Syracuse’s 2-2 start doesn’t tell the whole story, and Sunday night at Madison Square Garden made that clear in a hurry. For one half, the Orange looked more than capable of hanging with No.
13 St. John’s, carrying a 33-30 lead into the break in front of 16,431 fans.
Then the Red Storm turned up the pressure after halftime, Syracuse lost its grip, and a game that felt there for the taking slipped away in a 17-point defeat.
The second half was where everything broke open. St.
John’s opened with a 16-0 burst, Syracuse missed 11 straight shots, and the Orange finished with 21 turnovers. That kind of collapse doesn’t just show up in the final margin - it reshapes the rotation.
With a three-game homestand at the JMA Wireless Dome coming before ACC play draws closer, the box score offered a pretty blunt message about who is earning trust and who is sliding.
At the top of that list was Anthony, who looked ready for the spotlight from the jump. The sophomore guard led Syracuse with 17 points on 7-of-12 shooting, added four assists and didn’t turn it over once in 28 minutes off the bench.
He had 10 points by halftime to help the Orange stay in front, then chipped in seven more after the break while St. John’s was suffocating nearly everyone else with its pressure.
Anthony has now led Syracuse in scoring in three of its first four games, and it’s getting harder to think of him as just a sixth man. Whether Gerry McNamara moves him into the starting five on Wednesday or keeps him in that bench role, the offense has looked cleanest when the ball is in his hands.
Amarri Monroe also made the most of his minutes. In 21 minutes, he posted 12 points on 5-of-6 shooting, hit 2-of-3 from 3-point range, and added three rebounds, three steals, two assists and a block.
He was especially important once St. John’s started rolling, scoring 10 of his points after halftime and helping spark transition chances with his active defense.
The bench production gap was impossible to ignore. Syracuse’s reserves outscored St.
John’s bench 29-7, and Monroe’s two-way impact stood out against a starting group that never found the same rhythm. He made a strong case for a bigger workload, maybe even 25-plus minutes a night.
On the other end of the spectrum, Donnie Doty had another rough night. After a quiet outing in Indianapolis, the transfer managed just two points on 1-of-8 shooting against St.
John’s, including 0-for-4 from deep. He played 15 minutes, finished without an assist and committed three turnovers, spending most of the game on the bench.
There’s still some room for patience there. Moving from Siena to high-major competition is a real adjustment, and Doty’s rebounding early in the season has shown he can help in ways that don’t depend on scoring.
But Syracuse needs more than brief flashes from a veteran starter, especially with tougher nonconference games still ahead. Wednesday’s home matchup with Cornell gives him a chance to get back on track.
Freshman guard Moesch also had a difficult night after being inserted into the starting lineup for the first time this season. He finished with a team-high nine rebounds and five assists in 33 minutes, but his nine turnovers - seven of them before halftime - repeatedly fueled St.
John’s transition game. His shooting was off too, as he went 3-of-11 overall and 1-of-7 from 3-point range.
That kind of learning curve against a top-15 opponent is one thing, especially after he had looked sharp against Indiana. But nine turnovers from the point-of-attack spot is too many, and his hold on a starting role appears uncertain once the roster is fully healthy again.
In Other News...
Syracuse Just Exposed A Backcourt Problem It Cant Ignore
Syracuse had given itself a real chance at halftime against No. 13 St. Johns, carrying a three-point edge into the break before the game flipped hard in the second half. The Orange were outscored 49-29 after halftime and left Madison Square Garden with a 79-62 loss, a result that felt less like a single bad stretch and more like a warning sign for a backcourt still trying to find its footing.
The turnover numbers told the story as much as the scoreboard did, with Syracuse coughing it up 21 times and watching St. Johns turn those mistakes into a 32-19 edge in points off turnovers. At 2-2, the Orange are already staring at a problem they cannot keep papering over, especially with junior guard Aiden Tobiason still working his way back from injury and the guard rotation under pressure to stabilize fast. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Heads To Boston College With A Familiar Problem Still Looming
Syracuse heads into its final road game at Boston College with a 3-1 mark in the back half of the season, and the focus inside the program remains on keeping the attention on the next snap rather than the noise around it. Dino Babers said the Orange are trying to stay locked in on the matchup ahead, even as transfer portal chatter continues to hover around college football and around this roster in particular.
One bright spot from the recent win over NC State was Calvin Russell III, who was named ACC Receiver and Rookie of the Week after his performance. Babers also confirmed Russell is expected back next season, a notable piece of good news for a Syracuse offense that has been trying to build momentum while sorting through the usual end-of-year uncertainty. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Just Got A New NFL Selling Point In Tommy DeVito
Tommy DeVito is suddenly in line for a much bigger role in New England after Drake Maye suffered a fractured ankle and was ruled out indefinitely. DeVito handled most of the recent game in relief, going 12 for 24 for 81 yards with a touchdown and an interception, and now the Patriots have no trade options left after the deadline to bring in outside help.
For Syracuse, the development offers a fresh NFL talking point around one of its own. DeVito may have entered the season as a backup, but with the Patriots short on alternatives, he looks like the starter for the foreseeable future, giving the Orange another pro quarterback to point to in recruiting and in the broader pitch about what Syracuse can produce at the position. [Read more 🡒]
