Syracuse may be back in the same uncomfortable spot it found itself in a week ago: waiting to see which quarterback is actually available.
Malachi Nelson, who came into Saturday’s loss to Louisville already dealing with bruised ribs, did not finish the game after suffering a right foot injury. He had to leave with Syracuse still searching for answers, and once again Danny Lauter was the one summoned to close things out.
Nelson finished with 315 passing yards, two touchdowns and three turnovers before exiting. He appeared to reaggravate the rib issue before heading out, then walked to the tunnel after the game wearing a protective boot on his right foot.
“It was a couple different things,” said head coach Fran Brown when asked about Nelson after the game. “It was like leg, shoulder.
Something like that. See how that goes.
We’ll get to it later.”
The Orange’s final drive with Lauter at quarterback never really got off the ground. With no timeouts left, Syracuse opened with an Ahmad Miller handoff that gained 3 yards.
Three plays later, it went back to Miller for 2 more. Then, after four more plays, Syracuse faced 4th-and-1 and again handed it to Miller.
The result was a turnover on downs and the end of the game.
Lauter also saw action in last week’s game against Virginia, when he helped Syracuse score eight points. Against Louisville, he finished 3-of-5 passing for 24 yards.
Brown made it clear Syracuse was trying to set Lauter up as best it could, even if the situation wasn’t ideal.
“I tried to make sure [Lauter] could, kind of, have everything set,” Brown said. “Especially for a two-minute again. He was in it last week but just being able to do a two-minute with, I hate it to say it that way, but it’s our fourth-string quarterback.”
Brown added that Lauter does not get many reps with Syracuse’s starters, but said he thought the quarterback handled Saturday night well.
What makes this even murkier is that the quarterbacks ahead of Lauter are still very much up in the air. Nelson had to work his way back to practice later in the week just to be available against Louisville.
Steve Angeli practiced early in the week but was ultimately ruled out. Amari Odom’s status remains uncertain.
“Whoever [is] there, we’re gonna go out and compete as hard as we can,” Brown said. “I just want the best player to be there. And if Steve and Amari do come back, they’re still gonna compete with Malachi because he’s doing a good job, for the most part.”
Nelson’s night followed a pattern Syracuse has seen before. He’s delivered strong first halves, including a 17-7 halftime lead over Virginia last week. Against Louisville, he helped the Orange put up 23 first-half points while throwing for 218 yards and two touchdowns on 70% passing.
The second half, though, turned ugly. Nelson committed three turnovers after halftime, and Syracuse managed only three points in that stretch. Last week was different only in the details: Nelson stayed in the game, but Syracuse was shut out with him at quarterback in the second half, and the Orange were helped by multiple dropped interceptions.
“We’ve just got to make better decisions,” Brown said. “Them as players, us as coaches.
It’s a mixture of everything. Let’s make sure we put each other in a good space.”
The turnover issues have not been limited to Nelson. Angeli threw five interceptions in three games and ranked among the leaders in turnover-worthy plays. Odom helped Syracuse to its only FBS win since Sept. 20, 2025, at Connecticut, but he also threw two costly interceptions in that game, including one that came on a miscommunication with freshman wide receiver Calvin Russell III.
Now Syracuse may be headed toward a stretch where Lauter, freshman Zaid Lott and sophomore Rich Belin are the only quarterbacks available, none of whom has started an FBS game. That would be a tough assignment against North Carolina, which owns a top-five scoring defense in the ACC.
In Other News...
Syracuse Wasted Too Much In Another Loss Fans Saw Coming
Syracuse had enough offense to hang around with Louisville, even outgaining the Cardinals in total yards, but the Orange could not get out of their own way in another ACC loss that felt all too familiar. A series of turnovers and mistakes, including multiple interceptions from quarterback Malachi Nelson, undercut the kind of production that usually should have been enough to keep a conference game competitive.
The defense did not make the early situation any easier, either, as Louisville moved the ball freely in the first half and kept extending drives on third down. By the end of the 34-26 defeat, Syracuse was left with the same troubling pattern that has followed it through this ACC skid, good stretches undone by the sort of breakdowns that make every missed chance feel even bigger. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Keeps Sliding As One Orange Star Carries An Unsteady Offense
Syracuses trip to Louisville was another reminder of how thin the margin has become for an offense trying to keep the Orange afloat. In a 34-26 loss, Syracuse dropped its Atlantic Coast Conference losing streak to 11 games, even as receiver Umari Hatcher turned in a huge day with 224 receiving yards and quarterback Malachi Nelson pushed through a recent collarbone injury to stay on the field.
Louisville, meanwhile, got past a slow start from quarterback Lincoln Kienholz and eventually found enough rhythm to finish the job. For Syracuse, the bigger issue was familiar: one star production night was not enough to cover for an unsteady offense, and the frustration keeps building as the conference slide stretches on. [Read more 🡒]
Calvin Russells Breakthrough Became A Painful Syracuse Lesson
Calvin Russell IIIs first career touchdown against Louisville should have been one of those breakthrough moments Syracuse could build around. Less than seven months after Achilles tendon surgery, the wide receiver gave the Orange a jolt with a scoring play that showed how far he has come, only for the celebration to turn costly when he was flagged 15 yards for unsportsmanlike conduct after throwing the football into the stands.
That penalty helped set up a missed extra point in a game Syracuse ultimately lost, turning Russells feel-good moment into a painful reminder of how thin the margin can be. Fran Brown has already addressed the issue with Russell, stressing discipline, and it fit a broader problem for the Orange, who continue to battle penalties at inopportune times. [Read more 🡒]