JJ Starling Just Brought Back A Syracuse Frustration Fans Know Too Well

JJ Starling's viral fame from a disastrous free throw attempt underscores his ongoing battle with shooting inconsistencies since his college career began.

JJ Starling found himself in the spotlight for a brutal reason last week, and the clip spread fast.

The former Syracuse and Baldwinsville standout, now at Buffalo after transferring from Syracuse, missed a free throw so badly that the ball never came close to the rim. Video of the attempt started making the rounds on social media on Wednesday, and the reaction came quickly.

BrickCenter posted the miss and drew 2.2 million views and 11,000 likes in less than a day. Barstool Sports shared it as well, pulling in 392,000 views and 2,600 likes.

Starling wiped his hands on his shirt after the miss. The broadcasters speculated that the ball may have slipped from his hands. Buffalo did not address the shot in its postgame press conference after a 107-65 win over Penn State-Schuylkill.

The clip landed because it fit a larger, uglier pattern. Starling has battled shot issues throughout his college career, especially after a shoulder injury during his freshman season. Former Notre Dame coach Mike Brey said last year that Starling had been a strong shooter during his McDonald’s All-American high school career, but that his form changed after the injury with the Fighting Irish.

His time at Syracuse was defined by awkward-looking mechanics, a hitch at the line and a career that never quite clicked the way the program hoped it would. He never shot better than 32.4 percent from 3-point range with the Orange, and his free-throw numbers got worse each season. Syracuse leaned on him heavily anyway, making him a centerpiece of the program.

By the end of his three years there, the frustration was obvious. He rarely spoke to reporters and often stayed out of the team’s locker room after games.

People around him have pointed to the pressure he carries. “The pressures that kid deals with every day are a lot,” former assistant coach Allen Griffin said last year.

“I know it weighs on him, especially being back home,” his prep school coach Pat Holmes said. “All he wants to do is win. ...

I know JJ’s not one to make excuses, but you can tell the shot’s not the same. I can tell you there’s definitely been moments of frustration.”

At Buffalo, Starling is playing major minutes and averaging 32 per game, along with 6.3 points. But the efficiency problems have followed him there too. He’s shooting 30 percent from the field and 23.1 percent from 3-point range, while his free-throw struggles continue to undercut the athleticism that helps him get downhill and draw contact.

In Other News...

Syracuse Sent A Clear Message About What This Team Wont Excuse

Syracuse got back in the win column with a 91-82 victory over Cornell at the JMA Wireless Dome, nudging its record to 3-2 and giving the Orange a chance to reset after an uneven start. The result had enough positives to matter, with Garwey Dual, Sadiq White and Luke Wilson all offering a glimpse of the locker-room mood afterward, but the bigger takeaway was less about the final score and more about what the group said it still needs to clean up.

The Orange made it clear they are not interested in brushing aside the defensive lapses that showed up against Cornell. The message from the players was centered on getting better on that end and tightening communication as the season moves forward, a reminder that early wins only carry so much weight if the details keep slipping. For Syracuse, the next step is not complicated in theory, even if it is harder in practice: defend better, talk more, and make sure this kind of game becomes the floor rather than the warning sign. [Read more 🡒]

Gerry McNamara Delivered A Boeheim Tribute Syracuse Fans Will Feel

Jim Boeheims presence on the ACC Network broadcast for Syracuses game against Cornell added a familiar layer to an already meaningful night. It was the first time the Hall of Fame coach had worked as a color analyst for a Syracuse game, even though he has been part of the network since late 2023, and for Orange fans it was a reminder of how deeply his voice still hangs over the program.

After the game, Gerry McNamara spoke about Boeheims influence on his own career and the way he thinks about coaching. For Syracuse supporters, those comments carried extra weight because McNamara is now helping carry the program forward while still working in the shadow of the man who defined it for so long, a transition that remains as emotional as it is important. [Read more 🡒]

Syracuse Heads To Boston College With Bowl Hopes On The Line

Syracuse heads into its final road game of the 2026 regular season with plenty still hanging in the balance, traveling to Boston College for an Atlantic Coast Conference matchup that carries real postseason weight. At 5-5 overall, the Orange need one win in their last two games to lock up bowl eligibility, so this trip comes with the kind of late-November urgency that can define a season.

The challenge is made tougher by the injury report, which lists several Syracuse players as out for the game. With the ACC Network carrying the matchup, the Orange will have a chance to handle business away from home and put themselves in position to extend the season, but they will have to do it with a thinner margin for error than they would like. [Read more 🡒]