Victor Scott is back in the big leagues, and the Cardinals are giving him another shot to prove the last month wasn’t a fluke.
That matters because St. Louis has been waiting for Scott to turn center field into a long-term answer, especially with an eye on 2026.
Early on, it looked like he might be on that track. His bunting made him one of the most unusual and entertaining players around, and for a brief stretch, the leap seemed real.
Then came the crash. Scott faded hard enough that the Cardinals had no real choice but to option him to Memphis on June 8 after he had hit .194 with a .534 OPS.
The struggle didn’t stop there. In June and July with Memphis, he hit .215 with a .625 OPS and stole just 10 bases, a disappointing run for a player whose speed is supposed to be part of the appeal.
August, though, at least gave the Cardinals something to hold onto. Scott hit .270 and swiped 13 bases that month, and there’s at least a sliver of hope that the bat may finally be moving in the right direction.
The user STLSports noted on X that Scott changed his batting stance around July 25, and the results followed soon after. That’s not exactly a guarantee, though.
Scott also arrived at spring training with a different stance, and that version never produced lasting results.
Even with the uncertainty, the Cardinals do need something from him offensively. If he can become even a modest threat at the plate, he can still add a different layer to the lineup.
The bigger issue may be whether he can turn back into the kind of baserunner who forces pitchers and catchers to pay attention. In his 61 major league games with St.
Louis in 2026, Scott stole nine bases but was caught four times. That’s the same number of times he was thrown out in 38 steal attempts in 2025, and it points to a player who has not yet fully translated his speed into clean, effective production.
That’s especially notable because stolen bases are slipping again across baseball, according to an article in FanGraphs, after the brief boost that came in 2023 when MLB widened the bases and cut down on pickoff attempts. St.
Louis has gone the other direction. The Cardinals have 87 stolen bases as of Sept. 1 after finishing with 89 in 2025, and a big chunk of that has come from Jordan Walker, who leads the club with a career-high 18 steals.
Even with that, the Cardinals still rank 17th in the majors in stolen bases, and there’s room for more.
Scott is one of the few players on the roster who can realistically change that. If the speed starts showing up again, the Cardinals could add another layer to an offense that already has some juice on the bases. For fans who still dream about “Whiteyball,” that’s the dream scenario.
The path for Scott is also clearer than it might seem. Looking ahead to 2027, assuming there isn’t a lockout, there isn’t much standing in the way of center field reps.
Nathan Church appears to be the main competition. Beyond that, the organization doesn’t have many obvious internal options ready to step in.
Tai Peete and Trevor Condon are still some distance from the majors, and Memphis’ group of Chase Davis, Zach Levenson, Colton Ledbetter and Bligh Madris does not look ready to force the issue.
That leaves Scott in a familiar but important spot: the post-hype sleeper phase, where the promise is still there but the patience is thinning. A breakout like Jordan Walker’s is not the expectation, especially since Scott never carried that kind of bat to begin with. But if he can avoid another major-league stumble, get the bat to an acceptable level and stop second-guessing himself on the bases, he still has a chance to reclaim center field as his own.
In Other News...
Cardinals Are Adding An Overlooked Arm As Bullpen Questions Linger
When active rosters expand, the Cardinals are set to bring up pitching prospect Rincon and catching prospect Leo Bernal, a move that gives the club some added depth as the bullpen continues to draw attention. St. Louis has room to make it happen after releasing Caleb Ferguson and optioning catcher Jimmy Crooks, which leaves an active roster spot open for a position player.
Rincons call-up is the more intriguing one from a pitching standpoint. After eight seasons in the minors, he has settled into a multi-inning relief role and logged 71 1/3 innings with a 4.04 ERA at Triple-A Memphis this season, enough to make him a useful arm as the Cardinals try to stabilize the middle innings without a lot of margin for error. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals May Have A Faster Path In Mind For Rainiel Rodriguez
Rainiel Rodriguez has kept putting his bat on the map at both High-A and Double-A this year, and that kind of offensive progress is exactly why the Cardinals are already thinking beyond where he began. The 19-year-old is still one of the organizations most promising young names, but the club is also weighing how best to get him moving more quickly through a system that has other catching prospects in the pipeline.
Assistant general manager Rob Cerfolio said Rodriguez has already seen some time at first base, and the Cardinals plan to look at more defensive options for him this offseason. It is a familiar kind of development pivot for a bat-first prospect, especially for a team still trying to sort out longer-term answers at third base or first base, and Rodriguezs path may end up being shaped as much by where he can fit defensively as by what he has already shown at the plate. [Read more 🡒]
Cardinals Catch A Dodgers Break They Really Did Not Need
The Dodgers are getting a major boost behind the plate just as the stretch run starts to tighten, with Will Smith and Dalton Rushing both back from the injured list and left-hander Justin Wrobleski also rejoining the club. Los Angeles added infielder Alex Freeland to the active roster as well, while making room by sending outfielder Alek Thomas down and designating catcher Ben Rortvedt for assignment.
For St. Louis, the timing matters because Smith has been one of the most important players in the Dodgers lineup and his return comes after he was limited by a neck injury and sidelined for nearly three months. Any time a contender can restore that kind of bat and stability at catcher, it changes the way an opponent has to game-plan, and the Cardinals now have one more hurdle waiting for them in a series that already had little margin for error. [Read more 🡒]