Syracuse heads into Saturday night with the same uneasy question that has hung over so much of this season: who is going to play quarterback?
That uncertainty sits on top of a longer slump that has only made the rest of the week feel heavier. The Orange are trying to stop a 10-game losing streak in ACC play and an 11-game skid against Power-Four opponents, and now they get one of the nation’s most productive offenses when Louisville comes to the JMA Wireless Dome.
The quarterback picture remains cloudy. Steve Angeli (Achilles) and Malachi Nelson (chest) are both questionable, while Amari Odom (shoulder) has been ruled out.
Tight end Daunte Bacheyie said Angeli, Danny Lauter and Zaid Lott took the most reps in Tuesday’s practice. Sophomore Rich Belin has also continued to travel with the team, even after being relieved of his holding duties on special teams.
If Syracuse can get Angeli or Nelson back, that would at least give the Orange a familiar hand under center. Angeli is 4-3 as a starter at Syracuse and has thrown for 2,048 yards, 14 touchdowns and seven interceptions while completing 60% of his passes.
He is 1-3 against Power Four teams. Nelson, in his first start for the Orange last weekend, went 16-of-29 for 217 yards and a touchdown.
The other options are far less proven. Lauter never played an FBS opponent while at Georgetown, and Lott and Belin have never taken a college snap at quarterback.
Louisville, meanwhile, brings a far more established identity on offense. The Cardinals rank 16th nationally in scoring offense, 36th in passing offense and 11th in rushing offense. Quarterback Lincoln Keinholz is in the mix for second-team All-ACC honors, and Louisville’s backfield is considered one of the ACC’s strongest, with only Florida State boasting a comparable running backs room.
The issue for Louisville has been on the other side of the ball. The Cardinals rank 15th among 17 ACC teams in scoring defense, 12th in rushing defense and 16th in passing defense.
Still, there is one defender Syracuse has to account for: Clev Lubin. According to Pro Football Focus, he is the ACC’s fifth-best pass rusher, leads the league with 26 pressures and has five sacks.
His pass rush win rate of 21.6% ranks second in the ACC among 50 qualified players, and he can line up over Syracuse right tackle Kam Pringle and wreck the Orange passing game.
Syracuse’s defense should at least feel somewhat familiar with Louisville’s style after last week. The Orange just dealt with a Virginia team that wanted to run the football, and that showed up in the numbers. Syracuse finished that game with three linebackers who posted a defensive grade of at least 70 on 20 or more snaps, according to PFF.
Jamie Tremble logged a season-high 38 snaps and finished with a pass-rush grade of 77. Chris D’Appolonia posted a tackling grade of 78.8, and Zyian Moultrie-Goddard was Syracuse’s second-highest graded defender overall. Moultrie-Goddard and Tremble have the best run-defense grades among Syracuse linebackers with at least 30 snaps defending the run.
That group could be even more important if Antoine Deslauriers remains limited. He is questionable again this week, and Syracuse may be leaning on D’Appolonia, Tremble and Moultrie-Goddard for most of the linebacker work against Louisville. Deslauriers owns the second-worst run grade among Syracuse linebackers this season at 59.5, but he also has the team’s best coverage grade, which should keep him in the mix on third downs.
There are two Syracuse players who continue to flash like high-end pros. Wide receiver Umari Hatcher and defensive tackle Rashard Perry are both posting numbers that put them among the best in the country.
Hatcher’s 112 receiving yards per game rank eighth in the FBS and second in the ACC behind Heisman Trophy candidate Malachi Toney. Perry owns an overall PFF grade of 89.1, second among all defensive tackles with at least 160 snaps.
His tackling grade ranks 14th out of 267, and his pass rush grade is 24th.
Hatcher’s season has been especially impressive given the path he took to get here. He missed all of last season, nearly transferred and has still managed to put up a 100-yard game with three different starting quarterbacks this year.
The problem for Syracuse has been what happens after halftime. Against FBS opponents, the Orange are averaging just 4.25 second-half points per game and being outscored by 10.25 points on average. The pattern has been ugly: California outscored Syracuse 14-6 in the second half, Pittsburgh won the second half 10-3, Connecticut forced overtime with a 20-7 second half, and Virginia won the second half 21-8.
The offense has simply gone cold. Syracuse has run 24 second-half drives against its four FBS opponents, and seven have ended in interceptions, four in turnovers on downs, four in missed field goals and six in punts. Only three of those 24 drives produced points.
The injury list is not helping. Along with Angeli, Nelson and Deslauriers, Syracuse has listed kicker Tripp Woody (hamstring) and center Joe Cruz (ankle) as questionable.
Woody and freshman Shay Barker have been part of a kicking operation that has been the worst in the FBS. Cruz, meanwhile, has had a rough stretch at center, was benched for Kahlil Stewart at UConn and started against Virginia before rolling his ankle late in that game.
Saturday’s game is set for 7:30 p.m. ET on ACC Network. The latest line has Louisville favored, and the published pick is Louisville 38, Syracuse 17.
In Other News...
Gerry McNamara Just Framed Syracuses Rebuild Around One New Reality
Gerry McNamara spent part of a recent public meet-and-greet at Destiny USA doing more than signing autographs. The Syracuse mens basketball coach used the appearance to underline how much the programs rebuild now depends on community partnerships, player development and the kind of off-court support that has become a bigger part of roster building across the sport.
McNamara also made clear that his job no longer stops at coaching the team on the floor. With general manager Greg Fahey, he is involved in both roster management and the business side of the operation, including NIL opportunities for players such as Sadiq White Jr. He also pointed to the grind of getting players ready for pro basketball, stressing the need for accountability and execution as Syracuse tries to set a new standard under a changing model. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuses New Transfer Guard Already Puts The Early Rotation In Question
Aiden Tobiasons first impression in a Syracuse uniform was cut short Tuesday night, and now the Orange have a little more uncertainty in the backcourt as the regular season approaches. Gerry McNamara said the Temple transfer left the exhibition game early with a right leg injury that appears to be a hamstring issue, and the guard is expected to sit out the next exhibition against Siena while he recovers.
The timing matters because Tobiason arrived with starter-level experience and looked like someone who could factor into the early rotation right away. Syracuse is giving him one to two weeks to get back on track, with the focus on having him available for the Nov. 2 season opener against New Haven, but any missed time now only tightens the pressure on the Orange to sort out their guard minutes before games start counting. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Faces A Brutal Test As Familiar Problems Keep Mounting
After a frustrating loss to Virginia, Syracuse gets little time to regroup before welcoming Louisville in a matchup that already looks like a serious gut check. Fran Browns first season has brought the usual learning curve, but this one feels more urgent because the same issues keep surfacing: protection, execution, and a margin for error that seems to shrink by the week.
Louisville brings the kind of rushing attack that can stress a defense for four quarters, so Syracuse has to be sharper at the line and more disciplined in space. The Orange also need a clearer answer at quarterback, cleaner work on special teams, and more from their offensive playmakers if they want to turn a difficult home date into something manageable. [Read more 🡒]