The College Football Playoff is headed toward 24 teams in 2027, and for the TNIAAM crew, that news landed with a mix of frustration, skepticism and a little bit of hard truth about where the sport is going.
Kevin didn’t dance around it. He said he’s “Not a fan of it,” though not simply because the bracket gets bigger.
For him, the real issue is bigger than the playoff itself: conferences have grown too large for football to feel right. He said he’d be more open to expansion if the sport went back to 9/10-team leagues where everyone played each other, but he doesn’t see that happening.
And in a 24-team field, he asked whether fans really need to see four 8-4 Big Ten teams get in.
Dom’s reaction was more about the slippery slope. In his view, the complaints won’t stop at 24.
He pointed out that even in a 12-team format, teams sitting just outside the cutoff will feel wronged. With 24, he thinks that tension only gets louder, especially if plenty of teams have similar résumés and believe they belong.
He said he was comfortable with 12 because it struck a balance between expansion and having “a solid collection of teams who actually *deserve to compete for the national championship.” Still, he’s not convinced 24 is the end of the line, wondering whether 30 or 32 teams could be next.
Mike went even harder. He said, “There are few times that I’ll say I “hate” something.
This is one of those times.” His biggest concern is what happens to the regular season when so many more teams have a path in.
In his view, too many games will lose meaning, the magic of the upset will fade, and big programs may start wondering what their huge stadiums look like when they’re emptier than usual. He also suggested that if television ratings are the real driver, then the Power 4 might as well stop playing non-conference games.
The roundtable also dug into the less obvious fallout. Kevin said one consequence could be a drop in regular-season fan interest, especially since conference championship games already struggle at times to draw strong crowds. If those games can’t always hold attention, he questioned why fans should keep investing the same time and money into a regular season that matters less.
Dom flagged the calendar as another mess waiting to happen. If the playoff stretches the season, he said the transfer portal timeline would become even more chaotic than it already is.
Mike looked ahead to the bowl system and didn’t like its chances. He said bowls could “go outright extinct if/when this takes place.” Outside of the former New Year’s Six games, he doesn’t see many surviving after 12 more teams are pulled into the playoff mix, though he wondered if niche bowls like Hawai’i and the Sun Bowl might hang on.
Asked what it means for Syracuse, all three saw opportunity, even if they didn’t exactly sound thrilled about the broader setup. Kevin said it’s clearly a positive for a program like Syracuse because there would simply be more openings for teams outside the SEC and Big Ten to get into the field. He also suggested that more access could help drive attendance and interest, which is part of why plenty of schools would support the change.
Dom agreed that the door gets wider for a Syracuse-type team, especially if the Orange can put together another season like 2018 or 2024. But he also acknowledged that the qualification bar would be much lower, and he’s not sure how fans will feel about that.
Mike was the skeptic in the group on that front too. He said he’s doubtful the move would help the ACC or Big 12 much at all, arguing that the same strength-of-schedule debates that already favor certain 9-3 Big Ten and SEC teams would simply be used to push 8-4 teams over other one-loss programs. Even if the playoff stops being a one-bid setup for those leagues, he questioned whether getting one or two teams in is really that big a leap.
When it came to an ideal setup, the group split into different visions. Kevin laid out the most structural overhaul.
He’d split the P4 into two divisions, with teams playing everyone in their division. In his version, there would be eight divisions of nine schools each, meaning 72 P4 teams total.
Schools would play eight league games, two non-conference games and an FCS exhibition. Every division winner would get an automatic CFP bid, giving eight spots right away.
He’d add the top two G6 champions and six at-large teams. He also said play-in games for the final six spots would be fine, and if a play-in team reached the title game, it would top out at a 16-game season.
Dom’s ideal is simpler: a 16-team playoff, and then no more expansion after that. His format would include the Power 4 conference champions and runners-up, which he said would protect conference championship games from becoming a reason to leave a team out.
From there, he’d be open to either two G6 bids and six at-large spots or one G6 bid and seven at-large. He doesn’t want byes for top seeds, and he wouldn’t re-seed the bracket either.
In Other News...
Syracuses New-Look Roster Faces An Early Test Fans Will Track
The preseason AP top-25 is out, and Syracuse was left on the outside looking in as the Orange begin a season that already has the feel of a measuring stick year. With a revamped roster and some changes on the sideline, there is still plenty for this group to prove, and the schedule is not offering much time to settle in before the scrutiny ramps up.
Duke, Virginia, Louisville and Miami all sit among the teams Syracuse is slated to face, with several of those opponents either ranked or drawing votes in the preseason poll. For a program trying to move past recent struggles and establish a new identity, those early ACC games will do more than test the Orange - they should give a clearer picture of how quickly the new-look roster can come together. [Read more 🡒]
Calvin Russell Gives Syracuse Fans A New Reason For Optimism
Calvin Russells return from an Achilles injury gave Syracuse something it has been searching for on offense: a young receiver who looked ready to handle a bigger role right away. The freshman wideout made his mark against Louisville with six catches for 53 yards and his first touchdown, giving the Orange a needed spark while showing the kind of reliability that can change how defenses account for the passing game.
The touchdown came with a little extra drama, too, as Russell picked up a 15-yard penalty for his celebration, a reminder that the enthusiasm he brought to the moment was matched by the concern it created on the sideline. Fran Brown made clear he noticed the penalty, even as he understood why the play meant so much, and Syracuse now has a new reason to be intrigued by what Russell can become once he settles fully into the offense. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Faces Another Tough Home Test As Frustration Keeps Building
Syracuses latest step through ACC play was another hard one to absorb, with the Orange falling to Louisville and extending their conference losing streak to 11 straight games. The setback left them at 2-4 overall and still searching for their first league win, a familiar and frustrating spot for a team trying to keep its season from slipping further off course.
The schedule does not offer much breathing room. Syracuse heads to North Carolina next, then returns home for SMU on Oct. 31 at noon, a matchup that already looks like another stern test. SMU is 5-1 and expected to handle California this week, which only adds to the sense that the Orange will need to find answers quickly before another difficult opponent comes to town. [Read more 🡒]