Syracuse’s trip to Madison Square Garden gave Gerry McNamara exactly the kind of early read he needed.
Against ranked St. John’s, the Orange had stretches that looked competitive and even promising.
They led at halftime, they were efficient in the first 20 minutes, and for a while they did enough in the paint to keep the game on their terms. But the second half told a very different story, and by the end of it Syracuse was staring at a 79-62 loss - its second straight defeat and second loss of the season.
The biggest swing came after the break. Syracuse’s first-half shooting was strong, as the Orange hit 58% from the field and held St.
John’s to 33 points before halftime. That cushion didn’t last.
Rick Pitino’s halftime message clearly landed, and the Red Storm came out rolling.
Turnovers were the killer. Syracuse finished with 21, and St.
John’s turned those mistakes into 32 points. That kind of margin is hard to survive against a top defense, and the Orange simply couldn’t keep pace for 40 minutes.
The shooting numbers followed the same downward path. Syracuse dropped to 33% from the field in the second half, and after a solid three-point showing against Indiana, the Orange made only four threes in this game. That kind of inconsistency is a problem if the goal is to build an identity that holds up over the course of the season.
The other issue is less about one game and more about the shape of the roster: who is the guy? Aiden Tobiason was supposed to be that answer, but his hamstring injury changed the equation.
Sadiq White and Gavin Doty have had to absorb more of the load, and while White has been scoring well, Doty has struggled to adjust to the high-major level. He scored big against New Haven and Central Connecticut, but he managed only seven combined points against Indiana and St.
John’s while shooting 3-for-15 in those two games.
Kiyan Anthony has given Syracuse useful production off the bench, but the Orange still need another starter to emerge. Right now, that missing piece is hard to ignore, and it’s part of why this team is still searching for the right formula against elite competition.
In Other News...
Fran Brown Just Sent A Strong Syracuse Message On Steve Angeli
Fran Brown used his Monday update to keep Syracuses momentum pointed forward after the 34-31 win over NC State, and there was plenty to unpack beyond the scoreboard. He touched on Calvin Russells expected return in 2027, praised linebacker Chris DAppalonia for fighting through a hand injury to make a key play, and shifted quickly to the next challenge on the schedule with Boston College and quarterback Mason Mackenzie in mind.
Brown also offered a clear read on Steve Angelis place in the program, signaling confidence that the quarterback will remain part of Syracuses plans. For a team trying to build on a gritty conference win, that kind of message matters, especially with the Orange looking to steady the offense and keep the roster picture from becoming a weekly distraction. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Faces A Defining Steve Angeli Decision For 2027
Steve Angeli has given Syracuse plenty to like since taking over as the teams quarterback, steering several game-winning drives and helping the Orange to a 7-4 mark in his starts. Fran Brown has been open about valuing Angelis competitiveness, and there is no question the quarterback has brought stability to a position that can define a programs trajectory from one season to the next.
The harder part is deciding whether that stability is enough for where Syracuse wants to go next. Brown has to weigh Angelis willingness to keep competing, what it would take to keep him in the fold financially, and whether the Orange can identify a clear upgrade as they try to move closer to College Football Playoff contention. For a coach trying to push the program forward, this is less about what Angeli has already done than whether his ceiling matches the standard Syracuse is aiming for in 2027. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Has A Frontcourt Problem Gerry McNamara Needs Solved Fast
Syracuse has shown enough early to suggest it can hang with quality opponents, but the 2-2 start also makes clear how much work still needs to be done. Losses to Indiana and St. Johns exposed the same issue in different ways: the Orange can play stretches that look competitive and organized, then fade when the game turns physical and the possessions get messy. For a team trying to build momentum, that kind of unevenness is hard to ignore.
The biggest concern right now sits in the frontcourt, where rebounding has become a real problem and the big men have not provided the steady presence the Orange need. Gerry McNamara does not have much time to wait for that to sort itself out, especially with Cornell coming next and another chance to show the early-season issues are fixable. If Syracuse is going to stabilize, it needs its size to start matching its effort. [Read more 🡒]
