The NCAA has taken the next step in Amarri Monroe’s eligibility fight, filing an appeal Thursday in the 4th Department Appellate Division of New York State.
That filing came on the final day of the 30-day window that opened after Onondaga County State Supreme Court Judge Jean Marie Westlake issued an injunction against the NCAA. That order allowed Monroe to keep playing while he challenges the NCAA’s new 5-in-5 eligibility rule.
For now, nothing changes on the floor. The injunction remains in place, which means the NCAA cannot enforce its eligibility rules against Monroe or Syracuse while the case moves through court. Monroe’s status is unchanged by the appeal, and he is expected to be available tonight when Syracuse faces Central Connecticut State.
The 6-foot-7 forward already appeared in Syracuse’s season opener Monday, finishing with five points in nine minutes during the Orange’s 74-58 win over New Haven.
What happens next is the key question. In similar eligibility disputes, the NCAA has followed an appeal by asking the court to stay the lower court’s injunction.
If that request is granted, Monroe would become ineligible while the case continues. If the Appellate Division turns down the stay, he would remain eligible.
The case is not expected to be resolved before the end of the basketball season. Discovery, depositions and the schedules of the court, the judge and both legal teams make that unlikely.
Monroe is being represented by the local law firm Newman and Lickstein, while the NCAA’s legal team is based in Albany.
Monroe, 23, spoke with Syracuse.com earlier this month after Westlake issued the injunction that lets him play. He is seeking eligibility under the NCAA’s new 5-in-5 rule, which gives athletes five years to play five seasons. The NCAA did not extend that ruling to players like Monroe, who graduated high school with the 2022 class.
In Other News...
Syracuse Backcourt Depth Takes An Early Hit At The Worst Time
Syracuses backcourt rotation is already being tested before the season can really settle in. Guard Aiden Tobiason will miss the upcoming game against Central Connecticut State after suffering a hamstring strain in an exhibition, leaving the Orange to adjust without the junior transfer from Temple. He arrived with three years of eligibility remaining and was expected to be part of the group helping stabilize the perimeter.
The timing is less than ideal for a team still sorting out its depth and roles. With Tobiason sidelined, Syracuse will need other guards and wings to absorb the minutes and keep the offense moving against a matchup that now comes with a little more uncertainty than planned. For an early-season roster trying to build rhythm, even a short absence can ripple through the whole backcourt. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Has A Real Shot To Expose Clemsons Biggest Weakness
Syracuse heads into its matchup with Clemson coming off a win over SMU, and the timing could hardly be better for a program looking to make a statement. The Orange are set up to test a Tigers team that has not looked like its usual self on offense this season, while Syracuse has reasons to feel better about its own chances after showing progress on both sides of the ball.
The key for Syracuse is straightforward: pressure Clemsons quarterback and keep building on the more confident play it has gotten under center. If the Orange can turn that into another strong home performance, they would not only put Clemsons offensive issues under a brighter spotlight, but also have a chance to do something Syracuse has not done against the Tigers before - beat them in back-to-back meetings. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Heads Into Clemson With One Major Defensive Concern
Syracuse heads into its matchup at Clemson carrying a familiar late-week uncertainty, with several key players sitting on the injury report as the Orange try to firm up both sides of the ball before a difficult road test. Quarterback Steve Angeli, defensive pieces Kahlil Stewart and Tunmise Adeleye, and a handful of others are all listed as questionable or probable, leaving the Orange with some important decisions to monitor right up to kickoff.
Malachi Nelson is trending in the right direction, but he remains doubtful, which keeps the quarterback picture from fully settling just yet. Clemson has its own injury issues to manage, with starters Elyjah Thurmon, Harris Sewell and Gideon Davidson ruled out and wide receiver Tyler Brown questionable, but Syracuses concern is more immediate on defense, where availability could shape how the Orange try to handle one of the ACCs tougher road environments. [Read more 🡒]