Syracuse will have Amarri Monroe available when the Orange open the season against New Haven on Nov. 2 after the transfer forward won a preliminary injunction in his lawsuit against the NCAA, syracuse.com’s Mike Waters reported Tuesday.
The ruling came after Monroe’s preliminary hearing before Onondaga County Supreme Court judge Jean Marie Westlake. It clears the way for him to suit up for Syracuse while the case continues.
Monroe first filed the lawsuit on Aug. 31, seeking a fifth year of eligibility. Before that, he had been part of a class-action case in Colorado that briefly helped him and other athletes in the class of 2022 through a temporary restraining order. A federal appeals court later reversed that outcome, which pushed Monroe to take his case to Onondaga County Supreme Court.
At the center of the dispute is the NCAA’s new rule giving all athletes five years after college enrollment. Monroe’s complaint said the association’s transition provisions shut out him and others in class of 2022 from using that rule.
“The NCAA continues to specifically and arbitrarily exclude him and similarly situated members of class of 2022 from the ability to utilize the new NCAA rules,” the complaint reads.
The filing, made by Steven Eychner of Newman & Lickstein, called that exclusion “arbitrary and capricious.” Monroe’s side argued that because he played only four seasons in four years and has not yet turned 24, he should be allowed to take advantage of the new rule. The NCAA countered that he had already used the four years of eligibility he was originally granted, so he could not now claim a fifth.
Monroe arrived at Syracuse on Aug. 4 after four seasons between Wofford and Quinnipiac. His most productive stretch came with the Bobcats, where he averaged 15.5 points and 8.1 rebounds across 96 games over his last three seasons. He was a three-time all-conference selection and the Metro Atlantic Athletic Player of the Year for 2024-25.
His first year at Wofford was much rougher. Head coach Jay McAuley was dismissed nine games into the 2022-23 season, reportedly because of violations tied to overworking players, and associate head coach Dwight Perry took over.
Monroe started 11 of his 22 games that season, averaged 3.6 points per game, and did not play for the Terriers after their Feb. 4, 2023 game against Furman. After his senior season, Quinnipiac reportedly filed a “Season-of-Competition Waiver” on his behalf in hopes of gaining an extra year because of that turbulent 2022-23 campaign.
The NCAA turned that request down. An appeal was later denied in July, setting up Monroe’s lawsuit.
During a 90-minute hearing on Sept. 17, Monroe’s attorneys and NCAA lawyer Kevin Cannizzaro argued the case before Westlake.
“I cannot presently be placed on Syracuse’s basketball roster or compete for Syracuse,” Monroe wrote in a signed affidavit filed with his complaint. “That prevents me from participating in Syracuse’s basketball program on the same terms as the other members of the team.”
Westlake’s ruling changes that for now.
In Other News...
Syracuse Fans Have A Real Reason To Watch The ACC Split
The ACCs annual Tipoff in Charlotte had the usual preseason buzz for both the mens and womens basketball sides, but the leagues biggest conversation was happening off the court. Commissioner Jim Phillips spent part of the day fielding questions about the Protect College Sports Act of 2026, a proposal that could reshape how conferences operate and how schools think about their future.
For Syracuse fans, the real intrigue is in the unease around conference realignment. Phillips said four of the leagues 18 school presidents have concerns about portions of the bill tied to that issue, even as the ACC continues to point to rising TV ratings and a healthier financial picture, with revenue distributions expected to approach $1 billion for the first time. For a league long under pressure to prove its stability, those competing forces make the next stretch worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Faces A Growing Debate After That UConn Escape
Syracuses escape against UConn did more than preserve a win in the moment. It also set off the usual ripple effect that follows a shaky result this early in the season, with the Orange moving through several college football ranking systems as ESPNs SP+, CBS Sports, The Athletic and College Football News all adjusted their views of the team after a game that was far closer than it had any business being.
There was at least some good news to offset the uneasiness, with Tylik Hill and Umari Hatcher both picking up ACC weekly honors. Even so, the broader conversation around Syracuse now feels less about the scoreboard from that night and more about what it says moving forward, especially with a full slate of ACC results around the league and Week 6 already on deck. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Just Got A Timely Boost From Two Breakout Playmakers
Syracuse needed something to stabilize an uneven start, and it got exactly that in overtime against UConn. The Orange escaped with a 42-41 win to climb back to .500, with Amari Odom making his first start of the season and immediately giving the offense a different look by throwing for more than 300 yards and accounting for six total touchdowns.
Umari Hatcher and Tylik Hill were right there with him in the push to the finish, and both were rewarded afterward as ACC Offensive Players of the Week. For a Syracuse team trying to build momentum and find more consistency, the emergence of those playmakers gives the offense a much-needed jolt, even if the bigger question is whether it can carry over from one high-scoring escape into the weeks ahead. [Read more 🡒]