Yadier Molina In Another Dugout Would Hit Cardinals Fans Hard

As beloved former players Albert Pujols and Yadier Molina consider managerial roles elsewhere, Cardinals fans grapple with the loyalty and legacy implications of seeing their heroes in the opposing dugout.

St. Louis has a strange kind of offseason anxiety right now, and it has nothing to do with snow or holiday shopping. It’s the idea of Albert Pujols or Yadier Molina wearing a different uniform in a dugout - not as players, but as managers somewhere else.

That was the topic on Cardinal Territory, where Jim Hayes, Lance Lynn and Kyle Gibson dug into how Cardinals fans might react if either franchise icon landed a managerial job outside St. Louis.

At the time of recording, Pujols was being considered for the Astros’ opening before Houston hired Yankees bench coach Brad Ausmus. The larger question, though, still hangs there: how would fans handle seeing number five or number four running another club?

Hayes put the scenario directly to Lynn.

“Albert gets the job as manager of the Astros, do you think Cardinal fans are gonna be really pissed at the Cardinals? Or is that crazy?”

Lynn’s answer was blunt.

“Here’s my opinion,” responded Lynn. “I think if Yadi were to get a job managing in the major leagues somewhere else before, they’d be more pissed about that, and here’s why: Albert has been in other organizations and did go away for 10 years before he came back.

Now, I understand they’re both in that same ballpark because of their greatness to the Cardinals organization and what they did. But Yadi having another major league uniform on, in a managerial spot, I think, will sting a little bit more than Albert.”

He didn’t stop there.

“You’re gonna see people pissed either way. But Yadi managing in the major leagues will sting a little bit more than Albert because he’s never had another major league uniform on.”

That’s a fair read, and it gets at the part Lynn didn’t say out loud: Oli Marmol is already part of the equation. Cardinals fans have soured on the current manager after the team’s playoff drought, and whether that’s fair or not hardly matters at this point. The reaction is what it is.

That’s why the thought of Pujols or Molina somewhere else hits differently. In a winning environment, it probably wouldn’t land nearly as hard. If the Cardinals were piling up division titles and October trips, fans would have a lot less energy to spend worrying about where their legends ended up.

Molina, meanwhile, has remained close to the organization since retirement, working as an instructor for the Cardinals. A promotion to manager would make plenty of sense from a morale standpoint. But if the results don’t follow, the fall could be even sharper than what fans are already living through.

No one questions the respect Molina deserves, and he should absolutely be viewed as a legitimate managerial candidate. But even Whitey Herzog couldn’t fix this roster by himself. Until the Cardinals are better, no name on the bench is going to erase the frustration.

Maybe that reality shapes what Pujols and Molina do next. Maybe it doesn’t. For now, it’s the offseason, and with a lockout coming, there’s time to sit with the possibility a little longer.

In Other News...

Cardinals Could Get A Fascinating Chaim Bloom Reunion Chance

Kristian Campbells name is back in the conversation as Boston weighs whether to move on from the former top prospect, and that could put the Cardinals in an interesting spot. Campbell has struggled to find his footing in the majors on both sides of the ball, and he spent most of 2026 in Triple-A, which has only added to the uncertainty around his role with the Red Sox.

For St. Louis, the appeal is easy to understand. The Cardinals have some familiarity with Campbell, and the recent coaching additions on their staff could make the idea of a reunion more than just a passing thought. The question is whether the upside is worth the financial commitment attached to him, which is the sort of detail that can turn a speculative claim into a much tougher decision. [Read more 🡒]

Two Cardinals Decisions Still Haunt The Franchise After 2011

After the 2011 World Series title, the Cardinals were at a crossroads that looked manageable at the time but has only grown more consequential in hindsight. Tony La Russas retirement forced the organization to make a defining managerial choice, and the ripple effects of that decision have lingered through the years that followed, especially as the club tried to preserve the standard it had set during its championship run.

The other blow came even more directly from the roster, where the loss of Albert Pujols left a void that went beyond production. St. Louis never really replaced what he meant to the clubhouse or the lineup, and the combination of that departure and the managerial gamble helped shape a stretch in which the franchise struggled to sustain its usual footing. [Read more 🡒]

Cardinals Could Use Jimmy Crooks To Fix A Bigger Roster Need

The Cardinals catching picture has already started to take shape this offseason, and it may leave Jimmy Crooks on the outside looking in. St. Louis is committed to rookie Leo Bernal as its starting catcher and sees Pedro Pages as a dependable backup, which creates a crowded path for Crooks despite his strong minor league track record and the fact that he has only a limited major league resume.

For a club trying to address bigger roster needs, that kind of depth can become a trade chip quickly. Crooks is 25 and still carries enough prospect value to draw attention, and the Cardinals have reportedly found that teams are interested in their catching situation. If St. Louis decides to move him, it could be less about giving up on a player and more about using an extra piece to fill a more pressing hole elsewhere. [Read more 🡒]