Forty years after Keith Smart’s baseline jumper broke Syracuse hearts in the NCAA Tournament title game, the two programs meet again with a much different kind of pressure on the line.
This time, it’s not about a championship. It’s about getting back to the NCAA Tournament at all.
Syracuse and Indiana both enter Monday night’s non-conference matchup in Indianapolis at 2-0, though neither has been tested by much yet. Still, for two rebuilding teams trying to climb back into the bracket picture, this one carries real weight.
Syracuse hasn’t been to March Madness since 2021. Indiana’s last trip came in 2023.
The Orange are in the early stages of the Gerry McNamara era, and the roster looks almost entirely remade. McNamara kept only two players from last season’s 15-17 team: Sadiq White Jr. and Kiyan Anthony, the son of Carmelo Anthony.
Anthony has opened the season averaging 15.5 points per game, while White is putting up 11 points and 10 rebounds per game. They’ve been joined by Siena transfer Gavin Doty, who is averaging 16 points, and Slovenian freshman Mark Morano, who is scoring 12.5 points per game and has already knocked down seven 3-pointers.
McNamara has plenty to like about the scoring balance, but what stood out to him after Syracuse’s 102-49 win over Central Connecticut State on Thursday was something much simpler: effort.
His first praise went to Quinnipiac transfer Amarri Monroe for diving on the floor to secure a loose ball, even with Syracuse already up 92-45.
"And you make a play like that? " McNamara said. "Laying it on the line every second, every possession, is who we're going to be, is who we need to be all the time.
Just a hell of a play. Hell of an effort."
Indiana is also in the middle of a roster reset, and Darian DeVries is a year ahead of McNamara in that process. Like Syracuse, the Hoosiers kept only two scholarship players and are leaning heavily on six transfers from high-major programs, who make up their top six.
The early returns have been encouraging. In a 91-57 win over Eastern Illinois last Monday, former Notre Dame point guard Markus Burton scored 19 points and added five assists, while Villanova transfer Bryce Lindsay chipped in 14 points off the bench. Then, in Thursday’s 92-69 win over Bellarmine, Burton was held to two points, but Duke transfer Darren Harris delivered the kind of shooting night Indiana was hoping for.
Harris scored a career-high 23 points in 23 minutes and went 5 of 10 from 3-point range. That’s exactly why the Hoosiers brought him in.
"We've seen it all summer and fall and previously in his high school days," DeVries said. "It was just a matter of time."
Harris had scored in double figures only three times in two seasons as a backup at Duke, but DeVries said the confidence never wavered.
"You're part of a new team and got a new role and you want to do well, and he's a kid that really tries every day to give us what he can give," DeVries said. "He wants to so bad. It was nice to see him have a great night."
In Other News...
Syracuse-St. Johns Just Lost The One Twist Fans Wanted Most
Syracuse heads into Madison Square Garden for a matchup with St. Johns that already carries plenty of intrigue, even before tipoff. The Orange are trying to bounce back from a recent loss, while the Red Storm arrive unbeaten and looking every bit like an early-season team worth watching.
Donnie Freemans absence takes some of the edge off the reunion, at least from a storyline standpoint, since the former Syracuse player who transferred to St. Johns will miss the game with an Achilles injury. Even so, the meeting still has enough juice for Orange fans, with a big-stage setting and a chance to see how Syracuse responds against a hot opponent in a building that tends to magnify everything. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Just Made A Strong Early Impression On A 2028 QB
A game-day visit can tell a recruit plenty, and Maddox Twigg came away from Syracuse with a strong first read. The 2028 quarterback prospect from Morgantown, West Virginia, was on campus for the Clemson game and liked what he saw from the atmosphere, the coaching staff and the people around the program, including punter Jimmy Gregg, with whom he has built a relationship.
Twigg already has multiple college offers, but Syracuse clearly left a mark as he sorts through his early options. For a young quarterback with plenty of time before any decision, those kinds of personal connections and the feel of a big Saturday in the dome can matter just as much as the football itself. [Read more 🡒]
Syracuse Faces A Shooting Concern At The Worst Time Against St. Johns
Syracuse heads into its matchup with St. Johns already dealing with a potential problem on the perimeter, and the timing could hardly be worse. Aiden Tobiason will be out with a hamstring injury, leaving the Orange without one of the guards they were counting on, while freshman Mark Morano is still working through a tweaked ankle and remains uncertain for the game.
The concern is less about just filling minutes and more about where the Orange find reliable shooting if both players are limited or unavailable. Syracuse will need others to shoulder more of the load on the outside, and the matchup with St. Johns now carries an added layer of pressure as the Orange try to sort out who can provide spacing and scoring when it matters most. [Read more 🡒]