers Suddenly Face A Bigger Baker Mayfield Problem Than Expected
Baker Mayfields thumb injury has turned into a much bigger issue for the Buccaneers than a short-term scare. The veteran quarterback suffered a dislocated thumb and is expected to miss multiple games, with his return hinging on how quickly he regains grip strength. For Tampa Bay, the timing is especially tricky because Mayfield had been in the middle of another season as the teams starter after appearing in three games so far.
The immediate answer is rookie Jalon Daniels, who has been named the backup and will start while Mayfield is out. It puts an abrupt spotlight on Tampa Bays quarterback depth and raises the stakes around how the offense functions without the player the Buccaneers signed to a multi-year deal. The bigger question now is not just who starts next, but how long the team has to live without Mayfield and what kind of shape he is in when he finally returns. [Read more 🡒]
Packers Fan Goes Viral For A Gameday Moment Bucs Fans Pounced On
A gameday photo from the Packers-Buccaneers matchup quickly took on a life of its own, with a Green Bay fan in a cheese-themed outfit drawing plenty of attention on social media. Buccaneers fans, already tuned into a rough start for their own team, jumped on the image and helped turn a random moment from the stands into one of the evenings louder online talking points.
It fit the mood around Tampa Bay, where the Bucs came in at 0-3 and were turning to undrafted rookie Jalon Daniels at quarterback because of Baker Mayfields injury. Green Bay arrived at 1-2, but the game was about more than the records for Tampa Bay supporters, who had little patience to spare and plenty of time to notice, and react to, anything that stood out. [Read more 🡒]
Todd Bowles Just Became The Center Of Tampa Bay's Biggest Debate
The Buccaneers slow start has pushed Todd Bowles into the middle of a conversation nobody in Tampa Bay wanted to have this early. At 0-4, with a 3-12 record stretching back to last season, the losses are piling up fast enough to turn every miscue into a referendum on direction, execution and leadership. Bowles stepped to the podium after the latest setback and owned the mess, taking responsibility while insisting he still believes he can guide the team out of it.
Bowles has handled the public side of the slump the way a veteran coach usually does, but the frustration around the team is only growing because so many of the defeats have stayed within reach. Close games tend to sharpen the focus on the head coach, and if the Buccaneers keep coming up short in those spots, the accountability debate will only get louder. For now, Bowles is asking for patience, even as the results make that a harder sell by the week. [Read more 🡒]